Freedom in flames

Recently, I happened to be involved in a public debate about the possibility of Lebanon soon introducing a smoking ban, along the lines of similar interdictions in Syria and Turkey. What most irritated anti-smoking activists was my proposal to allow for choice in certain types of facilities, with the market determining behavior. The outrage said a great deal about the mood driving a smoking ban law in Lebanon, and outside.  The proposal was fairly benign. A ban could be made complete in most places, including ministries and private offices, but remain optional in restaurants, cafés, and bars. The reality of a ban, however, would allow owners of leisure establishments to declare them smoke-free environments, even brand them as such, without clients being able to dispute this. In turn, other establishments could allow smoking. The market would arrive at some equilibrium, with both sides satisfied.    Rejection of these kinds of proposals