Home BusinessFinance Your social insecurity


Your social insecurity

Lebanon’s leaking National Social Security Fund

by Maya Sioufi

For paying nearly a quarter of each employee’s monthly salary into the National Social Security Fund (NSSF), one would think that private sector businessmen would be ensuring a nice retirement package and healthcare coverage for those working for them. Why then is it so common for retiree savings to run out at 68, and for hospitals to threaten to deny them services? This Executive investigation dives into the inner workings of Lebanon’s social insecurity.

The money pit

The NSSF, Lebanon’s largest insurance provider, more commonly known as the daman, manages $4.7 billion in private sector contributions and offers coverage for approximately 30 percent of the Lebanese population. Other than end-of-service indemnities, the daman also offers healthcare coverage and family allowance payments.

To deliver these services — or attempt to deliver these services — the law stipulates that the NSSF should receive an amount equal to 23.5 percent of every employee’s monthly salary. This cash is then allocated to the NSSF’s three dedicated funds and entirely invested in Lebanese currency through treasury bills and deposits with local commercial banks. Employers carry the lion’s share of the burden, paying 21.5 percent and employees contribute the remaining 2 percent.

Under the umbrella of the Ministry of Labor, the NSSF is a “black hole” says Nassib Ghobril, chief economist of Byblos bank. Of the three funds run by the NSSF, two have been racking up deficits for the last 10 years. The family allowance fund reported an accumulated deficit of $252 million as of the end of last year.

Employers pay cash equal to 6 percent of each employee’s monthly salary into this fund, up to a salary cap of LL1.5 million ($995), meaning for higher salaries the fund payment is fixed at $60. This stash of money pays $40 to each married employee if the spouse is unemployed and $22 for each child until the age of 18, up to a maximum of five children. This means that if an employee is married with an unemployed spouse and just one child, he receives more from the family allowance fund than his employer pays into it.

“This allows for corruption,” says Ibrahim Muhanna, founder of the actuarial firm i.e. Muhanna. “Let’s say you are my sister and you have three children. I can put you down as an employee; tax and contributions to the funds are paid and you get the benefits for the children.”

The healthcare fund, also known as the ‘sickness and maternity fund’, also runs a deficit that stood at $239 million at the end of last year. The employer contributes to this fund an amount equal to 7 percent of each employee’s monthly salary, with contributions also capped at a salary level of LL1.5 million. Unlike the other two funds, the employee also contributes by paying 2 percent of his monthly salary, up to a cap of LL30,000 ($20).

What the fund does is reimburse employees for 90 percent of their hospitalization costs and 80 percent of medication and examination expenses, though payment delays often exceed several months and involve navigating long queues and a quagmire of bureaucracy.

The catch for healthcare providers is that NSSF also sets the rate private hospitals can charge patients using their coverage for certain services — rates that can remain unchanged for decades. This year private hospitals in Lebanon began threatening to stop taking NSSF patients unless the rate for an overnight hospital stay was raised from $20 to $60, citing the burden of mounting medical costs. In response, the NSSF administration has asked the government to raise the salary cap on contributions to the healthcare fund to LL2.5 million ($1660) — or a maximum payment of LL175,000 ($116). Economic associations in Lebanon, however, have publicly opposed raising the cap, based on fears that this would pass the burden onto the employers in a time when the country’s economic growth is contracting.

Daman deficits!

Given that the contributions to the healthcare and family allowance funds are capped to a fixed salary, they fail to take into account the rising cost of living, the increase in medical costs and the rise in wages. With the cost of healthcare equipment and pharmaceuticals on the rise — the 2012 Towers Watson Global Medical Trends Survey estimated global medical costs would jump 10 percent this year after increasing 10 percent in the past three years — and contributions into the healthcare fund stable, the deficit continues to plunge ever deeper into the red.

“The contributions do not have an automatic adjustment mechanism like in the West — for instance, having the ceiling at three times the average salary so the ceiling grows along with the increase in the average salary,” says Muhanna. “In Lebanon, if you want to change the figures, you need the Parliament to change the law.”

The deficits on these two funds started piling up after the contributions rates were slashed in 2001 under the leadership of former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, with the aim of reducing labor costs. While the contribution rate to the EOSI remained unchanged, the family allowance fund rate was cut from 15 percent of an employee’s salary to 6 percent, and the sickness and maternity fund rate was cut from 15 percent to 9 percent, amounting to a 40 percent cut in contributions to social security. Mohamad Karaki, director general of the NSSF, blames these rate cuts on the deficits incurred by the two funds and wants to see them increased by at least a few percentage points.

Ghobril disagrees, saying that evasion from NSSF registration is very common. “Just like there are people who evade taxes and you don’t fight tax evasion by raising rates — it will scare away more companies from registering,” he says.

Jihad Rizkallah, lawyer at El Meouchi law firm, says it is “a frequent problem” and common practice in Lebanon for employers to declare lower salaries for their employees in order to decrease their NSSF contributions. “But the employee has the right to claim all amount due; this is of public order,” he says.  “Even if the employer and the employee agree on not registering with the NSSF, the employee can change his mind and his rights are preserved. The employer needs to pay up.”

While Karaki states that more controllers have been hired in the past year — from some 40 to now 100 staff — to stop evasion from contributions to the NSSF, the impact on the figures are yet to be seen.

Abundant insecurity

The only fund that is running a surplus is the end-of-service-indemnity (EOSI) fund catering to retirees [see story page 50]. With an accumulated surplus standing at $5.2 billion as of the end of 2011, the other two funds borrow from the EOSI to stop their bleeding. The lucrative nature of this fund might well be the reason some politicians have said they want to spin it off from the NSSF and have it privatized, which is delaying the discussions in Parliament on implementing reforms to social security, according to Karaki.

The daman’s mission is to provide private sector workers with society’s basic needs from healthcare to family assistance to catering for retirement. With private hospitals threatening to stop coverage, petty family allowances and with savings left depleted within a few years of retirement, it would seem that the nation’s social security fund actually contributes to a feeling of insecurity more than anything else.

Support our fight for economic liberty &
the freedom of the entrepreneurial mind
DONATE NOW

Maya Sioufi

Maya is a research consultant on Arab youth entrepreneurship and employment. She headed Executive's banking, finance and entrepreneurship sections from 2011 to 2013. Previously, she worked at JP Morgan in London in equity sales for three years. She holds an MSc in Accounting and Finance from the London School of Economics (LSE) and a BA in Economics from the American University of Beirut (AUB).   
--------------------------------------


View all posts by

You may also like