Executive Magazine

Searching for a sense of perspective

by Thomas Schellen June 3, 2012

written by Thomas Schellen

Indices, indexes, rankings and ratings. Never have there been more measures competing for attention than today. At the end of May, two ranking reports with relevance to Arab markets were released within two days of each other. The International Finance Corporation released its Doing Business in the Arab World 2012 (DBAW 2012) report and the Swiss-based global business school IMD released its 2012 World Competitiveness Yearbook (WCY).

The DBAW report tells us, in a nutshell, that Saudi Arabia has the best framework of business regulations for domestic companies in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) — ranked first among 20 Arab countries and 12th worldwide — and that Morocco was the country which made the greatest progress in improving its business environment in 2010/11, on a regional and global scope.

The WCY tells us that Qatar is the most competitive Arab economy — ranked 10th in IMD’s global review of 59 countries by 329 measurements — and that the United Arab Emirates was the country that made the greatest progress globally in competitiveness in 2011, advancing from 28th place to 16th.

The two reports are presumably a boon for the corporate executive who wants to choose a new market or manufacturing location. The IFC measures the level of development that regulatory frameworks have reached in 183 countries and the WCY exhaustively examines 59 countries for competitiveness on the basis of business and government efficiency, business performance and infrastructure. That is, of course, if the said executive has enough time on his hands to pore over hundreds of pages and evaluate the information that is provided.

DBAW is not a slim specimen of the report genre at 123 pages, and the WCY feeds nicely into the assumption that smart people will never stop reading, at over 300 pages (that’s excluding the expanded, detailed country profiles). Also for consideration is the Global Competitiveness Report 2011/12 by the World Economic Forum (WEF), another popular global reference and home of the Global Competitiveness Index (GCI). Covering 142 economies, it is a tome burgeoning with lists after lists, sub-rankings upon sub-rankings, filling nearly 550 pages. Thankfully there are electronic versions.

rankings

Curious details
A curio about the WCY is that the 15 most competitive economies in its ranking collectively represent just more than eight percent of the world population and do so only because of the United States, the WCY’s second most competitive economy, contributes some 55 percent of this headcount. Moreover, the top 15 in the WCY are not at all countries driven to improve their comparative economic edges by population expansion; Malaysia, number 14 in the list, stands in as number 75 in global population growth and all other 14 highly competitive countries are on record for comparatively low population growth.

Another note to ponder about the leading competitiveness reports is that both their producers, although each collaborates with research partners around the world, are based in Switzerland (ranked third by WCY and first by WEF). After banking services and those time measurement complications, the reports appear to form another market where Swiss qualities seem strong enough to inculcate oversized or even monopolistic positions.

Of course competitiveness reports are just one type of ranking report that have gone viral with the information age. Measurability is the undercarriage of management; convergence of global markets and production locations puts corporations and large organizations, whether in economy, public sector or civil society in an absolute need for comparative reports. This need has been answered by an army of knowledge economy producers, whose reports rank everything from financial centers to human happiness in comparative reports and handy lists.

Limited criteria, skewed results
In step with technological and scientific progress, the methodologies of global research reports have evolved to ever more sophisticated models. However, even the reports produced by top-tier institutions such as the IFC and leading academic entities such as IMD often disclose rankings or developments that smack of distortions or otherwise can startle the reader.

For example, a category of the DBAW 2012 report ranks countries for the ease with which businesses can access electricity. Lebanon is ranked in seventh place of 20 Arab countries and in one of the top 50 places worldwide for that particular category. Anyone who has ever done business in Lebanon or ridden in an elevator in the country knows of the annoying frequency of power cuts. The DBAW criteria, focusing on the time, cost and number of interactions required to get an electricity connection, do not mention reliability of electricity supply. But what good is knowing that it takes only a short time to get a warehouse connected to the grid when the grid operator cannot deliver the power?

In the WCY, the UAE acheived an improvement of 26 positions, from 34th to eighth, in a particular bracket of the business efficiency sub-category. Strong gains in a single year may be possible, but this particularly large leap upward was reported in the “attitudes and values” bracket. Attitudes change over time, the assumption goes usually, not overnight.

One will find room for questions in every index and rankings report, whether its subject is a single index based on measuring one performance area, a composite index collating several pillars into one ranking and offering the sub-rankings for better understanding, or a meta-index that consolidates other research reports under a captivating header such as Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index.

Besides having to digest and present more data than is comprehensible over a morning coffee, flaw factors in rankings include methodological omissions and at least three other components that one should be aware of: biases, data uncertainty and simplifications. The sources where one might look for these flaw-factors are business leaders, governments and media.

Surveys of business leaders and decision makers are a standard component of many rankings reports, for example the competitiveness reports by both IMD and WEF. Business leaders are usually opinionated and often biased. How common is it to meet a manufacturer or trader who will tell you that his competitor’s products are a better deal than his own, or that his own country of production is not a great location to manufacture his product?

Margins of error in rankings are not the first topic discussed by the providers of rankings who have themselves an incentive to appear as reliable and authoritative as possible. However, producers of the reports are well aware of the bias issue, which a researcher on the WEF’s report called “the halo effect”.

Secondly, not all data should be taken as equal. When governments produce projections of next year’s gross domestic product (GDP), any experienced business leader will assume that not all estimates will hit the bull’s eye.

Population estimates for a large country are very difficult or even impossible to verify, with all sorts of potential digressions in subsequent calculations. Plus, while we like to think of our governments as being honest, data supplied by government institutions and close affiliates to competitiveness researchers may, just may, in extremely rare cases, be a little bit more polished than they should be [think Greece pre-financial crisis].

But the biggest nightmare is the media. Take any rankings report and the media will redact its detailed and complex findings into something akin to a list of test results on the wall of classroom in third grade. Where the researchers explain that their report shows small actual changes resulting in a country’s rise in the percentiles of a ranking for a complex area such as labor market efficiency but that the change is not indicative of much at all, the media will scream that ‘Country X’ gained 20 ranks and is now top of the heap.

Stripping away the sensationalism, the rankings report in the knowledge economy is the business leaders’ Hamlet experience — to trust or not to trust, that is the question. According to Hisham el-Agamy, an Executive Director at IMD in charge of the Middle East Africa, Southeast Asia and Southeast Europe, governments and business investors use a competitiveness report as a “map to understand the country” but “any serious institution which wants to invest in a country does not only consider a single ranking.”

June 3, 2012 0 comments

Finance

Mounting fees

by Maya Sioufi June 3, 2012

written by Maya Sioufi

While it is still too early to assess the wider repercussions of the government- mandated wage increase this year, it is already irking Lebanese banks, coming at a time when banks are also compelled to increase spending to comply with mounting regulations both locally and internationally.

As one of the largest private sector employers, with roughly 21,000 employees as of the end of 2011, the salary increases, applied to all bank employees across all brackets, are “significant money,” says Nassib Ghobril, chief economist at Byblos Bank. As of February 1, the government has raised the minimum wage by 35 percent to LL 675,000 ($450) while increasing salaries by an average of LL 299,000 ($200) for income brackets above LL 675,000.

“As competition for talent in the region was increasing in previous years, we had to raise salaries and so we had already experienced a significant cost increase in the whole sector, ” says Walid Raphael, chairman of Banque Libano-Française. “Now, along with a reduction in growth of the economy, we are imposed with an increase in the cost of human capital. This has a major impact on the sector.”

In the first three months of this year, staff expenses at Alpha banks — the 12 banks with deposits in excess of $2 billion that account for 85 percent of the banking sector’s deposits — were up by 12 percent year-on-year to total $293 million, according to research firm Bankdata Financial Services. By comparison profits totaled $370 million during the period.

While the banking sector has strong fundamentals — it is still witnessing growth in assets and deposits albeit at a slower rate — its declining growth in profitability is making it more difficult to swallow the additional costs, a pain felt more vigorously by the smaller banks than the larger ones. “For the big banks which have large enough profits, they can manage, for the smaller ones, it is more difficult,” says Fadi Osseiran, general manager of BlomInvest Bank.

The regulation burden
The increase in salaries has been accompanied with an increase in costs for complying with additional international and domestic regulations — more software and staff needed. Those new regulations include Basel III and the United State’s Foreign Accounts Tax Compliance Act, while domestically Lebanon’s central bank has introduced new regulation aimed at curbing money laundering.

While the actual cost of compliance has yet to be calculated, the smaller banks are in a less favorable position to absorb the shock — as reflected by the drop in profits of the total banking sector relative to the Alpha banks. The sector’s growth in profits dropped by three percent in 2011 but the Alpha banks’ profits were up one percent, highlighting the struggle of the smaller banks. “Given that competition is increasing and that the larger banks are better prepared to face competition, I think the smaller ones will be impacted the most,” says Ghobril.

To pull through in more difficult times, consolidation may have to be considered. “We have been hoping that consolidation would eventually happen and it did not,” says Raphael, who added that he expects this to change. “We need the right people with the right skills, we need to train them so it is becoming a big burden for smaller banks.”

Jean Riachi, chairman of FFA Private Bank, believes that as competition gets tougher, smaller banks will have to merge with larger ones and he expects this to take place “in the future.”

As Byblos’ Ghobril says: “When you have a growing pie, there is enough for everyone but when the pie stops growing, then definitely the better prepared players are ready to adjust to this environment.”

This article was published as part of a special report in Executive's June 2012 issue

June 3, 2012 0 comments

Real estate

History under siege

by Jeff Neumann May 6, 2012

written by Jeff Neumann

In the arena of Lebanese architectural heritage some combatants are better at the game than others. Today activists, archaeologists, politicians and real estate developers have entered the stadium to battle it out over what is probably Lebanon’s oldest sporting venue. At issue is the fate of a Roman-era hippodrome downtown in Wadi Abu Jamil. Unchecked construction and the rush to build mega-sized steel and glass towers have taken a toll on historical sites in the city for nearly 20 years. The hippodrome site is privately owned and most of it has already been developed and built over, but a remaining plot of land in the middle of the former track has become the focus of many interests, all angling for different outcomes.

Some two thousand years ago the hippodrome hosted horse and chariot races. Today, it sits neglected in the heart of Beirut’s rebuilt downtown of exclusive villas and upscale shopping areas. Overgrown with tall grass and littered with garbage from nearby construction sites, it is almost impossible to imagine the hippodrome’s former glory. Assuming that you can get past the heavy security to even approach the site, the hippodrome today is virtually indistinguishable from any other neglected ancient ruins. But in spite of its current state, it has great significance: Lebanon is home to two out of five Roman hippodromes in the Levant — one in Tyre, and its twin in Beirut. The hippodromes of Lebanon are unique because they are the only ones in the world adjacent to Roman baths.

The great irony of the situation is that some of the loudest critics are largely responsible for the current state of the hippodrome. In March, former culture ministers Tamam Salam and Tarek Mitri held a press conference denouncing plans to build over the open remainder of the site. But the sale and development of various plots at the site in the preceding years were approved by both of them. Solidere, the private company in charge of reconstructing Beirut Central District, justified this earlier development using in-house archaeology experts. Development started by moving Roman-era baths to a different location nearby [see map], and progressed to the point where former Prime Minister Saad Hariri built a large private residence and garden squarely on top of the hippodrome.

So tight is the security at the site that current Culture Minster Gaby Layoun and his top advisor, Michel de Chadarevian, were not allowed past the rusty metal walls that have long encircled the area. “I went there with the minister last month and they would not allow us to even have a look,” de Chadarevian says. “We asked Saad Hariri’s office to let us look around, but we were denied access. We are not even allowed in to remove the grass.” Executive was directed by Hariri’s office to Future Movement Members of Parliament Salam and Nabil de Freige for comment, but neither was available for comment.

Build over, preserve under?

After signing off on development of much of the site, in 2009, Salam, then culture minister, placed the hippodrome on a list of protected historical sites, but the damage was already done. An area surrounding the reconstructed Maghen Abraham Synagogue was all that was left and today represents the plot of contention.

According to the culture ministry, the owner of the undeveloped plot, Nazem Ali Ahmed, consulted Italian architects to find a solution that would generate revenue, while also meet the requirement of having the ruins available for public viewing. His solution, while still in the early stages of development, is to construct a roofed, open air museum. The ruins would be viewable underneath thick glass flooring from walkways and landings. A second level would be reserved for retail and commercial space. Its height will be limited by the current regulations laid out by Solidere, the ministry says. Solidere did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

De Chadarevian says that the current plan to preserve the hippodrome is based on similar efforts in Greece to enclose ruins under glass and install modern walkways and viewing areas. He explains to Executive that the ministry is “happy to have an investor interested in creating and building a museum for free. We will not pay anything. He will do everything and we will all benefit.” (There have been unconfirmed media reports of a $30 million Kuwaiti-funded hotel and museum on the plot.)

This plan set off a public outcry from preservationists and archaeologists. Josef Haddad, founding member and current secretary of the Association for the Protection of the Lebanese Heritage, disputes the notion that a glass enclosure would preserve the ruins. “The glass will trap the heat and humidity and accelerate the deterioration of the site,” he says, pointing to the fact that Rome’s ancient ruins are largely out in the open and exposed to the elements. Under the current plan, portions of the ruins downtown, excluding the fragile section that was once spectator seating, will be removed during construction and replaced when the building is complete.

“We are surprised that out of all ministries, the Ministry of Culture is working the hardest to destroy the hippodrome,” Haddad says. “It belongs to the Lebanese people, not private landowners.” Haddad says that he and the Association for the Protection of the Lebanese Heritage “are doing our best to halt the process,” but adds that a real solution can only come from Solidere, Nazem Ali Ahmed, and the culture ministry.

Jeanine Abdul Massih, professor of archaeology at the Lebanese University, does not believe that constructing what would essentially be a shopping mall over the ruins would do the site justice. “If you want to really preserve it you need to take the whole thing, not just a part of it,” she says. “If you only preserve part of it, what do you really have left of this beautiful stadium? You cannot preserve just a part of a stadium to give an idea of what it was like.” Abdul Massih suggests protecting and restoring the entire site, and adding it to a Beirut historical walking trail. “We need to connect the people with the history,” she says.

Little room left to fight

“We are preserving this place — if the ministry could destroy all that Solidere has done in order to regain all of our antiquities, we would be very happy,” de Chadarevian says, striking a somewhat populist tone. In preservationist circles that might normally be a welcome statement, but he does not hide his contempt for activists seeking to reach a new deal for the hippodrome. “All the campaigns on Facebook, this is rubbish,” he says. “I asked them, ‘do you know what this is? Have you ever gone there and had a look around?’ No, they have not. So why are they even talking about this?”

According to de Chadarevian, the root of the problem is the location of Hariri’s home, and his former cabinet members using their influence to steer development deals. “The only problem is that new construction will block the view from Saad Hariri’s residence,” he claims, and points blame squarely at the two previous culture ministers: “[Tarek Mitri and Tamam Salam] agreed to destroy what remained of the hippodrome years ago.” Several members of Hariri’s Future Movement have rejected this claim.

Professor Abdul Massih suggests a land swap between the Beirut municipality and Nazem Ali Ahmed could resolve the dispute and come as close to satisfying all parties as possible. But the prime location of the hippodrome means this is a highly unlikely outcome. The current construction plan for the hippodrome site has top-down blessing, from Prime Minister Najib Mikati to the Ministry of Culture, as well as Solidere and the Beirut Municipality. Now, the municipality’s final approval of the building plans is all that stands in the way of commercial development at the hippodrome site. [No one from the Beirut Municipality was available for comment].

For those seeking full preservation, the overall outlook is grim. It is also nothing new, says Abdul Massih. “So many other beautiful things here have been destroyed, so nothing would surprise me,” she says. “But I will fight to preserve it.”

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Real estate

For your information

by Executive Editors May 6, 2012

written by Executive Editors

Real estate market “flat”

The overall number of real estate transactions in Lebanon dropped 4.29 percent between January and February. But while the number of overall transactions was down — 5,156 in February from 5,387 in January — the nationwide average value per transaction rose 6.66 percent over the same time period. The total number of real estate transactions fell by 12.02 percent last year to 82,984, compared with 94,320 transactions in 2010. Over the same year, the value of real estate transactions fell to $8.84 billion, compared to $9.48 billion in 2010. According to a Bank Audi report, Lebanon’s property market has shown “a somewhat flat performance” during the first two months of the year. According to year-on-year data, the total number of transactions fell 0.82 percent in the first two months of 2012, while the total value of transactions dropped $40 million to $1.16 billion. Using figures provided by the Order of Engineers, the report also notes a 3.5 percent overall rise in the number of construction permits issued across Lebanon this year. The data shows a 9.1 percent drop in new permits in Beirut and a 19.2 percent rise in the Mount Lebanon region.

Rent-to-own law passes cabinet

The Council of Ministers, Lebanon’s cabinet, approved a new draft rental law in late April, which would allow low-income families to buy property by making yearly or monthly payments. The Cabinet also agreed to amend a controversial rental law that, if passed, would allow landlords to raise rents by 20 to 80 percent over a four-year period [see page 30]. The Association of the Owners of Rental Buildings issued a statement the following day praising the passage of draft law 767, but also asked the Administration and Justice Committee of Parliament to “enter a new stage that ends the accumulated injustice against old landowners on the issue of rents” by quickly passing the law on to the General Assembly, and to establish a government fund to assist low-income renters who intend to buy residential property.

MENA construction drops

The value of construction projects awarded in the first quarter of 2012 across the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) has fallen more than 30 percent from the first quarter in 2011, according to Citi Research and Analysis. Approximately $18.5 billion in projects have been awarded between January 1 and March 31 in the MENA region, the research unit of Citigroup Global Markets said in its MENA Construction Project Tracker, a monitor that tracks projects from announcement to completion. The comparison figure for the first quarter of 2011 was $27 billion. The cumulative value of projects awarded in March was $4.3 billion, the lowest figure for the year-to-date according to Citi Research. With 76 projects awarded in the year so far, the number of projects was similar to the same period in 2011. “Project awards are generally lumpy,” the report says, while forecasting spending to show “ongoing strength” because of MENA governments’ “desire to avoid unrest” in the wake of the Arab Spring. Kuwait accounted for 38 percent of project values in the first quarter, followed by Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates with 16 percent, or $2.9 billion, each. However, the report noted that Kuwait’s leading share is derived mainly from one single $5.9 billion aviation-related project.

Needing more malls

An apparent dearth of retail space in new residential areas across Abu Dhabi is dragging down property prices, according to a report by UK-based property consultancy Cluttons. “A shortage of retail facilities at many of the new residential developments needs to be addressed, the lack of which is seen as a culprit to falling values,” the report said, before the opening of Cityscape Abu Dhabi last month. According to Cluttons, “Apartment values have been affected the most, with Al Reem and Marina Square apartments falling 7.4 percent and 7.3 percent, respectively, on third-quarter 2011 prices.” Abu Dhabi-based real estate consultancy CBRE also released data that shows residential apartment rents in the city are down 18 percent in the first quarter over the same period last year, and are down 3.5 percent since last quarter. Also at Cityscape, the National Bank of Abu Dhabi (NBAD) announced that its new wholly-owned subsidiary, NBAD Investment Management (DIFC) Limited, had been approved to start a real estate investment fund focused on “income-generating properties.” Zain Abdullah, senior executive officer of NBAD’s new unit said in a statement, “We believe that this fund will offer regional and international institutional investors a diversified avenue to access the UAE real estate market within a strong regulatory environment.”

UAE banks boost credit, offer 100% mortgages

As the United Arab Emirates’ property market continues to struggle, Emirates Islamic Bank announced in mid-April that it would offer 100 percent mortgages to UAE nationals. “For most people, owning a home is one of the biggest lifetime investments and provides an opportunity to build equity in real estate,” said general manager Faisal Aqil, speaking to The National in April. The new loans will be available for first time buyers or for buying off-plan, and can be approved within 24 hours. Variable rates will start at 4.99 percent. Home prices throughout the UAE have been trending downward in recent years, with Dubai as the exception, posting a meager 0.5 percent rise in home prices in 2011. In a statement to reporters, Abu Dhabi’s Aldar Properties announced a $1.09 billion credit facility from the 70 percent state-owned National Bank of Abu Dhabi. In addition to helping the developer manage its liquidity, the deal will be a three-year revolving facility to cover everyday operating costs.

Corruption ties and net loss for Egypt’s SODIC

Egypt’s third-largest property developer, Six of October Development and Investment (SODIC), posted a net loss of $32 million for 2011, after registering a profit of $22.4 million one year prior. In a statement, the company offered a stronger assessment of its operations, saying, “During a tough 2011 SODIC preserved the strength of its balance sheet, improved cash collection delinquency rates, increased receivables and maintained healthy levels of cash on hand.” Prior to the report, SODIC issued a statement about its former chairman Magdi Rasekh, who in April of last year was sentenced to five years in prison and fined $388 million for his role in an illegal land deal under the Mubarak regime, saying the ruling would not affect “the firm’s assets or the assets of the rest of its shareholders.” Also, last month, the Egyptian government announced a plan to sell nearly 8,000 plots of city land and certificates of deposit to expatriates living in the Gulf. By appealing to wealthy Egyptians living outside the country, the government hopes to raise some $4.5 billion with the new plan, which would also allow Egyptian joint stock companies to purchase land with a guaranteed 4 percent, one-year return on the investment. Additionally, any financing for the properties must be done through financial institutions based outside of Egypt.

Saudi prince seeks big tower loan

Kingdom Holding Co, Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal’s investment company, is seeking a loan worth as much as $533 million by this summer to help pay for the construction of the Kingdom Tower in Jeddah, according to a Bloomberg report last month. According to plans, the Kingdom Tower will be more than 1,000 meters tall, with an estimated finishing cost of $1.2 billion. The building plans, drafted by Saudi Binladen Group — a 16.63 percent stakeholder in the project’s owner, Jeddah Economic Co — were approved by municipal authorities in February, and the project is expected to take over five years to complete after construction starts. When finished, the Kingdom Tower will become the world’s tallest building, surpassing Dubai’s Burj Khalifa, which stands at 829.84 meters.

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Banking & Finance

Financial quotes of the month

by Executive Editors May 6, 2012

written by Executive Editors

“How can we grant bills of health from these [government run] labs when rats are running everywhere?”

Mohammad Choucair, head of the Beirut Chambers of Commerce

“The country will manage well, even if we don’t sell a single barrel of oil for two or three years.”

“In Silicon Valley, there’s still too much money chasing too few ideas. If your idea is brilliant and your timing is right, you can become a multimillionaire overnight.”

Paul Saffo, Silicon Valley forecaster on Facebook’s $1 billion acquisition of popular photo application Instagram

“Spain is not going to be rescued; it’s not possible to rescue Spain, there’s no intention to, it’s not necessary and therefore it’s not going to be rescued.”

“God willing, we will take the loan before a president for Egypt is in place.”

Mumtaz al-Saeed, Egyptian Finance Minister, on the proposed $3.2 billion International Monetary Fund loan

“Tonight, Senate Republicans voted to block the Buffett Rule, choosing once again to protect tax breaks for the wealthiest few Americans at the expense of the middle class.”

Barack Obama, President of the United States

“I feel great — as if I were in my normal excellent health. And my energy level is 100 percent.”

Warren Buffett, billionaire investor legend when diagnosed with prostate cancer

“Investments in tourism are extremely good despite the fall in the number of tourists entering Lebanon through Syria.”

Fadi Abboud, Lebanon’s Minister of Tourism

“At times, elections can lead to uncertainties and, for investors, to a changing configuration of opportunities and risks. We are entering such a phase in Europe.”

Mohamed el-Erian, CEO of Pimco, the world’s largest bond investor, on the upcoming French, Greek and Irish elections in Europe

“If you wake up the morning after and still feel like the gazelle is running from the lion, or the lion is running for the gazelle, then everything is ok.”

Fadi Ghandour, after resigning as CEO of Aramex, the delivery and logistics company he founded and managed for 30 years

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Banking & Finance

The expert opinion MENA stock tips

by Executive Editors May 6, 2012

written by Executive Editors

Black is still the dominant color on the market screens this year as equities continue their upward drift. In the midst of first-quarter corporate earnings season, which so far have proved resilient, investors are increasingly concerned that a correction is on the horizon as macroeconomics headlines remain frail. For this month, Executive speaks to Elie Khoury, cheif executive of Berytus Capital and Nour Eldeen al-Hammoury, chief market strategist at Amana Capital for their investment recommendations.

Elie Khoury

Bullish or bearish?

Khoury is conservatively bullish on the markets in the United States and slightly bearish on Europe, as the US enjoys much better fundamentals than Europe. He believes equities will continue their upward trend because, “With central banks from the US to Europe to England pumping all this money, they are inflating everything which is why equity markets performed so well since beginning 2012 until today.” He adds that if the US unemployment and housing picture improves, he will be buying equities more aggressively.

Main concerns?

Khoury’s greatest concern is banks’ exposure to derivatives. “At $188 trillion, this exposure is 14 times the size of the United States’ [gross domestic product]” he warns. In the short term, Khoury is mainly concerned with the economic issues in Spain and Italy; he adds that issues in Greece might resurface in May during the upcoming elections.

Favorite asset classes?

Khoury favors equities. “The summer time will provide us with many opportunities. Markets will correct and investors will get the opportunity to invest,” he says. Khoury’s top sectors to invest in are technology and consumer products.

Specific names?

He likes Pfizer in the pharmaceutical sector, Kraft in the non-cyclical consumer goods sector and Microsoft, Intel and Qualcomm in the technology sector. Khoury also highlights Costco, Home Depot, McDonalds and Starbucks as stocks he would be buying on the basis of their relative weakness to benefit from lower entry points.

MENA equities?

While deterred by the unrest in the region he notes that it is “putting a floor on the price of crude which is good for Saudi Arabia so it is the only country in the region we could be positive on.”

Nour Eldeen al-Hammoury

Bullish or bearish?

Hammoury warns against buying aggressively due to the very slow economic growth and the fact that the United Kingdom is back in recession. “The crisis is not over yet and it needs a minimum of 10 years to solve,” says Hammoury. He does not expect the recent rally in equities to continue and he is awaiting a correction in the markets, as “the waves of the tsunami are still rolling.”

Main concerns?

Hammoury’s largest concern is the oil market, as a “higher oil prices are not good for the global economy.” He is also concerned with the sovereign debt crisis in Europe and the lack of transparency from politicians. “We saw an ‘Arab Spring’, we could see something of the sort in Europe as well,” warns Hammoury.

Favorite asset class?

He would stick to gold and recommends buying between $1610 and $1625 per ounce. Within equities, Hammoury would remain in defensive sectors (such as utilities, consumer goods and telecoms).

MENA equities?

He is not interested in investing in the region at this point, but he does highlight that the abundant cash reserves in MENA governments’ coffers provide support in these turbulent times and “the continuous high prices of oil that will carry on stimulating reserve cash for governments.”

Specific buy?

His top stock globally is Apple. He sees it going to $700 or to $800.

Any name in the MENA region?

He likes Dubai-based Tabreed, also known as the National Central Cooling Company.

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Banking & Finance

For your information

by Executive Editors May 6, 2012

written by Executive Editors

Banking secrecy exceptions

Banking secrecy was lifted on 18 accounts in Lebanon last year according to the annual report of the Special Investigation Commission (SIC), an independent entity established 10 years ago by the Banque du Liban (BDL), Lebanon’s central bank, to fight money laundering. Of the 18 cases, five were referred from abroad and 13 were from domestic sources. In 2011, the SIC received 335 suspected cases, up from 245 in 2010 and 202 in 2009. Of the suspected cases, 100 were from foreign sources and 235 from local sources and the SIC investigated 285 cases. Counterfeiting, accounting for 13 percent of all reported cases, was the most common crime, followed by terrorism funding at 8.5 percent of reported cases, fraud of private funds at 6 percent, narcotics trade at 4.5 percent and embezzlement of public funds at 3 percent. Sixty five percent of the cases were not categorized. “Reporting entities were assessed via extensive on-site examinations and follow-up corrective measures were imposed,” according to central bank Governor Riad Salameh.

Eurobond oversubscribed

A $700 million Lebanese Eurobond issued last month was 30 percent oversubscribed, resulting in a boost to the finance ministry’s coffers. The first tranche of the Eurobonds brought in $600 million, up from the original plan to raise $350 million. It carries a 5 percent yield and matures October 12, 2017. The second tranche brought in $350 million as originally planned. It carries a 6.4 percent yield and will mature on April 27, 2026. Non-Lebanese accounted for 30 percent of the subscribers with the remaining issuance taken up by the local banks, holders of the majority of Lebanon’s hefty debt. Byblos Bank and Bank of America-Merrill Lynch were the lead managers on the Eurobond. The proceeds of this issue are to refinance $293 million and 115 million euros ($151 million) in Eurobonds which matured in March and April 2012, respectively. Lebanon’s finance ministry revealed earlier this year that it will be issuing $5 billion worth of Eurobonds and treasury bills to cover the public debt in 2012.

Qatar-Swiss mining mega merger

Qatar’s sovereign wealth fund, Qatar Investment Authority (QIA), has invested a whopping £1.7 billion ($2.7 billion) into Switzerland-based mining giant Xstrata. With a five percent holding, QIA now becomes Xstrata’s third largest investor after Glencore, the largest publicly traded commodities supplier, with a 34 percent stake, and asset manager Blackrock, with a five percent stake. This aggressive move comes ahead of a planned £23 billion ($36 billion) mega merger between Xstrata and Glencore and increases the chances of the deal tilting in Glencore’s favor. Aside from Blackrock, most of the top 10 investors are critical of the deal and want better terms from Glencore. Under the proposed deal, Xstrata shareholders would receive 2.8 Glencore shares for every share they own, but many shareholders want at least 3.6. Ivan Glasenberg, chief executive officer of Glencore and Mick Davis, CEO of Xstrata, are going on a global road show in the coming weeks to convince investors to agree to the “merger of equals”.

Egypt close to IMF loan

Egypt’s finance ministry expects to secure a $3.2 billion loan from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) by May 15, before a new president is elected to run the country at the end of June. However, the deal, which has already been delayed from March, faces a significant obstacle. The Freedom and Justice Party, the Muslim Brotherhood’s political arm that holds almost half the seats in the new parliament, is heavily critical of the IMF loan, and has suggested several other options, such as collecting overdue taxes or re-evaluating gas export deals. The party says it is not outright opposed to the loan, but wants either better terms or the creation of a new government — not due until after the presidential elections — to oversee the distribution of the funds. According to Egypt’s finance minister Mumtaz al-Said, “Egypt needs $10 billion to $11 billion in the next 18 months to bring back economic stability.” Egypt has hemorrhaged more than $20 billion in currency reserves since the February 2011 revolution, which overthrew former president Hosni Mubarak. Whether Egypt succeeds in securing the loan remained unclear as Executive went to print.

Kafalat loans drop

The loan guarantee company Kafalat gave out $33 million loans to small and medium enterprises in the first three months of the year, down 21 percent from the same period last year. The number of loans dropped 20 percent to reach 240. The industry sector accounted for 36.7 percent of the total guarantees; the agriculture sector took 36.3 percent of total guarantees, while tourism accounted for the next 20 percent of the guarantees. Geographically, Mount Lebanon accounted for the majority of borrowing, taking up 44 percent of the loans, followed by North Lebanon at 16.3 percent, Bekaa at 15.4 percent and South Lebanon at 10 percent. Beirut accounted for just 7 percent of the loans.

$100 million for MENA infrastructure

The International Finance Corporation (IFC), part of the World Bank Group, and the Islamic Development Bank (IDB) plan to invest $100 million in infrastructure projects in the Middle East and North Africa region. Each institution will be investing $50 million into the Arab Infrastructure Investment Vehicle, part of the Arab Financing Facility for Infrastructure (AFFI), an initiative led by the World Bank, the Islamic Development Bank and IFC. The AFFI assists in financing and technical issues for cross-border infrastructure projects and encourages governments and the private sector to contribute to the development of these projects. The purpose of the investments is to spur economic growth in the region. MENA countries need to invest $70 billion annually in infrastructure to sustain their growth rates, according to the IFC, which invested approximately $2 billion in the region in 2011.

Financing Tunisia

Qatar has agreed to lend Tunisia $500 million at an interest rate of 2.5 percent, to be repaid in five years. The Gulf state was one of the main foreign backers of the revolution which overthrew longtime president Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali and resulted in the Ennahda party coming to power in Tunisia in October last year. Earlier this year, Turkey opened a $500 million credit line to Tunisia, repayable over 10 years. The United States recently announced that it aims to help finance the economic recovery in Tunisia by providing “several hundred million dollars” of loan guarantees before the end of June, according to the US Department of the Treasury. The Tunisian economy is still struggling following the political upheaval that shook the country last year. The International Monetary Fund forecasts 2.2 percent gross domestic product growth in 2012 and 3.5 percent in 2013, while expecting the unemployment rate to drop 2 percent this year to 17 percent.

Aabar dumps Daimler

Abu Dhabi’s Aabar Investments, a government-owned company engaged in investing across sectors and countries, is reviewing its portfolio of overseas investments and intends to completely exit its investment in Daimler, as well as in the Formula One cooperation and Tesla Motors, the luxury electric carmaker, according to Germany’s Manager Magazin. Aabar acquired a 9 percent stake in the luxury carmaker by injecting 1.95 billion euros ($2.56 billion) in March 2009, which it reduced to a 3 percent holding in February after the surge in the price of the shares. The share price at the time of the investment stood at 20.27 euros ($27); as of 21st of April it was trading at 41 euros ($54), up 100 percent from the price that Aabar paid. Abu Dhabi National Energy (TAQA), an oil explorer and power supplier majority owned by the government, sold its 7 percent stake in Tesla Motors in April, making a profit of $113 million. In April, Aabar nearly doubled its stake in Dubai builder Arabtec to 10.45 percent.

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Economics & Policy

For your information

by Executive Editors May 6, 2012

written by Executive Editors

Popped for pills

The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA), which represents most of the major pharmaceutical corporations in America, has petitioned the United States Trade Representative to put Lebanon on the 2012 Priority Watch List. They have complained that there is a lack of adequate intellectual property protection in the Lebanese pharmaceutical market. While it was noted that the new industrial property law passed in 2000 represented a major step forward from the 1924 law, PhRMA claim it does not provide sufficient pipeline or transitional patent protection and gives an incomplete definition of confidential information. Another point of contention the US body raised was the ministry of public health’s failure to implement sound regulation practices to distinguish between innovative and generic medicines. The Ministry of Public Health was also mentioned for having failed to successfully crack down on parallel imports, which result in a ‘grey’ market of counterfeit medicinal products in the country. Lebanon was one of 17 countries from the region recommended for the black list, including Israel and Algeria.

Figures for thought

The most recent figures from the Ministry of Finance indicate that the total fiscal deficit for 2011 of LL3.5 billion ($23 million) was LL833 million ($555,333) less than its 2010 equivalent. These figures are the result of a LL1.37 trillion ($924 million) increase in revenues, or 11 percent, which offset the 3 percent increase in expenditures of LL553 billion ($368.7 million). It is important to note that the fiscal deficit saw a healthy decrease in November 2011 when the budget surplus from the telecoms ministry was paid, which was LL2.3 trillion ($1.53 billion) compared to LL957 billion ($638 million) in 2010. Despite the growth in total revenues, the tax contribution to the public purse actually decreased mainly due to a slowdown in the taxes on international trade, with decreases in excises and customs by LL590 billion ($393.3 billion) and LL33 billion ($220 million), respectively. Lebanon’s loss-making electricity company significantly increased its burden on the public purse, requiring an extra 46 percent in transfers reaching LL2.6 billion ($173 million) in 2011. Gross public debt continued to creep up over the same period, rising by just less than 2 percent to LL80,869 billion ($53.6 billion) in 2011.

Lebanon failing its women

Lebanon ranked 6th in a survey on women’s socio-economic advancement from a selection of 8 Middle Eastern countries. The MasterCard Worldwide Index on Women’s Advancement used indicators such as tertiary education, employment, business ownership and leadership positions to assess the standing of women in society in comparison to their male compatriots. Only Egypt and Saudi Arabia scored lower than Lebanon, while Bahrain, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Kuwait and Oman were deemed to have a better record in women’s advancement. Interestingly, Lebanon had the lowest proportion of female business and government leaders. Conversely, Lebanon had the highest rate of regular employment opportunities for women.

Prizing open the bandwidth

Lebanon’s Internet capacity will be increased from the current 23 Gigabits per second (Gbs) to 33Gbs within two months and to 43 Gbs within four months, according to plans unveiled by the Ministry of Telecommunications (MoT). The government intends to increase capacity by making increased use of the India-Middle East-Western Europe (IMEWE) submarine cable, which runs from Mumbai to Marseille. Lebanon became a member of IMEWE consortium in December 2010 and started limited use of the fibreoptic cable in June 2011. What’s more, Lebanon and Cyprus agreed in February on the principles of cooperation for the Europa submarine cable, which would complement the IMEWE, but Lebanon’s cabinet is yet to endorse financing of the project. With regards to the tariff structure, MoT proposals for unlimited nighttime usage between 12:00 am and 7:00 am have been approved.

The MENA’s stunted growth

Growth has stalled and the outlook is uncertain in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, according to the International Monetary Fund’s (IMF) 2012 World Economic Outlook. Among oil exporters, high oil prices contributed to growth of 4 percent, while among oil importers growth was only 2 percent in 2011, even after the exclusion of data from Syria. Looking forward the baseline forecast is for growth of 4.25 percent in 2012 and 3.75 percent in 2013. Among the oil importing nations, strong oil prices, anemic tourism associated with social unrest, and lower trade and remittance flows reflecting ongoing problems in Europe are the major challenges that lay ahead. The IMF identifies the reorientation of fiscal policies toward poverty reduction and the promotion of productive investment as a key medium-term fiscal policy objective.

Less tourists spending more money

The number of tourists coming to Lebanon in the first quarter of 2012 decreased nearly 8 percent on the same period in 2011. However, despite the fact the number of visitors to Lebanon fell, the amount of money they spent actually increased. According to Global Blue, the VAT refund operator for international shoppers, total tourist spending increased by 36 percent in the first three months of 2012 compared to the same period in 2011. The rise in spending by visitors was in a large part due to the fact that there had been a severe contraction in tourism in 2011, especially in the first half of the year. In early 2012 visitors from the Gulf flashed the most cash, with guests from Saudi Arabia accounting for 22 percent of total tourist spending in January.

Fueling the future

Starting in 2015, Lebanon looks set to turn to Liquid Natural Gas (LNG) to meet its growing energy demand. In early April, The Ministry of Energy and Water, launched a call for expressions of interest to build, own and operate a floating storage and regasification unit (FSRU), which is recommended to be at least 125,000 cubic meters (m³) in size with a regasification capacity of up to 3.5 million tons per annum (mtpa), according to the tender document. The deadline for companies’ proposals, which can be used for a new FSRU, existing FSRU or a vessel conversion, is June 4. Lebanon already has two combined cycle gas turbines (CCGT), but according to the MoEW the country also plans to increase the number of gas-fired power plants, which will gradually lift its LNG requirement from 1.2 mtpa in 2015 to 1.7mtpa in 2016, and up to 3.5mtpa by 2022. The FSRU will be located in the north of the country near the majority of its current and planned CCGT capacity and it is slated to operate on a tolling structure, whereby MoEW would pay a fixed monthly capacity fee to the FSRU owner, and then a monthly throughput fee for operating costs incurred for actual usage.

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Editorial

Parliament’s reckoning

by Yasser Akkaoui May 6, 2012

written by Yasser Akkaoui

Given the opaque functioning of the Lebanese state, it is good that sessions of the Parliament are open for the public to see. Unfortunately, they are akin to vultures tearing apart a carcass. In some 62 speeches and 28 hours of debate that took place over the three-day session last month, there were screams and accusations, name-calling and finger pointing, with hardly an allusion to progressive public policy.

In utopia, parliamentarians represent their constituents’ demands before the convention of government, which then attempts to fulfill these demands within resource constraints. In Lebanon, the Parliament is utterly detached from the lives of the Lebanese, its members asserting the interests of their sectarian overlords and the public purse fought over for plunder.

For years now Lebanon’s enterprising and entrepreneurial private sector has been surrogate mother to a people abandoned by the state, spurring new business and generating new wealth and employment. But even the private sector can only slow Lebanon’s current slide. Among many other issues, Beirut has become expensive well beyond the means of most of its residents.

Paying “old rent” has allowed hundreds of thousands of Lebanese to scrape by and afford their other costs of living, but it has effectively been a subsidy the private sector pays in place of government policy to address public housing needs. This warped rental market has led to dangerously dilapidated buildings, the decay of heritage structures and stunted economic development. A draft rental law that has resurfaced after lying dormant for years would phase out old rents, but its vagaries on public housing mean it will almost certainly fail to help people afford homes.

In utopia, parliamentarians would engage in earnest debate and develop legislation that would leave a lasting legacy. In Lebanon, pursuing policy development seems far from parliamentary minds, but at least they let us know.

Their reckoning may be nigh, however, with increasing public protests in the country showing a gathering rage that may soon force accountability upon those who were elected to serve the public good.

May 6, 2012 0 comments

Economics & Policy

Lebanon’s awkward first steps

by Zak Brophy May 3, 2012

written by Zak Brophy

For more than 14 years Lebanon has watched in frustration as neighboring Israel and Cyprus have searched for and discovered rich reserves of hydrocarbon fuels under their maritime waters. Political instability and ineptitude had ensured that Lebanon remained a jealous bystander during this period. However, the passing of the first implementation decree pertaining to the Offshore Petroleum Resources Law on January 4 suggested that the country was finally on course to join the bonanza.

A short flurry of hubristic statements for the press at the beginning of the year suggested the petro-dollars would soon be bulging from the state’s coffers, providing plenty for all. However, while credit must be given to the Ministry of Energy and Water (MoEW) for having finally got the show on the road, some faltering and somewhat dubious occurrences suggest the country has stumbled as it shoots out of the starting blocks in its race for hydrocarbon riches.

Gebran Bassil, minister for energy and water, confidently told reporters back in January that the Petroleum Administration (PA) would be named within a month, the first tender round would begin within three months and the first exploration contracts would be signed by the end of the year. However, as Executive went to print at the end of April, the PA had yet to be appointed.

“This administration is the most important thing for the pre-launching of the exploration rounds and the tender rounds,” says Roudi Baroudi, an independent energy consultant and secretary general of the World Energy Council’s Lebanon member committee. “Once the PA has been nominated they can immediately move ahead with the different consultants they have to start preparing the bid rounds for exploration and to define which blocks they would like to have the companies bid for.”

From council to council

The passing of the decree approving the bylaws of the PA in early January should have immediately paved the way for the creation and staffing of the PA. However, on January 29 the Shura Council, Lebanon’s administrative advisory body, issued an opinion noting no less than 51 points of contention with the decree. In a copy of the document obtained by Executive, the first point raised is that it is incumbent upon ministers to send decrees to the Shura Council before they are sent to the Council of Ministers (COM), Lebanon’s cabinet. It notes that in this case the Shura Council was bypassed and the decree was submitted directly to the COM.

Cesar Abou Khalil, advisor to the energy minister, said, “The Council of Ministers re-voted on this decree and confirmed it, so it is pointless to discuss what issues the Shura Council has raised now that the Council of Ministers has used its prerogatives and have confirmed it. It is confirmed and in vigor.”

Shura council rulings on decrees are advisory, but they ensure that they are harmonious with Lebanese laws and the constitution. However, the course of events ensured that the COM was caught in a bind whereby, even if they had wanted to, it would have been difficult to adopt the Shura Council recommendations after already issuing the first decree. In such a scenario they would have been obligated to pass a revised decree, which would have left them looking both incompetent and inconsistent in the eyes of the prospective oil companies. The COM voted on March 21 to ignore the Shura Council and proceed with the January decree in its original form.

The majority of the 51 points from the Shura ruling are for minor technical details, but some significant issues are raised with regards to the independence enjoyed by the PA. For example, the Shura Council ruled that article 6 of the decree that gives the minister power to impose punitive sanctions on the PA, including a deduction in benefits, was in contradiction to the Offshore Petroleum Resources Law passed on August 24, 2010. In that law the PA is afforded financial and administrative independence under the Wasiyeh, or tutelage, of the MoEW and it is the level of control incorporated into this Wasiyeh to which the Shura Council took exception.

Abou Khalil from the MoEW, however, argued, “[The Petroleum Administration] is purely advisory… They have administrative independence because they are named by the COM and only the COM can dismiss them. The minister cannot dismiss any of them. But by law 132, [August 28, 2010] it is an advisory body to the MoEW. Under our watch, there will no breach to the constitution. The minister is the head of his sector.”

According to Abou Khalil the ministry is fighting a precedent set during the time of former Premiers Rafiq and Saad Hariri, as well as Fouad Saniora, which “hollowed the ministries by creating these independent bodies which are under the tutelage of the prime minister… The oil sector should be under the minister and it is the same in all of the ministries.”

Another significant objection of the Shura Council was to the proposed rotating chair of the PA. Under the MoEW plans the six members will each spend a year presiding over the body, which breaks with the convention of appointing one chairperson within such bodies. Opposition member of Parliament and head of the Parliamentary Energy and Public Works Committee, Mohammad Qabbani, is opposed to the level of control the MoEW is set to have over the PA arguing, “The idea of the presidency rotating between the six members will only weaken the power of the administration.”

Abou Khalil confirmed this was for all intents and purposes true, but argued that it is a positive and necessary development: “When there is a rotating presidency there is a cross auditing between the members… This sector, we believe, will become one of the main drivers of our economy and development in the near future. We need to be tough on this issue, we don’t want to create another body that can become stronger than the government.”

The COM is within its rights to either heed or ignore judgments by the Shura Council on proposed decrees, but the fact that the Shura Council was not initially consulted, as is both protocol and law, and topics of considerable import were later contested, hardly sets a promising precedent for the development of this nascent industry.

Filling seats in the PA

Malek Takieddine, a Beirut-based legal consultant who works closely with international oil companies in the United Kingdom and Iraq, pointed out that the delay in appointing the members of the petroleum administration has been a cause for concern for some oil companies. Nonetheless, he argued there is still strong interest from international players in Lebanon’s play, given the initial achievements of the ministry.

With the decree in its original form re-voted on by the COM, Prime Minister Najib Mikati told Parliament in mid-April that the PA would be announced within the month, and as Executive went to print the government was in the process of selecting candidates through the Office of the Minister of State for Administrative Reform and Development (OMSAR).

There was a time lag of some three weeks between the passing of the decree in March and the launching of this process, raising concerns that the major political players had tried and failed to barter the PA appointments before moving to the more formal approach. Going forward, which strings will be pulled to influence the appointment of the PA and the PA’s day-to-day operation remains an open question.

“If a minister decides to go through a procedure where there is deliberating, accepting applications and examining CVs before taking it to the Council of Ministers then we hear such accusations,” said Abou Khalil. “And if we propose the names right away to the COM they scream ‘oh, they brought their guys.’”

The oil and gas industry is incredibly complex, with large sums of money at play, and so the PA requires high caliber professionals with extensive and particular skills —however, qualified candidates will not be easy to land.

One of the pre-requisites for applicants is 10 years experience in the industry, but Takieddine reasoned, “It needs to be clarified when we say experience, it needs to be specifically upstream.” In common speech upstream is a reference to stages within the industry such as exploration and production, while much of Lebanon’s current involvement, and therefore skill-base, in the sector is in downstream activities such as marketing and distribution.

Furthermore, industry opinions point out that the wages envisaged for members of the PA, while being hugely generous for a Lebanese government employee — expected to be around $10,000 per month — would be considerably lower than similar-level private sector posts in the oil and gas industry. The majority of Lebanon’s talented workers with suitable upstream experience are based abroad and the government may struggle to lure them home with such wages.

The MoEW’s Abou Khalil dismissed these concerns, assuring that the quality of the applications were more than up to scratch. “They will be stunned when they see the CVs,” he said, and while acknowledging that the wage would be small compared to what could be expected from comparable posts with major oil firms, he was confident that enough talented Lebanese would want to share in the development of this potentially very lucrative sector for the country.

As with all public sector posts there is an age limit for applicants, which in this case has been bumped up from 35 to 57. However, Takieddine argued that the posts on the PA are perfectly suited for highly skilled and experienced people who are near, or past, retirement age, and would be more likely to accept a considerable drop in pay in order to return home and take on these important and challenging roles. Although the maximum age is 57 he argued an exception could be beneficial in this case. When asked if the MoEW would consider such a move Abou Khalil responded, “Then we would have a real problem with the Shura Council…We have pushed it to the maximum that we could.”

Perhaps one of the biggest hindrances to filling the PA with qualified people is the rigmarole of satisfying the sectarian divide. Within the pool of grade one posts in government, such as the PA, there has to be a balance in the representation of Muslims and Christians according to the constitution. However, over the years, it has become protocol to balance the allocations not just across the whole body of grade one posts but in every administrative body across the country’s main religious sects. Qabbani argued, “It should not apply to every administration. It should be a ratio that applies to the whole basket of first grade positions. It’s suicide.”

Considering the massive importance of administering and managing the oil and gas sector properly, there have been calls for the PA to be staffed purely on ability. “In the current arrangement qualifications and merit are not being sought after but rather it will be the blackmailing of each community against the others,” says Yahya Hakim, board member of the Lebanese Transparency Association, the local arm of the global anti-corruption organization. “Each community will be putting [forward] someone who speaks in their name, not someone who can really run the show. So all of the issues will be political and not in the hands of the professionals as it should be.”

Although it is only a legal requirement to balance the sectarian ratios across all first grade posts, and not in every administration, it seems that this practice will still be applied to the PA. “We will employ people with the best capabilities while respecting the Lebanese system,” said Abou Khalil, in reference to the sectarian balancing act in top level recruitment.

Minister Gebran Bassil has surrounded himself with a technical staff that has worked assiduously to lay the groundwork for the development of Lebanon’s oil and gas sector. Some progress is being made. However, the irregular way in which the decree was passed raises concerns over the integrity of the approach. All eyes are now focused on exactly what kind of body the PA will be and what role it will play in the evolution of this embryonic, yet potentially vital, industry.

May 3, 2012 0 comments