Lebanon’s productive sectors are often short-changed in favor of tourism, real estate and banking. What’s more, Minister of Industry Vrej Sbounjian commands a paltry budget of LL7.71 billion ($5.14 million). In such an environment the nation’s industrialists need a well-informed fighter holding their corner in the Cabinet. Executive met with the minister to see if he has been up to the task.
The 2012 budget lacked any tangible or creative initiatives to boost Lebanon’s productive sectors. Was this not a failure on your behalf?
We can’t forget previous governments in the past six or seven years couldn’t even pass a budget, so I want to congratulate this government on even having passed a budget. With regards to industry, it is fine, we don’t have any complaints concerning the economy or industry.
Where are we at with the draft law to slash export taxes?
That law has been approved in the Cabinet and I met with [Speaker] Nabih Berri and he promised me it will be in the first parliamentary meeting. That law will mean taxes on all Lebanese products that are exported will be reduced by 50 percent. We pay 15 percent on income tax and profits, but that will be reduced to 7.5 percent.
Can the government afford to lose that revenue?
We don’t look at it from that perspective but rather at how many more jobs we will create and how many more opportunities and investments will come to the country.
One of the biggest disincentives to invest in Lebanon is bad infrastructure. What has happened to the plans to develop industrial zones in Lebanon?
There are lots of industrial zones in Lebanon that you can use. If you want to build a factory or a warehouse to produce or assemble a product you don’t need to go to an industrial zone.
In this government’s mission statement it said new industrial zones would be created…
I’m not saying I don’t want to do it. These are for places where there is no industry in Lebanon. But in a lot of areas there are factories that have been there for years. We cannot ask them to move.
It’s not about moving existing factories but providing the infrastructure to attract investment for new industries…
We are not looking to heavy industries. We are interested in service industries and assembly industries for export to other Arab countries. The investor will take advantage of the 7.5 percent tax rate, plus…
It’s not 7.5 percent yet…
It is 15 percent but it will be 7.5. There is nobody against this law.
If you are not focusing on heavy industry, what efforts are you making to develop high-skilled, light industry within Lebanon?
First of all we have great education and great schools and I would like to encourage…
The problem is that the well-educated and skilled workforce leaves to work elsewhere.
I think the reason of leaving is because the opportunities available in a large economy are more than in a small economy. This is not new. Look at Spain and Italy now and how many people are leaving.
They are going through an economic crisis and there are huge levels of unemployment.
And we are having an economic downturn. It happens.
But once intelligent and skilled young people finish their education, what strategy is there to keep them in Lebanon to help develop its industries?
We have to create the right environment and laws and then leave everyone to be creative themselves.
In your last interview with Executive you said more bilateral agreements were in the pipeline once those with Armenia and Sudan were signed. Are they?
Absolutely, we are looking to have agreements signed with Tunisia and Cyprus very soon.
Why is there no progress on Lebanon’s plans to join the World Trade Organization?
I want to ask you, is the WTO doing well for other countries?
Are you insinuating you are against Lebanon joining the WTO?
I didn’t say I don’t think it is a good idea. With my experience I have learned we have to take into consideration the size of the country and the size of the population. I don’t know all of the details of the WTO but I think that those two issues must be taken into consideration.
What have been the major impacts on Lebanese industry from the Syrian crisis and how has the government responded?
I think the major impact is the fear. People from any country that had a neighbor at war would be worried. People are seeing what is going on and are understandably worried. This is the only major worry so far.
But what about tangible impacts such as increased costs of overland freight?
We have found some ways, such as getting to Iraq going through Tripoli in the north to Turkey and overland from there. As for other countries, for some we are shipping from the Port of Beirut but in many cases the overland route is still fine.
Could the Qlaiaat airport be opened up for the freight of Lebanese produce to foreign markets?
This is one of many ideas people have…
But is it an idea you support?
Would it work? Would it be sustainable? Or would it just be another cost for the government? We are just speculating. Everything is working so far. Everybody is able to export fine from land via Syria and imports are coming in.
Lebanon’s industrialists have asked for faster reimbursement of the value added tax (VAT). What is being done in this regard?
I want to ask what are they doing in other countries? Some are doing well but all the rest are in financial trouble.
VAT reimbursements is a local bureaucratic issue; how is that related to the Eurozone crisis?
In some countries they raised VAT to say 21 percent. We are at 10. They are reimbursing but taking the money back in another way. The Lebanese enjoy very low taxes.
What is your stance on article 59, which allows industrialists to reclaim their VAT on industrial machinery and mineral materials?
If you are importing a product that you want to use to manufacture items and then you want to resell it, that should be excluded from VAT. Secondly, industrial machines that are imported should be excluded. Also whenever a product is being sold to the army we are putting VAT on it. This should be excluded.
Is this up for discussion in the Cabinet?
I need to discuss with my friend the Minister of Finance, but this is the right thing to do…
I would like to add a comment about the economy here. There is a lot of complaining but I don’t think it’s justified. There was great growth from 2006 to 2011, but in economies there is growth and then recession. Without the discipline of recession, continuous growth would bring us to a larger fall into recession.
But the lack of development of Lebanon’s productive sectors makes it more susceptible to external shocks and undermines long-term sustainable growth.
Where are the Lebanese? We are innovative, we had vision, where are these people? Why are we always complaining now? We need to be creative and have a long-term vision.
You need electricity, you need Internet, you need good roads…
We have some drawbacks, but we also have many advantages. We had six years of great expansion with an incredibly strong real estate market. We may be in a recession but that is a discipline we need to go through. We need to be more realistic and enjoy life a little bit. We don’t have to make money every year; there are many nice things to be done in the country.