• Donate
  • Our Purpose
  • Contact Us
Executive Magazine
  • ISSUES
    • Current Issue
    • Past issues
  • BUSINESS
  • ECONOMICS & POLICY
  • OPINION
  • SPECIAL REPORTS
  • EXECUTIVE TALKS
  • MOVEMENTS
    • Change the image
    • Cannes lions
    • Transparency & accountability
    • ECONOMIC ROADMAP
    • Say No to Corruption
    • The Lebanon media development initiative
    • LPSN Policy Asks
    • Advocating the preservation of deposits
  • JOIN US
    • Join our movement
    • Attend our events
    • Receive updates
    • Connect with us
  • DONATE
Economics & Policy

For your information

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

Telecom bidding concludes

The Ministry of Telecommunications has announced that it has concluded the bidding round for the second installment of the ministry’s project to build Lebanon’s modern Internet infrastructure. The ministry awarded the contract to the Swedish company Ericsson, in part because its bid of $6.3 million was the lowest price of the five competing companies. The project specifications cover the supply and installation of DWDM multiplexers, equipment that allows signals to pass along fiber optic cables. Bids by Tellabs and UTL were thrown out because their “administrative files were not complete” and ZTE was disqualified because it did not meet the ministry’s technical specifications. The project has been criticized in the past by United Nations International Telecommunications Union experts for being overpriced and badly structured.

GDP forecast drops with cabinet demise

The longer it takes, the worse it will get. That was the sentiment of most international financial institutions that commented on the collapse of Lebanon’s cabinet last month. JP Morgan slashed its Gross Domestic Product estimate for Lebanon in 2011 following the collapse of the cabinet, as did the International Institute of Finance, with each lowering their forecasts to 4 percent and the former expecting political negotiations to last several months. Before the cabinet dissolved, GDP calculations from the United Nations Economic and Social Commission of Western Asia were set at 5.6 percent, down from 6.7 percent in 2010. Credit Suisse expected the crisis to affect the country’s creditworthiness but anticipated that it would be contained by Lebanon’s strong financial standing. EFG Hermes noted that because the cabinet was in a state of paralysis anyhow, its downfall did not represent a short-term risk to the economy but, down the line, risks were likely to increase. Barclays Capital noted that the cabinet’s downfall meant that the much-needed reforms and expenditures associated with the 2011 budget would be delayed and could put pressure on interest rates and the government’s borrowing costs. It estimated that the finance ministry would need to roll over some $3.4 billion in foreign currency debt at these new rates but also noted one ‘silver lining;’ the lack of budget expenditures would keep the fiscal deficit in check. 

A moderately free economy

Lebanon’s economy is “moderately free.” At least, that was the reading of the United States’ right-wing think-tank Heritage Foundation, which posted its global Index of Economic Freedom last month in collaboration with The Wall Street Journal. Lebanon was ranked 83rd out of 183 countries in terms of its economy’s freedom and eighth among 17 countries in the Middle East that were surveyed. The term “moderately free” was an upgrade from the 2010 index reading that classified the country as being “mostly unfree.” The index evaluated 52 independent economic variables and 10 broad factors to come up with its results. Lebanon ranked one notch below Greece.

A water plan for another government

Before his resignation from cabinet last month, then-Minister of Energy and Water Gebran Bassil unveiled the long-awaited plan to reform the country’s water infrastructure. The plan seeks to provide citizens with a flow of 1.8 billion cubic meters (BCM) by 2035, which would cover the current deficit, the minister claimed. According to Bassil, during a dry year water demand can outstrip the annual supply of 1.2 BCM by some 283 million cubic meters (MCM). If measures are not taken the average annual deficit is expected to rise to 600 MCM by 2035, he warned. The total investments needed to realize the plan were set at $7.7 billion, with an additional $2.2 billion in expenditures over the next 10 years. Noting that $1.6 billion has already been pledged, the minister expects the rest to come from a combination of sources that include the government budget, the private sector and international organizations. The plan would increase Lebanon’s storage capacity to approximately 670 MCM from the current 235 MCM. It also seeks to increase the amount of treated wastewater that can be reused from the current 6 percent to 80 percent by 2015 and 95 percent by 2022. The current practice of one-time annual fees charged to consumers would be phased out by increasing the percentage of users with water counters to 25 percent by next year and 75 percent by 2015, with the rate of bill collection to increase to 60 percent from the current 47 percent, and up to 80 percent by 2015. The minister also revealed that only a third of the 4,050 employees required to fill the organizational structures of regional water establishments are currently employed.

Energy round up

Transfers of funds to Electricite du Liban dropped significantly during the first 11 months of last year, but may soon see another rise with the cabinet’s collapse. The latest figures from the finance ministry released last month showed a 22 percent drop in transfers to $1.06 billion. The fall was attributed to the relatively low price of fuel oil imported from the Kuwait Petroleum Company and the Algeria’s Sonatrach — the Lebanese government’s only two suppliers — compared to 2009, as well as a 27 percent drop in the quantity of imports. That import drop is the result of fuel oil being substituted by Egyptian natural gas, the delivery of which to the Deir Ammar plant via a pipeline from Syria began in November 2009.  According to the finance ministry, supply was halted on November 5 of last year even though the previous cabinet approved the December payment. EDL has yet to make the disbarment, the ministry stated, and the cabinet will need to approve future payments to Egypt in order for Lebanon to continue receiving natural gas. The lack of a cabinet decision to improve the Lebanese energy sector’s fiscal situation precedes the current political crisis, as the previous cabinet failed to ratify a credit line on a concessional loan to help Lebanon cover its energy expenditures, as agreed upon with the Arab League’s Arab Monetary Fund (AMF) in December 2008. Last month the AMF extended a $45 million concessional loan to the government with a rate of LIBOR plus 1 percent. Meanwhile, last month the energy ministry also unveiled its national energy efficiency strategy that seeks to reduce the country’s energy expenditure by 1 percent every year for the next five years and plans to make good on the promise Lebanon made at the Copenhagen climate conference last year to produce 12 percent of its power output through renewable sources by 2020.

Tourism passes two million

For the first time in Lebanon’s history, the number of tourists arriving in the country over a period of one year has surpassed two million. According to the Ministry of Tourism, the number of visitors during 2010 reached 2.17 million, a 17.12 percent increase from 2009. The numbers were bolstered by a high number of arrivals during the holiday season in December, reaching nearly 900,000 tourists, a 14 percent increase on the previous year. Of total visitors, other Arab nationalities topped the list with some 895,000 (41.27 percent), followed by Europeans (25.35 percent), Asians (17.23 percent) and tourists from the Americas (11.47 percent).

FDI levels off

Foreign direct investment in Lebanon (FDI) saw a slight contraction last year, a possible indication that the economic ceiling has been reached. The total amount of FDI estimated by the World Bank for 2010 was $4.65 billion, a decline of 3.2 percent on 2009 ($4.8 billion) but still more than 2008 ($4.33 billion). The downward trend is consistent with the fall of FDI throughout the region, which contracted by 12 percent in 2010 compared to the previous year, hitting $28.4 billion. Lebanon still accounted for the highest estimated ratio of FDI to gross domestic product in the Middle East and North Africa at 11.9 percent (down from 13.7 percent in 2009) and ranked second in total investment, behind Egypt’s $6.5 billion. FDI to the country accounted for 16.4 percent of all investment in the MENA region, up from 15 percent in 2009. The bank also estimated Lebanon’s current account deficit at 23.6 percent of GDP in 2010, compared to a surplus of 0.3 percent for the MENA region. The World Bank calculated GDP growth at 8 percent in 2010, putting Lebanon even with Yemen as the fastest-growing MENA economy among a total of nine low and middle-income countries in the region.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Real estate

For your information

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

Large price tag, small apartment

In a study comparing the 2010 prices of 120-square-meter apartments across 92 cities, Beirut came in highest in the Arab world, and 33rd overall. That’s a steep rise from 52nd place in 2009. As a study on property investment, the Global Property guide looked at high-end apartments in selected areas of the world’s cities that are available for resale. The study collected prices of apartments in Ashrafieh, Verdun, Ramlet El Baida and the downtown district, among others. The study placed Beirut and Tel Aviv at the top of the Middle East and North Africa region for their price-to-rent ratio, or the number of years required for rent paid to equal the property’s sales price. Up from 24 years in 2009, it now takes and average of 30 years.

Squatters’ scuffle

Albert Abela, a Lebanese man living in London and chairman of Abela Group, most famous for its worldwide catering services, successfully evicted a group of 30 European squatters from his £10 million ($15.9 million) mansion in Highgate, London on January 17, according to British daily The London Evening Standard. Abela, who has not lived in the house “for a long time” according to one neighbor, commissioned a private company who used 22 officers to remove the squatters after obtaining a court order on the morning of the eviction. The last squatter to leave, 21-year-old Jason Ruddick, revealed that he had traveled 1,500 miles specifically to live in the 10-bedroom mansion, staying there since Boxing Day. In a bizarre confrontation with bailiffs, he discussed the group’s plans to squat in another abandoned home. A neighbor said, “I can’t understand how someone could let a property that expensive just sit empty… if people need a home I don’t mind all that much.”

Political upheaval shakes share prices

The resignation of 11 ministers and collapse of the government on January 12 sent investors on the Beirut Stock Exchange scrambling, with the bourses’ largest publicly traded company and Lebanon’s biggest construction company, Solidere, seeing its “A” shares tumble 8.2 percent to $18.73 and “B” shares slide 6.7 percent to $18.72, according to data from Bloomberg. The shares slipped further as tension in the country mounted over the next week. Following Parliament’s election of the new Prime Minister Najib Mikati and the cessation of demonstrations around the country by supporters of the former Prime Minister Saad Hariri, share prices rebounded, with Solidere “A” shares closing at $19.96 and “B” shares at “20.02” as of going to print. 

New stars for Starwood

It’s going to be a busy five years for Starwood Hotels & Resorts. The group, which operates 50 hotels throughout the region, plans to open another 25 hotels in the Middle East by 2015, making the area its prime focus after North America. Ten will be in the United Arab Emirates, which is already home to 20 Starwood hotels. The New York-based operator said that the president, chief executive officer, chief financial officer and other executives are currently touring the Middle East and will sign five deals this month to open new hotels. Currently on the agenda are new hotels in Muscat, Amman and the emirates of Sharjah and Ajman. The UAE construction firm Al Habtoor group, which owns four hotels in Dubai and two in Lebanon, said in a January 17 press release that its CEO, Mohamad al-Habtoor, held meetings with the top leadership of Starwood Hotels & Resorts. Despite the fact that his company is still waiting on payments of around $1.1 billion for projects that have been complete, the chairman of Al Habtoor Group has plans to build the largest hotel in the UAE, which will have approximately 2,000 rooms.

Eco education expansion

Abu Dhabi’s Masdar Institute of Science and Technology has selected Arabian Construction Company (ACC) to take up the second phase of construction on its campus expansion plan, which means the Lebanese firm will be in charge of building student dorms, labs and conference areas for a price of $204 million. Company director Hamed Mikati told Gulf News on January 9 that Aldar Properties, based in Abu Dhabi, will manage the project, which would take about a year and half to complete and will enlarge the campus size by 35 percent by adding 82,000 square meters. He said, “We are taking sustainable building practices and the reduction of embodied carbon into account and look forward to being a part of the future of green construction.”

Failed bid to buy out the occupiers

Palestinian-American businessman Bashar Masri was beaten by Israeli supermarket tycoon Rami Levy in a bid to buy out a bankrupt Israeli real estate company Digal Investments & Holding, which is building a housing project in East Jerusalem. Masri offered $36 million to buy all shares in Digal and half the shares in another company that is building a hotel on the plot. Masri had said he wanted to sell the more than 300 units to Palestinians.  Levy told Israel National News TV that the opportunity to take over the project was an attractive one, both from a financial and ideological perspective, with 90 homes already built and 300 more planned. “There is no reason why Jews should not live there,” Levy said. Digal completed nearly a quarter of the 400 residences, which they planned to sell only to Jews, but later ran into debt problems when slow sales ensued. Masri told the Los Angeles Times in a January 12 article that the sale “sends the wrong message that if you are of Arab background you will be treated differently from someone with an Israeli background. It is not good for your business if you claim to be a free-market economy.”

Jeweled property

The Boghossian Foundation, founded by the Armenian family of the same name, has opened the Villa Empain in Brussels to art aficionados. The previously run-down villa has been refurnished with textiles and art for gallery showings. Opened in November and running until February, the exhibition shows off a range of Ottoman relics. Jewelers Jean and Albert Boghossian, who fled Beirut during the civil war in the 1970s and are now based in Geneva and Antwerp, purchased the property in 2006 as a new headquarters for their foundation before opening it to the public in April of 2010. Global Post describes the family as having “rescued” the villa, which had fallen into disrepair and was once used as a Nazi headquarters.

Five-star Kurdistan

Beirut-based Malia group, partnering with Italian company DIVA, opened the Erbil Rotana Hotel, the first five-star hotel in the Iraqi region of Kurdistan in late December, according to Byblos Bank’s January report. The hotel, built at a cost of around $55 million, sits on 20,000 square meters of land and offers 201 guest rooms. Founded in Lebanon in 1936, Malia Group now operates in Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Egypt and some parts of Europe. They had been active in the Kurdistan construction industry before starting work on the hotel, which had been scheduled to open in 2009.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Banking & Finance

Money matters bulletin

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

Regional stock market indices:

Regional currency rates:

Qatari banks’ 2010 results hit record highs

Qatari banks are expected to have registered new all-time high net profits of $3.7 billion in 2010, according to the preliminary releases by the sector’s leaders. Total net profits up until September had amounted to a record $2.55 billion, supported by new regulations following the global financial crisis. Similarly, banking activity was encouraged into further diversification after conventional banks were prohibited from allocating more than 10 percent of their capital into Islamic finance. Of the best performers, Qatar National Bank, the country’s largest lender by market capitalization, posted a 41.3 percent leap in its fourth quarter profits to $410 million, bringing its yearly net profits to $1.57 billion. Al Rayyan Bank profits soared 52 percent to $250 million from $164 million in 2009. Qatar’s final positive jolt this year was winning its bid to host the 2022 World Cup. This will boost productive and commercial activity in a country whose ample liquidity is being absorbed by the financial sector. 

OCI and Arab Contractors bid for Egyptian nuclear project

Egypt plans to establish four nuclear power reactors with a combined capacity of 4,000 megawatts to meet the surging demand for electricity. The first reactor is expected to be launched in 2019, while the fourth and last reactor is scheduled to start operating in 2025. For that purpose, the two largest contracting companies in Egypt, Orascom Construction Industries (OCI) and Arab Contractors, formed a joint venture to bid on Egypt’s first nuclear power plant in early February 2011, with the winning bid to be announced by end of July 2012. According to OCI’s managing director, this strategic joint venture has created a regional consortium qualified to bid on the large flow of future nuclear power plants in Egypt and the Middle East.

Jordanian economy to grow  4.25 percent in 2011

An International Monetary Fund (IMF) mission team visited Jordan on December 13 and 19 to review macroeconomic and financial developments. The mission released an aide-memoire in which it noted expectations that Jordan’s economy would  grow by 4.25 percent in 2011 amid diverse signs of recovery in the country, with increasing exports, strong tourism revenue and higher capital inflows and private investments. Moreover, the IMF maintained its gross domestic product growth estimates for 2010 at 3.5 percent compared to a 2.3 percent in 2009, its weakest growth since 1989. The Fund stated that the economic recovery is expected to continue with the rising domestic activity, fiscal prudence and credible monetary management, supported by strong supervision and regulation of the financial sector. Jordan’s budget deficit is predicted to narrow to 5.3 percent of GDP in 2011 compared to an estimated 5.75 percent of GDP in 2010, while the external current account deficit is expected to expand to 5 percent of GDP in 2010 and 6.25 percent of GDP in 2011 amid higher expenditure on imported commodities.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Banking & Finance

Investments of scale

by Imad Ghandour February 21, 2011
written by Imad Ghandour

It is telling that the most exciting event in private equity this year was the Celebration of Entrepreneurship event in Dubai — also known as Wamda, the equivalent of the West’s eureka. It brought a much needed freshness and vigor to a private equity industry that is in search of excitement and vision.

The private equity industry landscape has changed dramatically in the past two years as the mood has swung from celebration to humility. Fundraising and deal-making activity shrunk in 2009 by as much as 85 percent and did not recover, as many, including yours truly, had prophesied. 

The number of funds that are active and investing has also shrunk to less than a dozen in the Gulf Cooperation Council from a peak of more than 50, with many fund managers unwillingly switching from being deal makers to caretakers. Some funds have already closed down shop while others are facing up to the fact that, after their current ventures wrap up, there aren’t any to follow.

Over the past four years, successful managers raced to raise bigger and bigger funds (as big as $4 billion) and few managers remained focused on the smaller opportunities, which constitute the mainstream of the corporate landscape in the Arab world. Constrained by their current mandate, the remaining mammoth funds are now facing a new challenge: access to quality deal flow. These large funds are starving for new investment opportunities that can deliver the promised returns and are facing the grim scenarios of either returning some of the cash raised to investors or investing in sub-par deals.  

Going back to Wamda celebrations, the 2,000 delegates that participated in the festive conference represent a renewed and revived core of the Gulf’s economic activity. Gone are the days when business in the region meant betting on inflated real estate prices and skyrocketing stock markets. A much more sober mood of industrious entrepreneurship is setting in.

The number of people I know personally that are en-route to starting their own businesses, despite the recessionary environment, is enormous. They come from all walks of life — from students to executives — and are setting up everywhere from Riyadh, to Jeddah, to Cairo, to Dubai, to Beirut, to Amman.

In the past 20 years working in the region, I have not seen such a vibrant entrepreneurial environment as I do today. The benefits of economic liberalization are starting to trickle in.

So what does that mean for private equity?

It means that there is a stellar increase in demand for equity funding, which is good news in principle, except that economic liberalization measures have not extended to privatizing large-scale state enterprises. Instead they have given rise to a wave of grassroots entrepreneurialism.

In other words, large private equity funds seeking to attract, say, a company like Gulf Air, are going to compete with each other over the few opportunities of such scale that remain. On the other hand, smaller growth capital funds focused on funding a company like Bateel — a successful regional chain of date stores and cafés — will have ample opportunities from which to choose.

Large funds are rigidly geared to do large deals; due to the high profile of the people they hire and the bandwidth of their fund managers it won’t be easy to switch their focus to smaller deals.

IMAD GHANDOUR is chairman of Gulf Venture Capital Association

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Banking & Finance

For your information

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

Institutions react to unrest

With the political situation in flux recently, international institutions and organizations have been putting in their two cents as to what they regard as the possible impacts on the Lebanese banking sector:

  • The International Monetary Fund (IMF) congratulated the Lebanese banking sector for its resiliency in past crises and said that it sees no concerns in the near future due to the large reserves at both Banque du Liban (BDL), Lebanon’s Central Bank, and local banks. For this reason, the IMF said that depositors should have no concerns about the security of their banks or the strength of the Lebanese lira.
  • Merrill Lynch said that holding Lebanese assets is no longer worth the risk, though it does not see a forthcoming decrease in the interest rate spread between the Lebanese lira and Western currencies, suggesting that deposits should stay stable.
  • HSBC said that though investor sentiment may suffer, Lebanese banks are not in immediate danger as they are well capitalized.
  • Credit Suisse said that the situation is likely to spook some investors. They also said that with Lebanese banks dependent on short-term depositors from outside of the country, unhedged lending with an increase in the rate of dollarization might be an issue.
  • Barclays Capital expressed confidence in BDL’s ability to keep the Lebanese lira stable but said that continued political stagnation and uncertainty may cause a reversal of any progress the government has made in paying down the public debt.
  • Citibank noted that domestic deposits have historically continued through tense times, including after the Hariri assassination and the 2006 war with Israel.
  • JP Morgan suggested buying Lebanese credit default swap protection.
  • Standard Chartered highlighted the potential negative impact that current conditions may have on the real estate and tourism sectors in the long-term.

All parties acknowledged the concern that a macroeconomic slowdown would be detrimental to the banking sector. The central bank put out a statement on January 19 in which Governor Riad Salameh stated that “the current conditions will not stand in the way of the Central Bank’s commitment to stability of the exchange rate and interest rates.” Joesph Torbey, chairman of the Association of Banks in Lebanon, echoed that sentiment saying in a statement that the “banking sector is capable of containing… and overcoming the situation. [We wish] that the crisis is not prolonged as it would have a negative impact on the economy.”

BDL balance sheet dips

Banque du Liban (BDL), Lebanon’s central bank, held $31.03 billion in foreign assets as of mid-January. This new total represents an appreciation of 1.39 percent, or $425.49 million, in the first two weeks of January. Since mid-January 2010, BDL’s foreign assets have grown 8.8 percent from $28.68 billion. The central bank’s overall balance sheet saw a 3.01 percent ($391.67 million) depreciation, however. Gold reserves at the BDL showed annualized growth of $2.15 billion, or 20.5 percent, increasing from $10.47 billion on January 15, 2010 to $12.62 billion on January 15, 2011. 

Clearing up… checks, that is

Cleared checks were up 20 percent in 2010, showing a healthy rise in consumer spending for the year. However, the indicator did see a 3 percent decrease in December 2010 as compared to December 2009. December was the only month demonstrating negative growth, but the slowdown in spending began in August, as overall clearing growth for the first half of the year was at 35.5 percent. The fourth quarter solidified the trend as growing rumblings of political tensions brought the average growth down to 3.1 percent. Cleared checks are an indicator of general patterns of spending within an economy and therefore demonstrate the potential effect that continuing political uncertainty could have on domestic economic trends.

Five MENA companies to watch

Three UAE companies, one Saudi corporation and one Egyptian company were included in Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG) “New Global Challengers” list for 2011. DP World, Emirates Airline, Etisalat and Saudi Arabia’s Saudi Basic Industries Corporation, as well as Egypt’s El Sewedy Electric, all made BCG’s lineup. The list was compiled following a BCG search for small companies in rapidly developing economies that have posted impressive levels of growth. DP World replaced Dubai World on this year’s list. The report noted that DP World is posting 50 percent more growth than the industry average and is aggressively expanding into emerging markets such as Brazil, Egypt, India, Pakistan and Turkey. Chemical, plastic and fertilizer producer Saudi Basic Industries (Sabic) is the Middle East’s most profitable non-oil company and now operates in 40 countries. In 2009, Sabic posted revenues of $27.5 billion. Egypt’s El Sewedy Electric is a manufacturer of cables and power transformers, distributing in Africa and the Middle East. The company posted an average of 35 percent annual revenues growth from 2004 to 2009 and reached $1.7 billion in 2009. El Sewedy is the only company of its kind distributing through many parts of Africa.

The Islamic road to standardization

The main challenge on Islamic finance’s path to equal consideration with conventional banking is standardization, according to David Vicary, global Islamic finance leader for Deloitte. Still in relative infancy, Islamic finance requires an agreed-upon set of short-term liquidity instruments and an index where these instruments can be traded, said Vicary at a January 14 press event in Beirut. Vicary suggested that a global sharia body would be necessary in order to standardize Islamic finance and make it globally relevant, though he noted that such a body is unlikely to come about due to the varying opinions of sharia scholars. Furthermore, Islamic finance needs a cross-border liquidity structure and transparency. Some sharia scholars sit on the boards of over 130 different Islamic financial institutions, a threat to transparency and honest competition. Despite its challenges, Vicary said that Islamic finance is poised for growth as 25 percent of the world population is Muslim and only 1 percent of the assets are Islamic. Though religion, he reminds us, cannot be the only driver of growth. “The crisis has drawn attention to a different economic model which is not based on derivatives,” he said. Regarding Lebanon’s Islamic financial industry, Vicary said that the local market is less important than the opportunities for regional expansion that greater Islamic fluency would bring. “There is an opportunity for Lebanese banks to use Islamic finance to drive their regional aspirations,” he said.

Iraqi central bank tiff

Iraq’s central bank is dissatisfied with a recent court ruling which places it in the hands of the country’s cabinet and not the parliament. The bank says that giving the cabinet supervisory authority opens its international assets up to seizure attempts by the country’s creditors. “[The bank’s] independence, as stated in the law, was and still is the only guarantee that the Central Bank of Iraq’s financial resources outside Iraq are not subject to measures of confiscation and seizure by international creditors,” said the central bank’s statement. The bank holds $50 billion in reserves. The ruling came down in mid-January just before Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki’s reappointment and also put the electoral commission and the country’s anti-corruption watchdog in the hands of the cabinet. The independence of Iraq’s central bank was implemented by a 2004 law written by United States administrators and the central bank’s statement suggests that this move by the country’s executive runs counter to that sentiment. “Safeguarding the central bank from executive authority is as necessary now and in the future as it was immediately after the fall of the previous regime,” said the same statement.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Special Feature

Afghanistan the road to Khost

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

The efforts of united states-led coalition forces to secure the wild frontier of afghanistan’s eastern border while winning the hearts and minds of the local population epitomize a larger war that shows little sign of ending. EXECUTIVE traveled to the region and, embedded with u.s. marines, documented the struggle for this rugged land and its people. 

Khost Province is, in many ways, a microcosm of Afghanistan. An active insurgency, fuelled by one of the major infiltration routes from Pakistan,  faces up to a strong coalition and Afghan security presences amid tribal tensions and rivalries, feudal warlords, assassinations and widespread corruption, all set within an inhospitable landscape largely carved from vast and forbidding mountains. It is close to the very roots of Afghanistan’s current war, with some of those who hijacked planes and flew them into the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon in Washington on September 11, 2001 having been trained in Al Qaeda’s former camps in the province. Of the major issues that plague Afghanistan, the only one not overly prevalent in Khost is the production of opium.

Against this backdrop of conflicting interests and an often-fierce insurgency, the United States and other actors are attempting to drag the backward province somewhere closer to the 21st century. Currently the major effort is to reconstruct the Khost-Gardez (K-G) Pass, which links the capitals of Khost and Paktia Provinces. Low-lying portions of the road had been paved before the Russian invasion in the early 1980s but needed resurfacing, most of which has been accomplished. Sections still awaiting repair run through the treacherous mountain passes that are home to some of Afghanistan’s most wanted and notorious warlords. Although not as famous as the Khyber Pass, the Khost-Gardez, known locally as the Seti Kandow Pass, is nonetheless just as ancient; together they have formed the main routes connecting Kabul to the Indian sub-continent since antiquity. As such, its strategic control has been of importance in countless military campaigns over the course of millennia, a tradition that has carried on into modernity.

The renovation of the pass is due to be completed in October 2011, but the project, funded by the US Agency for International Development (USAID) and being built by private contractor Louis Berger, has run into severe logistical difficulties, as well as controversies. Not the least of these have been allegations of massive fraud against the Washington, DC-based contractor, who runs projects throughout Afghanistan and have been accused of systematically over charging the US Government.

The K-G Pass was at one time one of many projects planned in Khost. If these had gone ahead, there would be a new international airport to whisk some 200,000 Khostis back and forth to the United Arab Emirates, where they have found work in the absence of sufficient jobs in the province — this, however, never materialized. In the event of an accident on the pass, you might also have hoped to be taken to the brand new hospital, built with USAID funds, only to be later condemned as structurally unsound by both Afghan and international engineers. New water and electricity grids for Khost city still exist only in blueprint, among other canceled projects, leaving the K-G Pass as the major remaining endeavor of the reconstruction efforts in Khost.

Bringing Khost to commerce and country

The pass is a key project that could help to accomplish several goals. Most obviously there are the commercial gains of improved transport, linking Khost not only to the hub trade city of Gardez, but also by extension to Highway One all the way to Kabul. Once the pass is completed, travel times for the 101 kilometer trip from Khost to Gardez should be cut from somewhere over six hours to well under four, not to mention the immeasurable gains in comfort and safety that the hard paved road should bring.

During the winter it was not unknown for people to freeze to death, caught in their cars under avalanches or in conditions that had become too difficult to navigate. The new road should vastly reduce such incidents and accidents in general. Once the road is paved it will also be harder to place improvised explosive devices (IEDs), which are often buried in the existing dirt road.

Beyond these practical benefits, though, is the more subtle and intangible goal of connecting Khost with Kabul and the central government, and thus making it an Afghan city not only in name’s sake but also in identity. Khost city sits only 25 kilometers from the Pakistan border and is linked to its neighbor by roads that are far more navigable than the currently torturous K-G Pass. The currency of trade in Khost is the Pakistani rupee, and since there aren’t sufficient storage facilities in the city there are stories of goods being trucked across the border in the summer and then sold back to Khostis at twice the price during the winter.

“Because of the mountain range just south of Gardez, Khost has traditionally been somewhat more closely tied politically and economically to North Waziristan in Pakistan than to the rest of Afghanistan,” said Richard Broadhead, USAID’s contracting officer’s technical representative on the project. He explained to Executive that the K-G Pass “can be perceived as an umbilical cord to the government, finally making [Khostis] part of the family.”

Currently, many Khostis identify themselves as Waziristanis, feeling more closely connected to Pakistan’s semiautonomous North-Western frontier provinces, than they do to either Afghanistan or Pakistan. Irrespective of which side of the border they are on, the Waziri identity is one of strong tribal loyalty rather than national affiliation, which is also true of other tribes in the west of the province.

Paving the way

The fact that both President Hamid Karzai and the American Ambassador William Wood were present at the signing of the contract between USAID and contractor Louis Berger gives some idea of the importance of the project. A total of $145 million has already been spent on the first two sections of the reconstruction through the low-lying lands to either side of the mountain pass itself, and a further $29 million has been requested to complete the remaining work on the 38 km section through the mountains.

Early indications are that the reconstructed K-G Pass is indeed resulting in considerably greater traffic flows. Surveys taken near the Khost and Gardez ends of the route saw traffic increase from an average of 1,500 vehicles per day in October 2007 to 2,250 by May 2010 at the Khost end, and from 1,500 to 1,950 during the same period at the Gardez end. The road had only been paved about 20 km out of each of the cities in May so further increases are expected when the pass has been completely finished. The road will also help to bring harvest to market, an important boon to Khost’s economy with 45 percent of rural households reporting that they derive income from arable agriculture and 36 percent from livestock, according to the United Nation’s World Food Program. Interviews with the road engineers, conducted by USAID, indicate an increase in the number of markets and food stalls along the road, particularly near Khost, and over time USAID expects a significant increase in the number and frequency of farmers using the road to bring their surplus goods to market. Transfer points for local crops to be taken to major market areas once the road is completed will have an even greater impact.

The Haqqani insurgency

The project has entailed USAID’s most challenging road construction to date. On top of the logistical challenges presented by flooding and by having to cut into the mountains to widen the road from one to two lanes, the largest obstacles have been insurgency related. A total of 19 construction workers have been killed and 35 seriously injured from insurgent attacks and a further four are missing after having been kidnapped. In addition, 30 major items of construction equipment and three contractor vehicles have been destroyed. These circumstances contributed directly to the previous Indian-owned sub-contracting company’s resignation and refusal to work the remaining section, which has now been sub-contracted to two Afghan companies.

In spite of these difficulties, Broadhead is confident the project will be finished by October 2011. “There have been delays and cost increases but we have completed 63 beautiful kilometers of highway to international standards and intend to complete the remaining 38 kilometers.” Some locals, however, are more skeptical. Shopkeeper Hamid Ahmadzai, who keeps a stall by the road, said, “If they work like this they won’t finish it in another five years.”

The reason there have been so many deaths among the construction workers is that Khost is a stronghold of the Haqqani Network, a Taliban-allied organization that retains its own identity and command structures while operating from its power base in Miram Shah over the border in Pakistan. As Broadhead explained, “the insurgents do not want the increased government of Afghanistan influence in the province that this road will allow.”

Although “Taliban” is often used as a blanket term for insurgents in Afghanistan, the situation in most areas of the country is more complicated, with a network of shifting allegiances between traditional warlords, crime organizations and the “Taliban with a capital T,” said Lieutenant Doggette, a US army intelligence officer based at Solerno, Khost’s largest military base. “You could say we have a Haqqani Network problem here — not a Taliban problem.”

Haqqani or Taliban, the net result is much the same: a steady stream of IEDs placed along the K-G Pass, regular mortar attacks on the military bases and the occasional direct exchange of fire from assaults along the road. The fighting has been fierce enough that Sergeant First Class James Jones of Bravo troop 1-33 cavalry of the 101st Airborne Division received three Purple Hearts in a two month span, for having sustained injuries in combat.

The view from one of the mountain tops which the US forces regularly patrol helps to explain the magnitude of the K-G Pass task from two perspectives.

Firstly, the engineering feat of repairing, repaving and, in some places, re-routing the pass can be properly appreciated in beholding the sheer scale of the mountains, with the road winding its way round hair-pin bends to its highest point at over 10,000 feet.

On the other side of the mountain is a visible reminder of the very different difficulty of ridding the K-G Pass of insurgent influence. At the top of the valley running parallel to that of the K-G Pass lays the village of Haki Kalay, the birthplace of Jalaluddin Haqqani, leader of the Haqqani network. It is thought that the insurgents, launching mortar attacks on the aptly named Combat Outpost (COP) Wilderness, simply drive the short distance down the valley to fire their rounds and then return to the safety of Haki Kalay. Haqqani himself wields considerable influence both in Afghanistan and Pakistan, where he is still said to participate in the Taliban’s shuras (council of leaders) in Quetta, Pakistan. Recently, General Ashfaq Kayani, the head of the Pakistani army, described him as an “asset,” angering both Coalition and Afghan authorities.

Haqqani is more than adept at walking the thin line between enemy and ally. As a Mujahedeen warlord he fought against the Russians before forming an alliance with the Taliban with whom his organization took on other Mujahedin from the Tajik-dominated Northern Alliance. He was appointed Minister of Borders and Tribal Affairs in the Taliban Government of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan before becoming governor of Paktia Province as well as the Taliban’s Military Commander from 2001 onwards.

When the Taliban fell, he was courted by Karzai to join the new government under Coalition patronage: an offer he declined. His organization is more power-oriented than ideologically driven, and while the Taliban might seek to re-impose strictly interpreted Sharia Law, the Haqqani network would likely settle for control of Khost and other areas that they view as their territory.

The Haqqani Network’s methods can be brutal. They are believed to have introduced suicide bombings to Afghanistan and are the major suspects of several prominent attacks in recent years in Kabul. With links to the Taliban leader, Mullah Omar, and supposedly to Osama Bin Laden, Haqqani is still an extremely high profile character who could play a significant role in Afghanistan’s future — especially given the overtones of reconciliation between the Afghan Government and the Taliban, which may yet see Haqqani find his way to the “moderates’ table” once the coalition leaves. It is hardly surprising then, with Haqqani’s ancestral home only a stone’s throw from the route of the K-G Pass, that US efforts to exert soft power and win the hearts and minds of the people in nearby villages is a struggle all on its own.

“Hearts and Minds”

One of the main mechanisms through which the coalition attempts to win support for themselves and the central Afghan administration is empowering local government to spread services and protection to the people.

The K-G Pass traverses three local government districts, two of which are long standing. The third, Gerda Seray, was newly created and is of dubious status. It is nominally supported by the provincial governor, who encourages the appointment of district sub-governors to it with the promise of pay from the provincial budget, but has a habit of then leaving them languishing without even a personal salary until they throw in the towel. According to a US military source, the current hopeful, Atiquollah Batori, is the fifth sub-governor to be appointed to the district by Paktia province’s governor without pay since the district was created in 2005. For several weeks nobody has turned up to what should be the regular shura (or meetings of village elders and advisors) at Gerda Seray District Center.

At the latest failed meeting, Batori suggested the elders were too scared to be seen near the district center, but an Afghan Army officer quickly retorted that he’d seen them in the local markets only a few hundred meters away. In response, the Commanding Officer at COP Wilderness, Captain Jarrad Glasenapp, together with his Afghan counterparts, decided that if the elders wouldn’t represent their villages then they would find somebody else who was willing.

Batori’s chief concern, however, was his salary and he issued an ultimatum that if he wasn’t paid soon he would resign. Often, however, local officials actually pay the provincial governors for their positions rather than being paid for their services. The officials then set about recouping this cost by taking a slice of whatever the district has to offer. The more lucrative the potential earnings from the area, the more expensive the position is in the first place.

This practice is just one of the many mechanisms of corruption that are widespread in Afghanistan, as Glasenapp acknowledged: “There’s always at least some skimming from the top and we just have to live with that.”

Although nobody was pointing a finger in this instance, everyone was aware that if the sub-governor can garner some support from the local villages and stay alive, he stands to make substantial profits on the road.

Staying alive, though, may not be so easy. There is a bounty of some $15,000 on Batori’s head, a figure that annoys him, not so much because the insurgents want to kill him, which is a given, but rather because his counterparts in the adjacent districts have been valued at $35,000. The insurgents are hardly playing a game of bluff; the sub-governor of the adjacent Schwak District, Ali Abad, was assassinated in November 2010 in an IED explosion targeting him while en route to his district center.

Later in the day of the non-attended shura, Batori joined a US patrol through one of the villages in his district in an attempt to find somebody who might represent the villagers. The effort was hampered by the fact that so many of the men have left to find work elsewhere and those that remain are too skeptical or scared to come forward, leaving this particular village appearing all but deserted. The patrol eventually found a man who they could talk to, and when asked why none of the men from his village will go to the sub-governor with their problems, he explained that he had heard that Taliban beat up the last villagers who visited the district center.

Transfer of power

Colonel Luong, the US Officer in charge of the battle space in Khost, is a man who spans the gap between American wars in Afghanistan and Vietnam — the former having recently replaced the latter as America’s longest.

His father had been a South Vietnamese Marine who fought the Viet Cong and the young Luong was himself among the last evacuees from the roofs of the US embassy in Vietnam as that war came to its famous end. His speech at a graduation ceremony for newly trained Afghan under-cover police and army agents was everything that you might have expected from a man of his position; encouragement and bombast mixed with patriotic overtones and denigrations of the “cowardly Taliban leaders.” Some 36 graduates took part in the ceremony; they will need every bit of continued training, together with substantial reinforcements and support from traditional Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF) in order to cope when the US military leaves.

The US and other coalition forces are certainly serious about the training they deliver to the Afghan National Army and the National Police, but it is a hefty task to bring those forces up to scratch before they withdraw. Ultimately, if the ANSF cannot stand up to the threat from insurgents, the temptations of corruption and the bribes of criminals, or worse still should the ethnically diverse army be divided by civil war, then the K-G Pass may only be completed in time to facilitate extortion for criminals and infiltration for insurgents.

“As long as I’m here I’m going to kill as many of these [insurgents] as possible,” said Luong. He concluded his speech to the freshly trained recruits with the words: “Today is an important day for Khost. Today the people of Khost know there is a force in the shadows protecting them; you are that force protecting Khost and the K-G Pass.” As coalition forces know all too well, this will be no small task.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Feature

Just another billionaire?

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

If it is true that one can study the heart and mind of an artist through examining his work, it is equally true that one can learn about, and perhaps understand, a tycoon through his business.

The most general public knowledge of Najib Mikati, Lebanon’s prime minister designate as of January 25, 2011, is that he made a fortune as a telecommunications entrepreneur.

The Mikati corporate family, with older brother Taha at the helm, began their succes in a modest and traditional Lebanese industry — construction — but things started to take off in the 1980s, when the siblings invested in telecommunications and established Investcom Holding.

As the face of Investcom, Najib Mikati rose to prominence when the company became the junior partner to one of Europe’s best known telecommunications firms, France Telecom. The joint venture, in which Investcom held one third, was in ownership of the incongruously named FTML, a Lebanese company that has been defunct for some years now. In its heyday, however, FTML operated the Cellis mobile phone network. It was an effective money-making machine and key enabler in Lebanese economic growth.

A growing wealth

The FTML joint venture could only come into being with the support of the Lebanese prime minister and telecommunications minister at the time of its creation in 1994/95, the legendary Rafiq Hariri.

Investcom’s value was estimated at $30 million by the late 1990s, according to information on the website of parent company, M1 Holding. By 2000, Investcom and its subsidiaries had projects across the Middle East and Africa, in Ghana, Guinea Bissau, Benin, Syria, Liberia and Yemen, with Cyprus added in 2003. A decade after the establishment of FTML, the Mikatis’ telecommunications empire had expanded to five million subscribers in the Middle East and Africa.

After a profitable initial public offering in London and Dubai in October 2005 and a $5.5 billion cash-and-shares-transfer deal with South African telecommunications operator MTN in May 2006, the Mikatis were bona fide billionaires and emerged on the Forbes list of the ‘super-rich’ at $5 billion, or estimated net worth of $2.5 billion each.

They were no longer running telecoms in Lebanon but M1 Holding owned ventures such as travel and aviation, oil exploration, a finance company, a management company, luxury fashion chains here and there and real estate in countries including the United Kingdom, United States and Lebanon.

According to business information provider Zawya, M1 Group interests presently include a Luxembourg-domiciled oil exploration company called Avante, whose website identifies Columbia and Mexico as countries of operations, Swiss airline Baboo (formerly Flybaboo) and 10.33 percent in MTN, through the group’s Dubai arm, M1 Limited.

At the time when M1 and MTN structured the merger deal in April 2006, the cash component was said to be valued at more than $3 billion and the MTN stock was quoted at less than $10 per share. According to data from the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, MTN presently has 1.88 billion shares outstanding and a market capitalization of $33.2 billion, of which M1’s 190 million shares are worth $3.4 billion. The MTN stock traded at around $18 per share in January 2011.

While the MTN shareholding alone justifies the billionaire label for M1 and its four current family owners — Taha and Najib and their respective eldest sons, Azmi and Maher — other M1 business forays are harder to assess in value and some may not have been as profitable. Baboo, essentially an Alps-hopping service with a fleet of two aircraft, appears not to have fulfilled expectations. Neither Avante, nor the Swiss carrier, nor Faconnable, the French fashion brand which M1 acquired in 2007 for $210 million, have been releasing results for public scrutiny, making the group’s total economic worth and performance hard to gauge. 

The businessman through his business

However, real business success is no more about being a billionaire than art is about a sculpture’s price tag in a Sotheby’s catalogue. In this sense, success in art and business are both about making a lasting impact and about the authenticity of style. It is largely immaterial how rich Najib Mikati is from the first billion to the second or third. But what can be said about his style of business leadership or deduced from his corporate successes and failures?

First, the picture is one of keeping things in the family. M1 is a family business, owned entirely, but to undisclosed percentages, by the brothers and their sons.

The appearance of family unity and coherence are carefully maintained. The reporters are kept at bay and the laundry, if any ever got dirty, is kept in the basket. In this regard, the Mikatis have much more in common with the Hariris than with other politico-economic families such as the Berlusconis, the Bushes or the Sarkozys.

The downside of the family business’ gleaming facade lies in shortfalls of transparency. Mikati stressed that he did not retain business interests in Lebanon when assuming the premiership in 2005, but one would wish for more disclosure on holdings and goings-on related to the family empire. 

Another practice of the Mikati family, which also has parallels to the Hariris, is early grooming of the sons to take responsible roles in the family enterprise.

Najib Mikati, by way of the Investcom business success, gives the impression of a mind that is able to see a need and turn it into an opportunity even if the risk might scare others, and do so to considerable personal advantage. From the way in which Investcom and M1 have evolved there is, moreover, reason to assume that as a business leader he resisted the impulse to micromanage and instead developed the ability to entrust and relinquish control, to a notable degree. 

What seems evident is that the Investcom philosophy attributed priority values to the corporate interests that were conducive to Mikati family interests. As many of the M1 and Investcom decisions were presented to the public through the second-generation executives, Azmi and Maher, while at the same time some of the decisions represented by Najib Mikati were reportedly driven by his older brother, Taha, a twofold picture suggests itself wherein Najib Mikati exhibited no fundamental objections to either frequently remaining in the background for the sake of family interests nor accepting a frontline position in representing interests that were said to have been decided primarily by others. Fear of risk, by the way, was not part of the Investcom mindset at any time.   

More Rafiq than Saad

The names Hariri and Mikati stand for two Lebanese families whose fortunes have risen in the second half of the 20th century in cities where the communal leadership had for many generations resided in the hands of other, more entrenched clans. Although he was born half a generation later than Rafiq Hariri, Najib Mikati’s ascent and ambitions have perhaps more points of similarity with the elder Hariri than between Hariri father and son.

When Najib Mikati walked into Lebanese politics as minister in the 1998 cabinet of Prime Minister Selim Hoss, he did so with presence and personality but not with an overwhelming aura of charisma.

When he was appointed prime minister last month, a German news magazine falsely labeled him “Hezbollah’s billionaire.” He is “not Hezbollah and not Iran,” was the perspective offered more aptly by an editorial writer at the Israeli daily Haaretz.

The historic track record of Hezbollah shows an unbroken political priority on protecting its assets — its people, security and military hardware — at any cost.

In matters of policy making, the organization and its political wing have demonstrated no inclination to impose changes, and they have also expressed few perspectives that would suggest ambitions to do so.  

Community leaders from his hometown who say they know Najib Mikati said that he foresees an opportunity to found a political heritage for his family and his northern city of Tripoli, long neglected by the capital. 

He may want to bank on his business experience of successfully navigating concessions to formal and informal partners while still achieving his own objectives. However, Mikati is likely to find that every move of his will be scrutinized much more closely, on the basis of a host of opposing agendas, than any past business decision.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Feature

Origin of the Uprising

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

The events of the last two months have touched the lives of every Tunisian, regardless of class or position. Executive spoke with several of them to hear, first hand, the story of how this tiny nation sparked the fire now raging across the Arab world.

By New Year’s Day 2011, Rafik Rezine had heard plenty about the violence in Sidi Bouzid. Everyone in Tunis had. 

At first the reports had come by circuitous means: through Facebook messages, phone calls and hushed conversations. Those lucky enough to have access to illegal Internet servers shared outside news reports with those who didn’t. The story was compelling, even if its details were unclear: a poor student turned street vendor, Mohammed Bouazizi, had set himself on fire after being humiliated by the police, and the quiet desert city of Sidi Bouzid had erupted against the government in response. 

Like most Tunisians, Rezine expected the protests to dissipate in a few days. Previously, unrest had risen only to fall, quashed by the police and by the president’s much-feared “Black Tigers,” special security forces named for the shade of their riot gear and the brutality with which they suppress dissidents.

Yet despite reports that police had used tear gas, batons and even live ammunition to disperse the crowds, the protests did not die out. On the contrary, when a private Tunisian television station, Nessma TV, finally aired footage of the protests it was clear that they had escalated and spread to the nearby cities of Kairouan, Sfax and Ben Guerdane. By this time the unrest had been boiling for 12 days and showed no signs of cooling.

Mixed feelings on the eve of a revolution

Though the country had experienced strong economic growth over the past several decades — at an average annual rate of 4.7 percent, according to figures from the World Bank, the highest in the Arab world outside of the Gulf — that growth has not been felt uniformly across all regions or demographics of this small country.

After Tunisia declared independence from France in 1956, industrial development occurred primarily in and around the coastal areas of Tunis, Sousse and Sfax, while the economies of smaller coastal cities were buoyed by money flowing from the millions of European, Libyan and Algerian tourists who visit each summer. By contrast, citizens residing within the interior of the country subsisted largely as they have for generations, tending goats, sheep and olive groves.

These interior regions exhibit a significantly lower standard of living than is enjoyed on the coast. On average, income is lower in rural regions and joblessness is higher. Although education is mandatory for all children, only 67 percent of rural children are enrolled in school, as opposed to 82.2 percent in urban areas, according to a World Bank estimate.

Because of these disparities, citizens of the interior — young people in particular — have streamed into the coastal cities. In a striking illustration of the country’s rapid demographic transformation, the population of Tunis has more than doubled since 1990. And when the economic downturn reached Tunisia in 2009, it was the interior of the country that suffered the most from dropping export values and rising food prices.

Rezine, an engineer working for a private company in Tunis, struggled to reconcile his own feelings as he watched the events unfold. On the one hand, he felt strong sympathy for the citizens of Tunisia’s marginalized core at the heart of the protests and could see why they were angry. At the same time, he felt a certain apprehension at the prospect that the riots could spread. Though he had no love for Tunisia’s autocratic government or its president of 23 years, Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali, he had done well for himself in the stable climate of the country’s capital — he had a good job, a family and prospects for advancement.

Authoritarian though it may be, the government protected the measure of security he had attained. Civil unrest meant civil instability. And so Rezine watched and waited. Then came the spark that set him alight.

On January 8, six protesters were killed in clashes with police in the provincial town of Tala, near the Algerian border. They were not the first protesters to die since Bouazizi’s act of desperation, but the scale of the killing infuriated Rezine and much of the citizenry of Tunis.

“For me, that was unacceptable,” he said in a recent interview, speaking by phone from Tunis. “We accept that, if there are protests, the police will act to disperse them; if there are riots, the police will use force. But people getting killed… it was another matter. It was our duty to go out on the street and say ‘stop!’”

“Once we were out, there was no stopping us. It was like a dream: Marching down the avenue, singing ‘Freedom! Work! Ben Ali Out!’”

Civil unrest comes to the capital

At 9 o’clock on the morning of January 14, Rezine joined around 100 other Tunis residents for a peaceful demonstration of civil dissent. It was largely spontaneous, spurred by the deaths of the previous days, though it was organized and communicated through Facebook.

They gathered in the downtown Passage neighborhood, near the Ministry of Interior and began to file towards Avenue Habib Bourgiba, a tree-lined thoroughfare in the center of the city named for Ben Ali’s predecessor. 

As the crowd grew close, Rezine could see that the avenue was empty and surrounded by a cordon of police. By now, however, the protesters’ numbers had swelled. What had begun as a hundred had grown to thousands. They encountered a police barrier at the entrance of Avenue Bourgiba and broke through it.  “That was the police’s mistake,” Rezine recalled. “If they had used more force to break us up before we got to Bourgiba, they could have held us back. But once we were out, there was no stopping us. It was like a dream: Marching down the avenue, singing ‘Freedom! Work! Ben Ali Out!’ We marched to the Ministry building and stayed there for hours.”

As the protests continued, the police realized the situation was growing beyond their control and advanced on the protesters with batons and canisters of tear gas.

Meriem Agrebi, a lawyer, was among the crowd when the police attacked. It was not the first time she had encountered the police in recent weeks.  Tunis’s lawyers had been among the first to pressure the government in the capital. On December 28, roughly 300 lawyers had gathered outside the President’s palace in Tunis in solidarity with the protests elsewhere, with lawyers marching in other cities as well. They were dispersed by police wielding batons, but reconvened to demonstrate again three days later. On January 6, an estimated 95 percent of the country’s 8,000 lawyers went on strike in opposition to police brutality.

Now Agrebi found herself running for cover. As gas canisters bounced in the street around her, she ducked onto a side street where, by prior arrangement, a friend was waiting in a car. They sped away. Doctors cited by BBC News would later report that 13 people were killed during the day’s clashes.  Those clashes would not be the last.

The next day, in the face of new demonstrations and riots, President Ben Ali imposed a state of emergency and promised new legislative elections within six months. That night, he fled by plane — first to Paris, where French President Nicholas Sarkozy reportedly refused him entry, and finally to Saudi Arabia, where he was granted asylum.

The first steps toward democracy

Ben Ali’s abrupt abdication was a massive victory for the protest movement, which quickly moved to capitalize on its gains, appointing members of its own leadership to key government posts. When Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi announced on January 17 that the new parliament would contain former members of Ben Ali’s now-disbanded Constitutional Democratic Rally (RCD) party, it was met with sharp criticism from the protests’ emergent leadership, which was spearheaded by the Tunisian labor union. Not satisfied by Ghannouchi’s promise of sweeping reforms, the unions staged fresh demonstrations around the country calling for all members of the previous government to step down.

That demand struck some Tunisians as far-fetched. Feres Yaiche, 22, an engineering student from the inland city of Kairouan, was among the first of his friends to join the protests. Still, he said in a recent interview, he thinks the movement may now be reaching too far.

“I don’t think a new start is necessarily the best solution,” he said. “I think that we can’t refuse everyone from [the previous] government because we need some balance to protect Tunisia socially and financially. We need experienced people in government to work on the situation going forward — otherwise there will be no forward, only chaos.”

“Everyone feels the corruption.. but you get used to it. You fall asleep… Bouazizi woke us up”

From the outside, looking in

And what exactly are the interests that will need to be ‘balanced’ in the new government? Tunisia is largely homogeneous in its religious composition, with 99 percent of its population Sunni Arabs; economic and geographic disparities, however, run strong.

Amr Hamzawy, a Senior Researcher at the Carnegie Middle East Center and an expert on social protest movements in North Africa, said in a recent interview that if divisions emerge in the new government, they would likely run along rural-urban fault lines.

“It’s important to understand that this wasn’t simply a conflict of Tunisia against the government,” he said. “It started out as a case of remote regions speaking out against the capital city. Even a new government won’t solve the underlying problems of inequality that exist between urban and rural areas of the country. If there is to be stability, there is going to have to be a significant reallocation of resources to the center of the country.”

While there clearly remains an economic split between rural and urban Tunisia, Hamzawy said that the protests had revealed a split among the ranks of the educated and elite as well. “Previously, most experts took it for granted that organizations like the national labor unions and the Bar Association were allied with the government, and by default, corrupt,” he said. “What we’ve seen, by the leading roles these groups took in the protests, is that even among their ranks there were divisions — a kind of two-class society where the administrators at the top received large cuts and distributed favors, but where the vast majority of participants suffered from the same corruption that plagued the rest of the country.”

Statistics from the World Bank’s Human Development Report support the theory. According to the report, Tunisia’s inequality gap is greater than those of India, Indonesia and Jordan, with 10 percent of the population in control of more than a quarter of the country’s wealth. That upper class has also held a monopoly on political power — an imbalance that, according to Hamzawy, may be evening itself out.

“Political forces like the labor unions and the lawyers’ associations didn’t exist in the form they [do] today, unified and powerful, but suddenly they’re playing a crucial role in sustaining street pressure on the government,” he said. They will likely continue to play a significant role in shaping the country’s future and could add a much-needed voice to the national discourse, he added.

From the outside, looking in

An ocean away, Leyla Chaibe, 19, watched her childhood home transform from authoritarian state to emergent democracy in what seemed like an instant. “When I go back to my country, I won’t even recognize it,” she said in a recent phone interview.

Chaibe, who was born to a lower middle-class family in the city of Monastir, now attends Wellesley College in Massachusetts on a full scholarship. She said that although the revolution had been abrupt it was not unforeseeable. “I remember when tensions started to build over government censorship a year ago,” she said. Her friends in Tunisia would refer to the Internet censors as ‘Amar 404,’ – a tongue-in-cheek reference to the default error message displayed by Internet Explorer when an Internet page cannot be found.

Although the economy slowed in 2009,  government officials continued to hound business owners for bribes. When Chaibe’s mother tried to start a day-care center in their community, a representative from the local ministry told her point blank that she would have to pay him a bribe if she wanted to see her business licensed.

“Everyone feels the corruption, and it wears on you, but you get used to it. You fall asleep,” she said. “Bouazizi woke us up.”

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Feature

A country inflamed

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

There were few signs preceding the protests that began on January 25 that they would push the regime of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak to the brink of collapse, leaving Cairo, Alexandria and much of the rest of the country in a state of chaos. Over the course of Mubarak’s 30-year-long reign, different groups of Egyptians have tried many times to openly oppose the regime in the streets, with any movement deemed threatening to the regime crushed under the truncheons of heavy-handed security forces.

This time, it was different. Within days, the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP) headquarters were in flames, gutted and charred carcasses of police vehicles littered Tahrir Square in central Cairo and vigilantes, armed with everything from kitchen knives to samurai swords and baseball bats, had set up checkpoints in the streets to protect their neighborhoods in the absence of the state security apparatus.

In short, revolution was in the air.

“Up to a week ago, I would not have believed it,” said Sarah Sirgany, deputy editor of The Daily News, Egypt’s English-language newspaper. “I did not think that people had it in them to go out in mass protests and call for one thing… [the resignation] of Mubarak.”

The Tunisian revolution earlier in the month didn’t plant the idea of the revolution in the heads of the Egyptians — it had long been there. Rather, Tunisia showed Egypt that change was possible. Still smarting from the November 2010 parliamentary elections where Mubarak’s NDP won an overwhelming majority of the seats, Egyptians were angry; opponents alleged that the election was even more rigged than previous ones.

Such political frustrations, which have pervaded Mubarak’s 30-year tenure, have been compounded of late: Egypt’s economic growth of recent years has lavished wealth on the socioeconomic elite connected with the regime and spurred inflation, while leaving nearly half of Egypt’s 80 million people in dire poverty.

The country was nearing breaking point, yet Mubarak showed no sign of reforming or giving up power. Demonstrations quickly turned into clashes on January 25, with riot police firing tear gas canisters and water cannons at first and later rubber bullets and live ammunition — but the protests did not end.

“The most extraordinary thing I’ve seen is that the protesters are relentless, or they have been [so far],” said Ahmed Moor, Executive’s correspondent in Cairo.

“People I talk to are surprised… that this kind of organic, spontaneous uprising is happening around the country,” said Matthew Cassel, a freelance journalist and photographer on the ground in the Egyptian capital.

In a pre-recorded television address in the early hours of January 29, after protesters had driven his security forces from the streets and fires raged at police stations and NDP offices across the country, President Mubarak said: “These demonstrations would not have taken place without the freedom of expression that was given to the Egyptians.” He said he empathized with Egyptians’ “suffering” and announced he was dismissing his cabinet. The sentiment, more or less, was that he was not going anywhere — at least not yet.

Foreign Affairs

While the United States government has actively pushed and encouraged protests demanding democratic reform elsewhere in the region, the Obama administration was slow to give any response to what was happening in Egypt. This is, perhaps, to be expected, as the US has long considered Mubarak a strong ally and a “force for stability” in the Middle East, as President Barak Obama described him in a 2009 BBC interview. As part of the payment for continuing to maintain the 1979 peace treaty with Israel, the US currently provides Egypt with $1.3 billion in direct military aid per year, an amount second only to the $3 billion or so the country is expected to provide Israel in 2011.

Given this relationship, past and current US administrations have been reluctant to slap the Egyptian leadership’s wrist when it comes to human rights violations and rigged elections. When asked about Mubarak while appearing on PBS’ NewsHour show on January 27, American Vice President Joe Biden said: “I would not refer to him as a dictator,” before adding that he hoped Mubarak would “respond to some of the legitimate concerns that are being raised.”

Anger on the Egyptian street against American support for Mubarak’s repressive regime has only been further inflamed by the spent teargas canisters security services have fired on protesters which are labeled “Made in USA.”

But US diplomatic language does seem to be shifting. The White House announced on January 28 that it was “reviewing” its military assistance to Egypt, which has been interpreted by some as a veiled warning to the Egyptian Army that it must act with restraint when dealing with the protesters. In a January 30 address, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton also said: “I want the Egyptian people to have a chance to chart a new future.”

While the reorientation of American rhetoric may be seen as significant within the US administration, it has had scant resonance on the Egyptian street. Speaking to a crowd of tens of thousands gathered at Cairo’s Tahrir Square on January 30, Egyptian opposition figure Mohammed ElBaradei said that the US is “losing credibility by the day.”

However, the slogans and chants that define protests continue to focus solely on deposing Mubarak. Dealing with the Americans’ management of the situation may have to wait until after the tear gas disperses and the last shots have been fired.

Revolution’s economic roots

Before the protests began, Egypt enjoyed strong gross domestic product growth — between roughly 4 and 8 percent over the last decade — and a boom in foreign investment over the past few years. The country’s large population, which made it an ideal place for investors given the sheer number of potential consumers, also helped feed socio-economic unrest. With an estimated 40 percent of the population living on less than $2 per day, poverty in Egypt has always been much more apparent than in most of the rest of the Middle East and North Africa.

While the country’s official unemployment figure was a manageable 9.4 percent in 2009, approximately 80 percent of that figure was comprised of people between the ages of 15 and 29. According to Egypt’s Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics, the labor force today stands at approximately 26 million and is expected to grow by 20 million people over the next 25 years. To avoid massive unemployment the country will need to accelerate its rate of job creation — currently about 400,000 jobs per year — to approximately 750,000 jobs per year.

That may not be easy to do if the current protests continue to have a negative effect on the economy, particularly on tourism. Cancelations of cruise stops and tours have been immediate; this is worrisome in several regards. According to international labor studies, tourism employs, albeit often not well-paid, substantial numbers of low-to-medium skilled people. Moreover, inbound tourism in Egypt is a strategic development sector and has seen greater growth than the economy at large, with 8 to 9 percent increases reported even during the economic stress years of 2008 and 2009.

It would be imprudent at this stage to project the impact of the January revolution on 2011 tourism earnings. However, in 1997, terrorist attacks on tourists in Luxor were linked to a drop in Egypt’s international tourism receipts of more than $1 billion in 1998. 

While a long-term downturn in tourism revenue has not been observed after limited terrorist attacks in countries such as Egypt and Turkey, the role of tourism in the Egyptian economy has expanded significantly, suggesting a potential amplification of economic detriment from even a one-year contraction. According to Euromonitor, tourism receipts in Egypt were estimated at $12.8 billion in 2010, with a significant medium-term gain from $9.3 billion in 2007.

Tourism aside, two other of Egypt’s main sources of income should not be threatened, unless all-out war is declared. The income from the Suez Canal, another one of Egypt’s key hard currency earners, is vulnerable to global economic issues but insulated from the local economy. However, while a shut-down of the canal at the moment looks like a super-long-shot threat, it would deprive the country of billions. In concrete terms, the revenue of the Suez Canal rose from $3.45 billion in 2005 to more than $4.5 billion in 2010.

Remittances — money sent home by Egyptian workers abroad — might be more likely to see a boost than a reduction. For fiscal year 2009/10 (FY09/10) which, in Egypt, ends on June 30, Egyptian central bank numbers put the amount of private inbound transfers — remittances mostly — at $9.5 billion.

The flow of foreign direct investments (FDI) and bond investments into Egypt warrants a measure of concern because of the economic importance of each, with FDI reported at $6.8 billion and foreign portfolio investment at $7.9 billion in FY09/10. Investments in the private sector economy as well as the operations of some major companies could face uncertainty; according to reports by Al Jazeera, protestors singled out government figure and tycoon Ahmed Ezz, whose Ezzsteel Group is described as the largest independent steel producer in the Middle East and North Africa and Egypt’s market leader.  

The institutional stability of Egypt’s ministry of finance and central bank will be watched carefully by international ratings agencies over the coming months. Monetary stability and the value of the Egyptian pound are among the concerns, while public sector finances could easily come under stress from attempts at appeasing social discontent through expansion of already massive cost-of-living subsidies, Moody’s warned on January 31. 

Street value

In the end, the durability of the current protests may actually depend on how long the poorest Egyptians can afford to stay on the street.

“You have to bear in mind that a lot of Egyptians are employed in the informal sector, which means that they work on daily wages,” says Sirgany. “In demonstrations they risk their lives, they risk being shot at, but they know for sure that they won’t have what will feed them on this day… But they’re still going on.”

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Feature

Spinning out of control

by Executive Editors February 21, 2011
written by Executive Editors

Hot on the heels of an international wheat shortage, the world cotton market is facing a similar supply crisis due to adverse weather conditions. The resulting record prices are a boon for Egypt’s dwindling cotton farmers, but have thrown the domestic textile industry, which relies nearly exclusively on cotton imports, into turmoil. 

India, the world’s second largest cotton exporter, instituted export controls in May, triggering a price rise which was further exacerbated by flooding in China, the world’s leading producer; Pakistan, the fourth largest supplier, was also affected. By December, cotton prices had reached an all-time high of more than $1.68 per pound, a near 80 percent hike on prices earlier in the year.

Normally accounting for around 40 percent of the world’s cotton production, China’s production is expected to fall 17 million bales below scheduled output in the 2010-2011 season. Also the world’s leading user of cotton, the Asian nation is now looking to purchase up to 20 million bales on the international market to meet demand from its large textile industry. 

This supply shake-up has naturally spread to the rest of the world — in Egypt, cotton farmers are counting their blessings while local textile manufacturers are relying on the state for assistance. To head off a crisis, the Egyptian government has exempted imported yarn from customs duties, while increasing subsidies for manufacturers using local raw materials by 50 percent. In addition, 280 million Egyptian pounds ($48.2 million) in aid money has been dispersed to spinning and weaving factories. 

Egyptian cotton has been a household name since the 19th century, when it was first exported around the world for use in bedding and haute couture. Its high quality long-staple cotton is still a niche market for Egypt, but it is the domestic textile industry, which requires cheaper cotton, that the government has opted to support.

Bringing in around $2.13 billion in 2009, textile exports are a major revenue earner for Egypt and account for around a quarter of total exports. Cotton was subsidized until the 1990s, with production peaking at 529,000 tons in the 1980-1981 season. The state scaled back its support of the industry, liberalizing sales in 1994 and removing protectionist tariffs in 2004, and production reached a low of 109,000 tons in 2008-2009. 

But with the global shortages, cotton is suddenly enjoying another day in the sun. After witnessing an uptick in prices, farmers increased the share of land dedicated to the crop at the beginning of 2010. An April report on cotton production in Egypt by the United States Department of Agriculture’s Foreign Agriculture Service predicted: “In 2010-2011, cotton area is expected to total about 160,000 hectares, or about a 34 percent increase [over] the area planted in 2009-2010.”

The gambit looks to be paying off: the Alexandria Cotton Exporters’ Association reported in January that its cotton contracts were $344.39 million for 2010-2011, compared to $117.3 million at the same time the previous year. Moreover, ongoing floods in Australia, another major cotton exporter, are a strong sign that prices will remain high for the remainder of the season. 

For Egyptian textile exporters, however, the cotton crisis could not have come at a worse time, having recently started to make inroads to the US and European Union textile markets where they face stiff competition from Chinese products. With China prepared to shoulder the high costs of cotton in a time of international shortage, Egypt’s government may need to take extra measures to protect its breadwinning industry.

February 21, 2011 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • …
  • 390
  • 391
  • 392
  • 393
  • 394
  • …
  • 685

Latest Cover

About us

Since its first edition emerged on the newsstands in 1999, Executive Magazine has been dedicated to providing its readers with the most up-to-date local and regional business news. Executive is a monthly business magazine that offers readers in-depth analyses on the Lebanese world of commerce, covering all the major sectors – from banking, finance, and insurance to technology, tourism, hospitality, media, and retail.

  • Donate
  • Our Purpose
  • Contact Us

Sign up for our newsletter

[contact-form-7 id=”27812″ title=”FooterSubscription”]

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
Executive Magazine
  • ISSUES
    • Current Issue
    • Past issues
  • BUSINESS
  • ECONOMICS & POLICY
  • OPINION
  • SPECIAL REPORTS
  • EXECUTIVE TALKS
  • MOVEMENTS
    • Change the image
    • Cannes lions
    • Transparency & accountability
    • ECONOMIC ROADMAP
    • Say No to Corruption
    • The Lebanon media development initiative
    • LPSN Policy Asks
    • Advocating the preservation of deposits
  • JOIN US
    • Join our movement
    • Attend our events
    • Receive updates
    • Connect with us
  • DONATE