Before the global financial crisis hit home, the main priority for banks in the UAE was how to decrease inflation rates. Another top concern in 2008 was dealing with the flood of liquidity streaming into the market, as well as currency speculation. But then, at the end of the second quarter, liquidity started to dry up, and immediately after the financial crisis climaxed in September banks became reluctant to give out loans as liquidity was so scarce. By the end of 2008, banks across the United Arab Emirates will have borrowed a minimum of AED70 billion ($19 billion) from the government. As of the beginning of November, banks had already received 80% of this liquidity package. Such a move aims to — most importantly — provide liquidity to the sector, in addition to easing tight lending requirements amid the continuing global financial crisis. Raj Madha, director of equity research at EFG-Hermes, thinks that the government “has been doing quite a good job” via pumping liquidity into the banking system and thus has been “very successful in bringing down interest rates.” Standard & Poor’s (S&P’s) announced in a recent report that the tightening liquidity conditions in the UAE are “only tangentially related to the global credit crunch and are being driven mainly by a host of country-specific factors, including speculative investor activity surrounding the UAE dirham’s peg to the US dollar, rapid domestic growth in recent years and concerns over the real estate sector.” Even though banks in the UAE have been growing at 40-50% per annum in the last two to three years, this will “inevitably slow,” said Eirvin Knox, chief executive officer of the Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank, to Bloomberg newswire.
With the country’s economy heavily based on development projects, the market will inescapably witness a slow down as projects will be more difficult to finance and loans harder — and more expensive — to acquire. And if liquidity dries up again, “funding future projects will, however, become more difficult, thereby affecting the UAE economy’s hitherto extraordinary growth,” according to S&P’s. But, a simmering in growth “would not necessarily be a bad thing,” argued S&P’s, “as it could alleviate infrastructure and resource bottlenecks that had been stoking inflationary pressures, as well as reduce the risk of a significant oversupply in the real estate market.”
As the UAE real estate index had declined by 46% in July 2008, banks have also been affected by some of the property market’s concerns. S&P’s stated that by the middle of this year, the UAE’s direct exposure held somewhere between 15-20% of their total loans and 80% of their adjusted total equity. Overall, a colossal decline in real estate prices would, undoubtedly, negatively affect the banking sector, via direct exposures and indirectly through the depleted value of the collateral taken.
Solid vaults
All in all, domestic banks in the UAE show robust financial profiles distinguished by high profitability, good asset quality and strong capitalization. Third quarter results have been, in general, “strong” according to Madha. Despite the significant write-downs that took place, they were not as big as expected. “They are having to change their lending criteria, but that is what you would expect in a rescue environment,” he said. Regarding short-term stability in the immediate aftermath of the global financial crisis, UAE banks have stabilized thus far.
Since year-on-year growth has been rather remarkable in the UAE, “the thirst for credit has been substantial,” noted S&P’s. But while a part of this has been quenched by external borrowing, the local banking sector has satisfied most of the credit needs. S&P’s contended that loans granted by UAE banks have expanded annually by an average of 35% in the past four years. Following Qatar, “this is the fastest rate of loan growth observed in the Gulf.” The pace of growth, underlined S&P’s, “even accelerated in the first half of 2008 (to about 50% annual increase), boosted by massive borrowings from government and government-related entities to expand their business domestically and internationally.” Although customer deposits also grew rather briskly, they could not keep up with the excessive growth in lending. Thus, by the end of June 2008, the loan-to-deposit ratio exceeded 100% for the entire banking sector. Now, with an ongoing era of uncertainty, banks must keep their eyes open to any and all possible solutions to these new long-term problems.
The temptation for mergers and acquisitions has thus never been more appetizing for those banks suffering from the crisis. Mashreqbank, the UAE’s largest private bank, has said it is only open to a merger if “one plus one equals three” — i.e. if both parties involved will benefit from the activity — said the bank’s chairman, Abdul Aziz Al-Ghurair. The CEO of the National Bank of Abu Dhabi, Michael Tomlin, has also said the bank would welcome a merger, emphasizing that “we need to be bigger to compete effectively on the global stage.” With over 50 banks throughout the Emirates, financial institutions have had little impetus to merge until the recent global crisis. Right now, the majority of bankers are keeping mum about the possible need for mergers and acquisitions. No one wants to be kicked while they are down and voicing a desire to merge or be acquired is viewed as a sign of weakness. In November, Sultan bin Nasser Al Suwaidi, governor of the UAE Central Bank, said the bank would support any mergers and acquisitions if that would help soften the blow of the international financial crisis on the local economy. Madha, however, does not see any advantages to mergers and acquisitions, feeling that it “would take up a lot of airtime and a lot of management time. You want management to be focused on liquidity issues and managing risk, not busy with M&A activity.” For the time being, banks are displaying more interest in expanding abroad than integrating domestically, but in the long run, integration could be something to consider.
Forecasts
In the medium term, the UAE banking sector faces a few challenges in terms of future growth and profitability. In the coming period wholesale funding will be harder to attract, and cost more. S&P’s forecasted “a potential moderate deterioration in asset quality in the medium term. On the liabilities side, banks are expected to step up their competition to attract additional customer deposits to fund their growth and keep their liquidity at satisfactory levels.” The ratings agency expects UAE banks “to continue to re-price lending risk, which should act as a significant buffer to overall profitability.” Madha highlighted that loans for share purchases — potentially a derivative exposure — will be a chief concern for Emirati banks in 2009. Another major issue will obviously be provisioning, said Madha, “and that will depend on how the labor markets do, and again, the labor markets are not as solid as they have been in the past. We’re certainly seeing a reality check in the labor markets at the moment.” A further principal obstacle, asserted Madha, is the continuing lack of visibility in the system. “The fact that there is effectively no communication between the government and analysts — I see it as significant risks,” he said.
For the future, Madha is concerned with long-term stability in the banking sector. He feels this will heavily depend on the performance of the real estate market in the UAE: “if the property sector holds up, then the banking sector should be fine.” Al Suwaidi, however, firmly holds that the UAE’s banking sector is strong enough to deal with any corrections in the real estate market. Keep your fingers crossed for the banking sector, because the real estate market seems to be facing some serious downturns in 2009. Overall, next year banks in the UAE will continue to try to stabilize whilst facing numerous challenges.
