Home For your information Country risk ranking drops

Country risk ranking drops

by Executive Editors

Lebanon saw its global country risk ranking drop by two notches, reinforcing its low position among the Middle East and North African (MENA) countries, according to Euromoney magazine’s twice-yearly survey. Ranked 109th globally, down from 107th in September 2004 – behind Cape Verde and Ecuador – Lebanon ranked 14th out of 19 MENA countries, scoring 36 points, well below the regional 49.14 average.

The country’s overall score regressed by 7% from the previous survey and declined by 3% on a year-on-year average.

The survey evaluates individual country risk by assigning a weighting to nine categories ranging from political risk to economic performance, debt indicators and access to bank finance. Lebanon maintained a perfect score on debt default and rescheduling, reflecting the country’s clean record in honoring its debt obligations, and also scored high on political risk and debt indicators. Lebanon scored lowest in credit ratings, access to bank finance and discount on forfeiting.

However the survey was conducted before the February 14th assassination of former premier Rafik Hariri. Since then, analysts say investors have tended to adopt a wait-and-see attitude, with no significant capital flight from the country having been registered since February.

Lebanese economist, Kamal Hamdan, maintains a positive outlook on the situation if the government meets its economic and fiscal obligations.

“Should this happen, we will be in good shape, because we are still benefiting from the effects of Paris II as well as this ‘beatific optimism’ as we characterize the behavior of investors here. It’s an optimism that goes contrary to rational economic behavior and leads investors to keep their capital and investments in Lebanon, despite the risk involved. This behavior has saved the economy from crashing time and again since 2001, and it looks as though it continues to do so.”

Beirut wins human resources award

Beirut was nominated first city in the Middle East for human resources (HR) by FDI Magazine, a publication of the Financial Times Group. Lauded for the standard of its schools and internationally recognized universities, the survey assessed the Lebanese capital to have the highest proportion of graduates among any city in the region, and came first for the quality of its academic institutions.

According to FDI, Lebanon’s 41 universities and 377 technical colleges have made it a center for regional learning.

“The educational sector has benefited from the country’s democratic institutions, and the fact that there has been no state interference in higher private education,” said Samir Makdisi, professor in economics at the American University of Beirut (AUB).

The survey indicated that Beirut’s high skills pool was a contributing factor in attracting foreign direct investment (FDI), which reached $2 billion in 2003.

“I haven’t seen the empirical evidence tying the level of education with the country’s FDI, but there is no doubt about the fact that a higher level of education contributes positively to economic growth and development,” Makdisi noted.

A high level of education combined with affordable wages by regional standards, make Beirut a city of choice for recruiters.

“All Arab countries like to recruit in Lebanon, especially Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Dubai and Bahrain,” said Dominique Safa, recruitment manager for the Beirut-based HR company Recruiters.

Makdisi painted a more nuanced picture. “Salaries aren’t necessarily lower across the board, there is a disparity. At the top level in businesses such as banks or private institutions of higher education, salaries are higher, making Lebanon more competitive with regards to other Arab countries, but not with the Gulf.”

Beirut was followed by Haifa in Israel, Doha in Qatar and Jubail in Saudi Arabia, as part of the survey designed to select the Middle Eastern Cities of the Future for 2005-2006.

Cutting down Cedars

Cedars, the second biggest-selling cigarette brand in Lebanon, has witnessed a drop in market share since February 2005, with some shop owners reporting a decrease of up to 50% in sales. The national brand which shot through the ranks of best selling cigarettes in the country largely due to its low price (LBP 750 per packet) is understood to be the smoke of choice for the country’s estimated 400,000 low-wage Syrian workers.

“Between 2000 and 2005, we experienced a 100% increase in sales,” says Antoine Madi of the Regie Libanaise des Tabacs et Tombacs, which produces the brand. “We did no marketing, nor any promotion. Sales went up due to the quality of the brand and its low price.”

Until January 2005, Cedars averaged annual sales of 80 million packets, giving it a 20% share of the Lebanese market, estimated at 7.5 billion “sticks” a year. It by-passed sales of leading international brands Winston, Viceroy, Gauloises and Gitanes, and briefly challenged Marlboro as the country’s leading brand. Since February however, perhaps as a result of many Syrian workers returning home, Cedars has slipped to second place.

 “We see two reasons for this,” said Madi. “An increase in counterfeited products on the Lebanese market, which is challenging our product, and the mass departure of Syrian workers in the country since the assassination of former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri.”

Illicit trade and counterfeited products remains a significant problem in Lebanon and the region. “It’s a big issue in this country,” said Naushad Ramoly, head of Corporate and Regulatory Affairs at British American Tobacco’s Levant and Yemen operations. “It’s a lose-lose situation for everybody: the consumers get products of poor quality, the country loses tax income and the tobacco companies suffer a drop in revenue.”

Habib Abdel Massih, the owner of a grocery store located next to a construction site in Gemmayzeh, says his shop has witnesses a 50% drop in sales of Cedars.

“The Lebanese prefer smoking Marlboro, Winston or Lucky Strike,” he explains. “They don’t trust the Regie to provide a quality product. Cedars is predominantly smoked by Syrian workers and the Lebanese living in the mountains.”

Apprenticeship put on hold

The Lebanese Broadcast Corporation (LBCI & LBC-SAT) much trumpeted plans to launch a pan-Arab version of NBC’s hit business TV show The Apprentice have been put on hold.

The 15-part series, scheduled to air in October, a month after the premiere of the rival CEO show, had already made announcements for casting and had signed up business mogul Mohamed Ali Alabbar as host.

Yet a media spat between Alabbar and the producers of CEO clouded the show in controversy from the start, leading to rumors of a pullout by the colorful chairman of the real estate development company Emaar-Dubai.

“The decision to put the show on hold until a more appropriate time was a unilateral decision made by LBC, which we were merely informed of,” an aide said, on condition of anonymity. “Mr. Alabbar will abide by their decision, but he had not expressed any desire to pull out of the show.”

LBC has refused to issue a public statement on the matter, but sources close to the production team say the casting has been put on hold and the shooting of the show postponed.

As of yet, none of the leading advertising agencies in Lebanon have entered negotiations on a sponsorship contract for the show, one of the largest sources of revenue for reality TV shows – another indication of the delays in launching the program.

A FreemantleMedia franchise, The Apprentice pits several contestants against each other in a bid to showcase their business savvy. Contestants are teamed up and made to solve a variety of business problems, negotiate deals and manage projects. The winner of LBC’s Apprentice was scheduled to walk away with a $300,000 a year senior position at Emaar-Dubai, working alongside Mr. Alabbar.

Bullish trade fair

In yet another testament to the continuing violence ravaging parts of Iraq, for the second year in a row, the country’s main trade show, dubbed “Rebuild Iraq,” was forced to kick off April 4th in a foreign capital.
In one sense, however, the setting for the four-day conference and expo in nearby Amman could not have been more appropriate: Jordan and last year’s host Kuwait have become the undisputed gateways for a deluge of consumer and industrial goods currently flooding the Iraqi market.
Unfortunately, for many Iraqi producers, the import binge has come at precisely the moment when they are least able to compete, leading to fears and impassioned complaints by some that Iraq’s productive sector is in danger of collapsing altogether.
In a sign of the frustration, one conference participant, who identified himself as “ one of the 25,000 Iraqi industrialists who are out of work,” upbraided an (inexplicably) bemused William Lash, US Assistant Secretary of Commerce, for having been more concerned with implementing a near zero tariff policy than supporting the already fragile domestic industrial sector.
In separate interviews after the conference, both Lash and Dr. Mehdi Al-Hafedh, Minister of Planning in Iraq, defended the Iraqi government’s ultra laissez faire approach to the country’s fragile post-war economy.
“All of our colleagues,” said Lash, “Ambassador Bremmer and all of his team spoke with the private sector and the interim government… When you are trying to attract capital in a very challenging environment you need to be as open as possible. The long-term future for Iraq is for opening her markets and opening her doors to capital, technology, ideas and partnerships, not restricting it.”
For his part, Al-Hafedh was less diplomatic in his assessment of the industrialists’ complaints. “Their problem,” he said, “is to always depend on the state, which is over now. We are in need of goods from outside in order to satisfy the needs of the local market. [Our policies] might be reviewed in the future, but the current need is to encourage imports from outside.”]


Investors head to Ras Al Khaimah

Ras Al Khaimah (RAK), among the UAE’s least developed emirates, is now positioning itself as a serious place for investment. To help promote this process, the World Bank is organizing an Investors Conference to be held in RAK 28-29 May. Under the heading “Invest and Live in Ras Al Khaimah” the conference aims to draw attention to RAK’s undoubted investment strengths. For a start, industries like glass, packaging, sanitary goods, pharmaceuticals, and tableware, which involve huge investments, are already exporting to more than 100 countries. Nevertheless, there is a lot of potential for more investments in manufacturing. RAK has also just begun to develop it tourism capability, and hopes to attract investors for constructing more hotels, golf courses and many forms of water based recreation and sport. All of this of course will act to promote other sectors, including real estate development, as has happened in Dubai. RAK’s public and private sectors launch a few weeks ago of the new real estate company, RAK Properties has thus been a timely move to promote real estate, leisure facilities and tourism.

RAK has considerable land that can be made available strategically for residential, commercial, and service industry development. A comparison of land prices between RAK and other emirates indicates great potential for this. Besides lower-cost land, RAK should be able to capitalize on its good environment and recreational facilities to attract investors. Strengthening of land use planning and management institutions is one of the priorities of the emirate. With the UAE Highway reaching RAK very soon, travel times to Dubai are being greatly reduced. This enhanced connectivity should make it increasingly feasible for people and businesses to locate in RAK and take advantage of the lower cost land there. More advanced transport such as high speed trains will eventually cut even these times down to make commuting to RAK even simpler. Travel from RAK to Dubai airport via the UAE Highway will be no more than 45 minutes. Success in this respect will establish RAK as a world-class investment destination in its own right.

Details of the coming “Invest and Live in Ras Al Khaimah” conference are available at investinrak.com.

Haifa not there yet

Dubai-based magazine Arabian Business recently published a list of the ten richest Arab singers. Top of the bill was Egyptian heartthrob Amr Diab with no less than $37 million, closely followed by Fairuz with $34 million. Diab’s fortune stems from record sales, concerts and – a staggering $17 million – from advertisement deals among which most notably his contract with Pepsi.

Taking into consideration Diab’s worldwide reputation spanning a 20-year-career, $37 million is not an unlikely nestegg. The same is true for Fairuz, one of six Lebanese singers on the list. The diva does not do commercials but has been performing for over half a century and currently charges up to $500,000 for a concert.

Less convincing were the alleged earnings posted for Elissa and Nancy Ajram. Elissa, whose duet with Chris de Burgh brought her brief international recognition, makes the fourth spot with a staggering $31.5 million. Music insiders say that this is far too high a figure for a singer whose first of her four albums was released in 1999. Nancy Ajram has supposedly clocked up $16.2 million, not bad for a 22-year-old with only two albums under her belt and a $500,000 Coca Cola endorsement. 

One notable absentee was starlet, Haifa Wehbe, who along with Nancy Ajram is Lebanon’s hottest selling artist and who was recently voted most popular Arab singer at the Lebanon’s Murex d’Or awards.

Wehbe’s manager, the alluringly-named Cynthia, defended her client’s pulling power by reminding Executive that Haifa, who charges $40,000 for a private concert, has just released her second album and will soon sign her first major advertising deal that would propel her into the big league. With an average of two  concerts a week in the summer season, Haifa has to work quite a bit before she sings herself into the top earners list, which is propped up by Zahleh’s favorite daughter Najwa Karam, who has to make do living on $13 million.

Danny Richa gets top job

Danny Richa, managing director of Impact BBDO in Beirut was elected President of the Lebanon Chapter of the International Advertisement Association (IAA) on March 30.

Richa is confident that, if Lebanon’s political situation changes for the better over the next few months, the sector as a whole will, despite the political setbacks, be able to match last year’s ad figures, which showed growth for the first time in years. 

“Lebanon has been here before,” he said. “In any other country the consequences of the crisis would have been much more disastrous.”

Richa believes that Lebanon’s leading advertisement agencies have been spared the current economic and political crisis. “We mainly work with international clients and brand builders who plan their strategies months ahead and so far all kept their promises,” said Dani Richa. “Unfortunately, it is the smaller agencies that suffer.”

Advertisement expenditure in Lebanon has been in gradual decline since 1999, when it peaked at $105 million, falling to $80 million in 2003. According to Stat Ipsat, TV advertisement expenditure decreased from $56 million to $33 million, press advertisement from $36 to $24, while only outdoors increased from $12 to $18 million over the same period.

“Last year we crawled back into the low eighties” said Richa. Hopes were high that growth would continue in 2005. According to some experts however, the 2004 figures did not signify a structural change for the better, but were boosted by the massive multi-media campaign for the Dubai Palm Island resort.

The IAA is a tripartite association representing the interests of advertisers, advertising agencies and the media with over 3,500 members in 89 countries.

Support our fight for economic liberty &
the freedom of the entrepreneurial mind
DONATE NOW

You may also like