Whatever happens in Gaza, blame Hamas! That was the official line of Israel’s well-oiled PR-machine and it was largely swallowed by most Western politicians and mainstream media. Hamas started it, so the argument goes, and if you hit someone, you may expect to be hit back. Hit Israel and expect to be hit back hard.
This is of course a quite simplistic view of things. First of all, Hamas did not start it. As Israeli columnist Uri Averny pointed out, the cease-fire between Hamas and Israel held for months. It was Israel that provoked Hamas by sending an army patrol into Gaza killing three Hamas militants allegedly digging a tunnel. Gaza’s ruling party replied by firing a salvo of Qassam rockets into Israel.
Now, one may argue that shooting homemade rockets into Israel is not the most effective way of promoting one’s cause and that it is time to find another method, but one is on thin ice to claim that Hamas initiated the conflict. In fact, as Averny also pointed out, it was predominantly Israel that did not live up to the conditions of the cease- fire, as it refused to lift the economic blockade that has strangled Gaza since 2007.
Nearly every international aid agency last year sounded the alarm. UNRWA reported last summer that half of Gaza’s population lived on food handouts, while unemployment amounted to 70 percent and that 87 percent of the population lived under the poverty line of $2.40 a day. The World Bank last year warned that the Gaza economy ran the risk of “irreversible collapse.”
Yet these gloomy observations hardly made headlines and they fell on deaf ears among Israel’s diehard supporters — and Hamas’ many enemies — who claim Hamas is to blame for the sorry state of Gaza’s economy. The fact that Israel has failed to implement the Oslo Agreement since 1994, long before Hamas even came to power, does not change things a single bit. That’s just politics, stupid!
The 1994 Paris Protocol on Economic Relations between Israel and the Palestinian Authority stipulates, “there will be free movement of industrial goods, free of any restrictions, including customs and import taxes between the two sides,” and “the Palestinians will have the right to export their industrial produce to external markets without restrictions.”
More importantly, the question of who is responsible for what in the latest wave of death and destruction in Gaza cannot solely be answered by determining who started it. Even if Hamas initiated the Israeli attack by firing rockets, that does not justify disproportional military retaliation. No courtroom in the world allows one to endlessly stretch the required link between cause and effect, as the right to self-defense is limited by the principle of proportionality. Yes, Israel has the right defend itself. No, it cannot respond in any way it wishes.
To put it in simple terms: if you hit someone in the face, the recipient is entitled to hit you back. They, however, are not entitled to bring out a crowbar to break both your knees, bomb the electricity plant in which you work and kill your whole family. On January 18, the day Israel unilaterally announced a cease-fire, Hamas rockets over a period of some three weeks had killed three Israeli civilians and 10 Israeli soldiers were killed. Over the same period, at least 1,300 Palestinians were killed, an estimated one third of whom were children. The immense material damage has since been estimated at nearly $2 billion.
Finally, the role of international media, such as BBC and CNN in the spectacle of death was highly embarrassing. Not allowed into Gaza, their reporters stood quite literally on the Israeli side of things. Their job was essentially to read out Israeli press releases and make sure that any accusation of wrongful conduct from Palestinians or the United Nations was countered by a smooth-talking Israeli press officer who, no matter what happened, blamed Hamas.
Israel bombed not one, but four UNRWA schools filled with refugees? Hamas is known to fire rockets from UN sites. Israel bombs a UNRWA truck killing its driver? Hamas is known to have fired at UN trucks in the past. Israel bombed a mosque filled with people? Hamas is known to hide weapons in mosques.
The Western media proudly claim to be objective, as they show both sides of the story. Yet, giving equal attention to both sides of a conflict that is essentially unequal, means taking sides. The war takes place in Gaza, Palestinian victims outnumber Israeli casualties by at least 100 to one and yet the New York Times publishes an equal number of photos of destruction in Gaza and Israel, therefore producing a false impression of the conflict.
To me, the war and its coverage are best summed up by a fragment starring BBC reporter Bethany Bell. Standing inside Israel, she first told us that some 60 air strikes hit Gaza overnight. We see black smoke behind her. Meanwhile, she continued, 12 Hamas rockets were fired into Israel. One of them hit a kindergarten. The kindergarten, Bell said, was empty.
Peter Speetjens is a Beirut-based journalist
