• Donate
  • Our Purpose
  • Contact Us
Executive Magazine
  • ISSUES
    • Current Issue
    • Past issues
  • BUSINESS
  • ECONOMICS & POLICY
  • OPINION
  • SPECIAL REPORTS
  • EXECUTIVE TALKS
  • MOVEMENTS
    • Change the image
    • Cannes lions
    • Transparency & accountability
    • ECONOMIC ROADMAP
    • Say No to Corruption
    • The Lebanon media development initiative
    • LPSN Policy Asks
    • Advocating the preservation of deposits
  • JOIN US
    • Join our movement
    • Attend our events
    • Receive updates
    • Connect with us
  • DONATE
North Africa

Banking

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

The Algerian government’s decision to delay the privatization of Crédit Populaire d’Algérie (CPA) has met with a mixed reception. While one of the banks involved in the bidding had called for suspension of the sell-off and labor unions have applauded the move, others have questioned the government’s fundamental commitment to privatization.

State banks are responsible for almost 95% of deposits and credits in the Algerian banking market. Despite their high levels of non-performing loans, they have retained the support of the authorities, particularly since the collapse of Algeria’s biggest private bank in 2003. However, the much-delayed CPA privatization had seemed to be a sign of renewed confidence in private banking.

On November 24, 2007, the government announced it had suspended the final bidding process for the sale of a 51% stake in CPA, the country’s first privatization of a public bank, to reassess the effects of the global mortgage crisis on the Algerian market. The announcement came two days before technical bids for the bank were scheduled to have been opened and will delay the privatization beyond the target date of the end of the year.

Deputy finance minister Fatiha Mentouri has said that the privatization process will recommence after the global effects of the collapse in the US sub-prime lending market have become apparent.

Citing “uncertainty” caused by the crisis, Mentouri said that “the opening of the sale has been postponed until there is some clarification about the international financial markets.”

However, no set date has been specified by the government and the delay could be longer than optimists might anticipate.

CPA has a 12% market share and assets totaling around $6 billion, and is seen as a prime candidate for banks hoping to expand their operations in Algeria, or establish a foothold there, without a capital outlay that runs to many zeros. The CPA privatization initially attracted France’s Crédit Agricole, Banque Populaire and BNP Paribas; Citibank, from the US; and Spain’s Santander when bidding opened in late 2006. However, Santander withdrew its bid in May to concentrate on expanding its operations in Europe and Citibank retired from the fray to attend to the wounds inflicted on it by over-exposure to the sub-prime market. Meanwhile, the government’s decision to postpone the technical bidding process came the day after Crédit Agricole called for more time.

Santander’s retreat, Citibank’s withdrawal to the sidelines and Crédit Agricole’s request for the process to be temporarily halted may have given the government a reason to re-open the bidding process to ensure greater competition and guarantee the bank makes its forecast $1.5 billion sale price.

However, for others, it is yet another unnecessary hold-up to the process which has already taken too many years. The CPA privatization plan was first drafted in 2000 and the sale slated to be completed by the beginning of 2007. However, the process was sidetracked by the collapse in 2003 of Khalifa Bank, Algeria’s largest private lender, which led to the uncovering of widespread corruption and mismanagement across the Algerian banking sector. This was a blow to confidence in private banking and caused the authorities to reconsider their policy. In the wake of the Khalifa scandal, the government barred private banks from lending to public institutions and prioritized strengthening the system and fighting corruption ahead of privatization.

The latest suspension has caused doubts that the government’s heart is really in privatization.

Former Algerian treasury minister Ali Ben Ouari has said that he is skeptical about the government’s stated reason for the suspension of bidding, noting that most of the bidders have not been affected by the sub-prime loss. Ben Ouari has warned that the government may be considering limiting foreign ownership in CPA. Given the fact that the economy is now in considerably better shape than when the privatization was first proposed, a majority stake may be offered to a domestic partner instead.

The government has also come under considerable union pressure to halt the privatization and the decision to postpone the sale indefinitely garnered praise from unionists representing CPA employees.

The halting of the sale calls into question not only the privatization of CPA but of the process of banking privatization in Algeria as a whole. The Banque de Développement Local is lined up for privatization this year and bidders will be watching recent events with interest. If the CPA sell-off suspension turns out to be a permanent change of heart, the banking sector as a whole risks being marooned from modernity in terms of technology, capital and the improved services that competition would engender.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
GCC

Arab Media Group

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

Skyscrapers are not the only structures to tower above the UAE’s golden sands. Dubai, the business hub of the emirates is bracing itself for yet another new media comer: the Arab Media Group (AMG), a Dubai government communication company and part of TECOM (Dubai Technology, Electronic Commerce and Media Free Zone Authority). According to Patrick Samaha, the company’s head of marketing, “AMG was founded in 2005 and currently includes nine radio stations, three newspapers, television stations, printing and distribution activities, an events management arm and outdoor advertising.”

The company was initially launched in 2001 under the name ARN (Arabian Radio Network), which has since morphed into eight radio stations — Dubai Eye, Dubai 92, Pulse, City, Hit, Noor Dubai, Al-Khaleejiya, and Al-Arabiya. The most recent addition is the station Virgin Dubai, a branch of Virgin International.

Today, the company is a full media group. With a workforce of 2,000 employees, occupying four office premises in Dubai as well as other locations in the country, the company has sprawled into various sectors of media activities. “We are not called the Arab Media Group for nothing,” boasts Samaha, “we provide different media across the entire spectrum.”

MTV and Nickelodeon Arabia

Recently, the company has gained wide publicity for its television deals with MTV and children’s network Nickelodeon, through its broadcasting division Arabian Television Network (ATN). The subsidiary will incorporate MTV Arabia as well as four other channels, three of them to be launched before the end of 2007.

The children’s channel, Nickelodeon Arabia, is scheduled to begin broadcasts in 2008. According to AMG, it will reach into a market of more than 36 million TV households and its potential audience is estimated at 190 million people across the region. According to Samaha, “Programming will include a mix of international content from Nickelodeon’s portfolio as well as local Arab productions.” Nickelodeon Arabia is part of a long-term relationship between AMG and MTV Networks International. “It is a great partnership that we are actively building on,” Samaha added. “This cooperation will allow us to produce programs that are reflective of local culture and values, something that also defines our approach to the MTV Arabia station.”

The latter is the first TV music brand to specifically target the youth in the Arab region. The Dubai station features both international and Arabic music combining international content with Arabic productions of popular MTV programs. The station is managed by Arabs for Arabs with the MTV crew currently including people from different nationalities, such as Lebanese, Egyptians, Jordanians, Saudis, and others. The marketing manager also pointed out that MTV programs will be adjusted to local cultures and sensitivities. The channel is showing Hip-HopNa (Our hip-hop), a show that will be co-hosted by a Saudi rapper and Palestinian-American producer Fredwreck (Farid Nassar), who has worked with Snoop Dogg, 50 Cent, and other music industry giants. Farid Nassar was in Lebanon a few months ago hosting a rap contest organized by MTV in Beirut. “We are not only concerned with what is fashionable but also by what is right for our region, and we do not intend on moving away from this philosophy. Today, we are aware of the responsibility that comes with engaging Arab youth. While AMG brings the world to the Middle East, it also brings the Middle East to the world,” explained Samaha. MTV viewers seem to agree: according to the network, 60% of respondents loved MTV Arabia’s new website.

The online division, Arabian Digital Network (ADN), which complements other areas of AMG’s activity is in the process of introducing 18 websites by early 2009 with www.MTVa.com among the first websites to jumpstart the process. AMG has also experimented with ShoofTV.com, a website for posting user-generated content.

Publishing and events

Also falling under the AMG umbrella is its publishing arm, Awraq, showcasing English language newspaper Emirates Today, its Arabic counterpart Emarat Al-Youm, and the Arabic broadsheet Al-Bayan.

Events management has also become a focus of AMG, which has created a subsidiary division, Done Events, which among other things, is bringing world-class shows to Dubai, like the Broadway musical “Chicago” in 2006. 

AMG owns an outdoor advertising company, Shoof. “We are the fastest growing company in this particular segment,” Samaha pointed out. In addition to previously listed segments, AMG operates a logistics and distribution company, Tawseel, and a printing press, Masar. Tawseel will be offering advanced distribution and logistics support to the media industry, comprising retail and direct marketing activities, as well as subscription management facilities for local, regional and international publishing houses.

“AMG is aware of the media’s growing role, and offers an experience of seamless and perfectly integrated services,” added Samaha. According to the manager, the company’s diversified product base facilitates and enhances its market position while adding to its overall strategy. “When you use the name Arab Media Group, you need to feature the full line of media products. When it comes to commercialization, we are definitely more efficient as a group; we work in a full surround sound effect. It also makes more business sense for our clients, since we can reach out to a broader audience by using more than one choice of medium whether, radio, TV or outdoor media.”

The Group’s target market varies also from one sector of activity to the other and, according to Samaha, AMG’s audience differs from a local to a regional one depending on the medium used. While MTV Arabia targets Arab youth, the radio arm, ARN, targets Gulf nationals, other Arabs, Westerners as well as Asians. “You can call us a media solution provider. We create content, write it, publish it, print it, air it, advertise and sell it. I believe we are the only group to offer an A-to-Z approach, across so many vehicles, and this is why we are called the Arab Media Group.”

When asked about Abu Dhabi Media Company, the new rising media star of UAE’s capital, Samaha answered, “Competition is good and allows us to strive for the best. Evidently, there is always a need for new groups. We produce consumer goods, and the UAE’s growing population implies the need for a larger variety.” He believes that AMG has helped shape the industry by offering a large basket of brands under one banner. “We are not launching just any product but a very special one, and I believe that for now growth lies mainly in television, but who knows what tomorrow may hold?”

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
GCC

Missing out on Iraq

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

Several hundred Kuwaiti trucks a day roll over the Abdaly border crossing into Iraq, where the containers are then transferred onto Iraqi vehicles for the onward journey. Meanwhile, at the Safwan border crossing, only 40 minutes away by car, over 1,000 trucks a day pass through the Virginia-Hobari military camp to enter Iraq.

Such a difference is not an indicator of Iraq’s economic particularities or the security situation. Trade with other immediate neighbors — Syria, Turkey, and Iran in particular — is resurging, with Tehran and Damascus benefiting the most.

What this disparity really shows is that nearly five years after the invasion of Iraq, Kuwaiti cross-border trade is still predominantly traffic for the US military and associated dependents.

This reality runs against the grain of one of the expected economic spin-offs of the overthrow of the Saddam Hussein regime, that Kuwait would become the Gulf’s logistical hub to access Iraq’s emerging market after decades of hostility and minimal economic interaction.

But Kuwait’s barriers to foreign investment, negligible sea and air trade due to infrastructure shortcomings, and overly zealous, yet equally lethargic customs officials who create logistical headaches, are all holding back Kuwait’s transit hub potential.

Bolstering relations

“After the invasion there was a flood of companies coming to base themselves here but after several months they pulled out and went home due to the vague tax and investment laws,” according to Hani Mhanna, the chairman of the Iraq Trade Bureau in Kuwait.

By law, Kuwait requires foreign businesses to be 51% owned by a local investor, as all the GCC countries required in the not-so-distant past. But Kuwait is lagging behind other Gulf countries in revoking such measures, which have been dropped by the likes of the Emirates and Qatar, in efforts to attract FDI and diversify away from oil revenues.

With taxes as high as 45%, and foreign companies faced with paying taxes twice, to the government and the company’s local in-company representation, Kuwait’s draconian FDI laws have also resulted in foreign companies entering into illegal practices to bypass regulations to establish a local presence.

“This taxation on foreign investors is stopping companies from setting up here. It’s been a mess and not enhanced since the 1960s,” Mhanna noted, adding that this has affected cross-border trade with Iraq to the benefit of other countries that have inked bilateral trade agreements with Baghdad.

According to vice president of General Trading and Contracting in Kuwait, Lorie Killingsworth, logistics are coordinated through only a few countries. She said, “Foodstuffs are all from Iran and Turkey. I was surprised. But they are pretty much the only countries that will deal with Iraq.”

Iran has seen trade blossom with Iraq over the past five years, with Iraq’s direct purchases standing in 2007 at $2 billion, and a further $2 billion more in ‘exchanges of kind.’ And this, suggest analysts, is only the tip of the iceberg.

The Islamic Republic has numerous plans in Iraq, including establishing a car plant near Baghdad, funding industrial projects, constructing two 300,000 barrels per day pipelines between Basra and Abadan, as well as building electricity generators in the south. The most recent electric generator in Sadr City is worth $150 million and produces 160 megawatts. Tehran has also signed bilateral trade agreements with Iraq’s Kurds, with trade estimated at $1 billion in the past year.

Turkey, meanwhile, accounts for some $4.9 billion of Iraq’s imports, roughly 23% of the $20.8 billion imported a year. This is primarily with Iraqi Kurdistan, with Turkey accounting for 80% of FDI in the semi-autonomous area.

However, Istanbul is mulling selective economic sanctions against the Kurdish area due to ongoing forays by Kurdish rebel groups based in Iraq against Turkish forces, which prompted multiple military incursions late last year. Further political differences could also flare up again between Iran and Iraq, reaffirming Syria and Jordan as primary transit hubs, with Syria accounting for $4.8 billion (26.9% of all imports) and Jordan $1.3 billion (6.3%) of Iraq’s imports. Damascus has also just secured a lucrative contract to transport Iraqi grain imports and Syrian Trade Minister Amir al-Khalil in November said mutual trade agreements would be “activated”.

Other factors that will shape trade with Iraq could be the division of Iraq into three semi-autonomous regions for Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds out of the country’s 18 provinces, as put forward in the Iraq Federalism Bipartisan Amendment to the 2008 Defense Authorization Bill in the US.

Iraqi federalism would mean that Kuwait would have to move goods through a Shiite-controlled corridor into Iraq.

On the ground however, this is already the modus operandi. “There is an unwritten code, a Shia truck will not go to the Sunni side, and vice-versa,” said Killingsworth. And although security is better, she added, it is still an issue. “It’s an unknown. You don’t know what’s going on. Recently, two housing units our trucks were carrying vanished, just outside of Basra.”

But once the security situation improves — the ever-present gorilla in the room for Iraqi trade issues — it is expected that traffic will shift from Kuwait’s military border crossing to the commercial side.

“That crossing is untapped and we will see a huge increase in business for Kuwait once there is peace,” believes assistant managing director of Global Logistics Services and Warehousing in Kuwait, Ahmad Hammauda.

Signs that this is slowly underway are evident at the border, with the US Camp Naval Star at the Abdaly civilian border closed down in September. Nonetheless, despite the current geopolitical tensions affecting Iraq’s neighbors, Kuwait, with minimal industry or agriculture, has yet to develop its transport hub status or to sink petrodollars into Iraq.

Killingsworth maintains that “Kuwait’s potential is in financial investment, setting up malls and selling processed foodstuffs, as well as partnerships with the oil ministry. I’m sure M.H. Alshaya [a Gulf retailer for clothing giants H&M and Marks and Spencers] will be there. Kuwait has this over Iran.”

Imports into Iraq (2006)

Sources: European Commission, US Census Bureau (2007)

Iraqi Exports (2006)

Source: US Census Bureau, 2007

By sea, by air, or across the desert?

Political animosity between Kuwait and Iraq has been a prohibitive factor in fostering relations, particularly over their turbulent history, the 1990 invasion, and the widely held notion in Iraq and much of the Arab World that Kuwait is a geographical part of Iraq. However, unlike the hostility between neighbors in other parts of the region, Iraq does have a diplomatic presence in Kuwait and Iraqi politicians have visited the country since 2003.

Hammauda thinks, “The hope is to turn cross-border relations into what they were in the 1950s and 1960s, when Kuwaitis went shopping in southern Iraq, and Iraqis came to Kuwait.”

To turn this hope into a reality, in November 2007 Kuwait earmarked $60-80 billion for infrastructure and construction projects, including airport expansion, road extensions and a North-South GCC railway. One major project will be the $1.2 billion port in Bubiyan Island, northeast of the Kuwaiti mainland and close to the Shatt al-Arab waterway that winds inland to Basra.

“Kuwait should focus on logistics, that’s why Bubiyan is being developed and free zones are at the border. Bubiyan’s location is a gold mine for access to Iraq, Iran, and eastern Saudi Arabia,” according to Hammauda.

However, like the overhaul of Kuwait’s foreign investment laws, the Bubiyan port project has been on the drawing board for years. Foot dragging by a government complacent with high oil revenues has prevented Kuwait’s sea cargo sector from developing, with a public-private joint venture inked in 2005 that should have seen the port completed by 2008. Equally, the viability of the port depends on extensive dredging to remove the mud that is washed down from the Shatt al-Arab, a factor that has prevented deep sea vessels from docking, in addition to the ships sunk and scuttled during the 1980-88 Iran-Iraq War. The downed ships continue to block sections of the northern Gulf.

“Kuwait is not doing a very good job, there are hardly any shippers that come here, as mother vessels go to Dubai then to here,” said Hammauda.

Deciding on whether to use land or sea, he said his company chose the three- to four-day land crossing from Dubai rather than use feeder vessels from the Emirates due to the uncertainty of customs and loading times.

This means, however, that for goods to enter Kuwait or Iraq, they have to cross Saudi Arabia, which has its own associated problems.

“Our biggest problem, outside of security in Iraq, is customs, mainly in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait,” Hammauda believed. “Our second problem is over-protection. There are layers of bureaucracy to check that a container is not smuggling in a bottle of Jack Daniels. Instead of investing in technology, they are increasing bureaucracy,” he added.

There is also the rather paradoxical position of two of Iraq’s potentially biggest trade partners, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, building US-Mexico border style walls to keep Iraqis out (with Saudi’s slated to cost some $7 billion) while at the same time trying to boost bilateral trade. As Hammauda sees it, “Walls are going up in Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. For us, this will make it more difficult to do business.”

It is perhaps no wonder then that Iraqi-Kuwaiti trade is languishing while Dubai, several hundred kilometers from Iraq, is enticing Iraqi businessmen to the Jebel Ali Free Zone, and air cargo operators are opting for the Emirate rather than charter aircraft out of Kuwait, prompting Killingsworth to comment, “You wouldn’t think of it but Dubai is doing well out of Iraqi business.”

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
GCC

Emaar and the scramble for India

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

As if building the world’s tallest building and investing in projects throughout the MENA region wasn’t enough, Dubai-based property giant Emaar is rolling out its presence in the world’s second most populated country.

Through a 2005 joint venture with Indian development company MGF, Emaar-MGF has been involved in multi-billion dollar real estate projects from Delhi in the north to Hyderabad in the south, and plans to build in India the world’s largest mall and a Giorgio Armani luxury hotel.

But Emaar is not the only Gulf developer in the subcontinent seeking a slice of a burgeoning middle class with extra purchasing power. Nakheel, a subsidiary of Dubai World, is hot on Emaar’s heels, inking deals in 2007 worth $25 billion, along with Dubai-developer Damac Properties announcing they were to invest $5 billion in India over the next five years.

Other private Gulf investors are also to sink $5 billion into developments in a sector analysts forecast will surge by 700% in the next decade.

The sudden foray into India by Gulf investors is not confined to the likes of Emaar and Co. seeking to build real estate and malls. With transactions in the market expected to grow from $14 billion to $102 billion in the next 10 years, $150 billion to be spent on infrastructure, and Indian stock markets riding high — Bombay’s bourse rose above 20,000 points for the first time in late October — Gulf investors are scrambling to get in on India’s boom. Bahrain’s TAB Bank now has two funds in Indian bourses worth over $220 million and Dubai’s Abraaj Capital has a $250 million fund with Mumbai’s Sabre Capital.

Other developments are also afoot, with Dubai-based developer ETA Star Properties to develop a $923 million ‘infotech’ park in Chennai, and the Gulf Finance House to back the $395 million Energy City India, cementing Delhi’s energy links with the GCC.

And at the end of the year, RAKEEN, a property arm of the Ras Al-Khaimah government, formed a joint venture with India’s Trimex mineral group to spend $5 billion on developing residential, commercial and office space.

As Mohammed Ali Alabbar, chairman of Emaar Properties, told the press, “India is only an hour away from us, it is our true China and with the size, population, culture, economic policies, and growth that exist in India, it’s a great opportunity.”

Top 10 cities worldwide for office space

Bullish market

Property and mall developers are riding high on India’s 7% annual economic growth and a middle class that is expected to surge over 10-fold, from 50 to 587 million by 2025, according to a McKinsey Global Institute study, propelling 5% of the population in the middle class bracket to some 40%.

But with an economic boom as well as a rising population — 1.1 billion and growing — property prices are spiking. And the rush to develop real estate in India, as for any emerging market, is also about the scramble for land.

Mumbai is now the second most expensive city globally for office space, with rent rising 55% in the last year, and New Delhi in the eighth slot, up 34.4%. Such rising costs were reflected in a $10 billion Nakheel development last year, with land accounting for some 40% of the price tag. As a result, Emaar-MGF has embarked on a $12 billion pan-India program that will include special economic zones, hospitals, residential units, hotels and malls.

“We have a pan-India presence, and will have a presence in all 22 states through the land we have acquired and are in the process of developing that,” said Anupama Chopra, head of corporate communications at Emaar MGF Land Limited.

In bulging-at-the-seams cities like Bombay with 12.6 million people and Greater Delhi with over 14 million, developers are focusing on the tried-and-tested in the Gulf ‘integrated township’ model of residential and retail space.

“This is something that is prevalent in the rest of the world but not in India,” said Chopra.

Utilizing the same model as in the Gulf, most of Emaar’s architectural designs for Indian projects are the same, “trying to replicate here” what worked in Dubai, said Beedisha Chakrabarti, corporate communications manager at Emaar-MGF. One of the projects, in Gurgaon, a satellite city of Delhi, is to be called Palm Springs.

To raise funds for such projects, Emaar-MGF plans to sell a 10% stake this year through an IPO, which bankers suggest might raise some $1.5 billion. When Nakheel’s joint venture partner DLF listed on the Bombay stock exchange in July, $2.25 billion was raised in India’s biggest IPO, and shares have since gained 30% in the past six months.

Retail dreams

Part of the land Emaar and Co. are investing in land is for the growing retail market, which is expected to grow by 14 times by 2012 and retail chains to expand 25% a year, currently at only 5% of the market. Indicative of growth is the surge from 150,000 square meters of retail space and 30 malls back in 2001 to 2.5 million square meters of space and 230 malls last year. But compared to China, the country has some way to go to match its neighbors superpower retail space growth, which surged to 222 million square meters between 1995 and 2003.

Negating the retail space difference, however, will be Nakheel’s joint venture partner DLF’s 300,000  square meter Mall of India. And not to be outdone, Chakrabarti said Emaar wants to replicate the Dubai Mall in India. “We are looking at doing India’s biggest mall, as we cannot compete with our own product by having the biggest in the world,” she said.

However, at 583,000 square meter the Indian version will out trump Dubai Mall’s retail space of 520,000 square meter.

In India’s current boom climate — the dream of Dubai super-sized — it would therefore not seem overly farfetched to imagine Emaar building India’s tallest building some time soon. But what is more probable is the creation of development icons that have made the Gulf famous: offshore residential island projects, like the World and the Palm. “It’s on the drawing board somewhere but not right now,” said Chopra.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Levant

Difficult accession

by Jason J. Nash January 24, 2008
written by Jason J. Nash

As true love goes, any declared affirmation of affection between Turkey and Europe will always be best seen as a brief encounter, which fades as the affair fizzles.

When observed from France, Germany or even Austria, the main and maybe only value of even considering Turkey as a member of the Christian Club of Europe known as the European Union is based on a thought that goes “better we have them than someone else gets them.” That someone else falls into a choice of two. Ankara could for years, if not decades, be drawn under the influence of the resurgent Russians under the continued guidance of Vladimir Putin, who is destined to continue running the country in one guise or another.

The alternative, as the French and the Austrians believe quite possible but dare not openly say, is that a country composed of 95% Muslims and led by a self-confessed (mildly) Islamist Party could easily show its “true colors” as an Islamist country. Encouraging and helping its entry into the European Union, this blinkered and bigoted argument runs, is equivalent to arming one’s own execution squad.

Not only would the Christians of Europe be “threatened” by more than 70 million Muslim members of their own club, there would be a risk they could bring in with them other non-EU Muslims through the ruptured defenses. Besides, the naysayers continue, European Istanbul is not even 10% of the Turkish story. On the eastern side of the Bosporus lies a whole different world; of stricter Islamic observance, educational backwardness, suppressed and illiterate woman and ethnic conflict.

And all that is without mentioning other significant numbers. Although hyperinflation in Turkey is a fading memory and the economy has been booming for the past few years, the country still has a sizeable under-educated and under-achieving rural population, which would make similar baggage brought into the EU by countries such as Romania and Bulgaria pale into insignificance.

Growth remains strong

Even so, Turkey enters 2008 with strong growth rates, led by a generally popular government with a strong mandate. The economy grew by around 4.8% in 2007, only a touch below the most optimistic forecasts. After an unseemly face-off with the avowedly secular army, the Islamic-oriented AK Party, (AKP) of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan won the July election by a landslide, which was followed by Parliament’s election of Erdogan’s ally and former Islamist Abdullah Gul as president. The elections gave the AKP a mandate to continue its business-friendly and fiscally conservative economic program, as well as to pursue the elusive membership of the EU, a cause passionately and very publicly espoused by the AKP hierarchy.

The news regarding pursuit of EU membership is less rosy. On December 14, a statement by EU foreign ministers referred to Turkey without using the words “accession” and “membership”. It is widely thought that French President Nicholas Sarkozy was behind the decision to exorcise the words from the communiqué, which was submitted to December’s EU summit.

Perhaps mindful of the strength of the Armenian lobby in France, Sarkozy is a vocal opponent of Turkish membership, favoring instead an ill-defined “privileged partnership”. In response, Prime Minister Erdogan launched a broadside at the French President, accusing him of “hypocrisy” — Erdogan has said on several occasions that Sarkozy has affirmed his support for Turkey’s membership in private. “Sarkozy says one thing in our bilateral meetings and says something else behind our back,” Erdogan said. “This is not a becoming attitude in politics.” Possibly not, but a deep and wide chasm between public words and private deeds is not a phenomenon confined to French politicians.

In response to the perceived slight, Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan refused to meet his counterpart Bernard Kouchner for bilateral discussions when in Paris for a meeting of donors to the Palestinian territories. Nonetheless, Erdogan has said that nothing will stand in the way of Turkish accession. Whether these words can be matched by reality is open to question. Another question is also increasingly being asked. How long will the Turkish people retain their own enthusiasm for European accession in the face of insulting snubs, obstructions and delays? Erdogan could soon find himself championing a cause in which his citizens — and voters — have long since lost interest.

The omission in the communiqué of specific references to Turkey’s potential future EU membership may not have much significance in itself. The heat and light of this particular dispute with Sarkozy may well soon die down. Much more important are the practicalities dating from the previous year which left Turkey feeling ambushed.

Eight “chapters” or areas of negotiation and harmonization with the EU that Turkey must complete before it can become a member were suspended in December 2006 over Turkey’s refusal to allow ships from the Republic of Cyprus, an EU member, into its ports. The chapters remain suspended and the Turkish government still looks unlikely to budge — while the Cypriot government refuses to countenance reunification with the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (recognized by Turkey alone), which was one of the preconditions for its own membership. As long as hardliner Tassos Papadopoulos remains president, the Cypriot government is also unlikely to seek rapprochement or compromise.

Furthermore, focusing on Sarkozy’s role in watering down the December communiqué is convenient but misses the bigger picture. He is, after all, not the only leader to question the wisdom of Turkish membership: German Chancellor Angela Merkel is, at best, deeply skeptical. Austria has long opposed membership, and current Chancellor Alfred Gusenbauer said in 2005 that “Turkey in the EU would mean the end of the EU, if that does not happen before anyway,” and echoes Sarkozy’s “privileged partnership” line.

Invasion of northern Iraq receded

If there is a glimmer of good news, it is that the threat of a large-scale Turkish invasion of northern Iraq seems to have receded. Throughout the autumn, Turkish troops were massing on the border with Turkey’s neighbor, threatening to launch an attack to root out Kurdish fighters from the Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK) said to be sheltering in the Iraqi mountains. A full-scale incursion would have made the re-opening of negotiations with the EU an even more distant prospect. However, should the PKK decide to launch more attacks on Turkish targets to boost its profile, the pressure on Erdogan, who is thought to personally oppose a full-scale incursion, could become too heavy to fend off.

Finally, the opposition of European politicians to Turkey’s membership, explicit or otherwise, has to an extent become a self-fulfilling prophecy. The more the EU stalls and dissembles, for fair reasons or otherwise, the more the Turkish people turn against the idea of membership altogether. Retaining their support may become increasingly difficult. And while the AKP leadership appears genuinely determined to bring Turkey into the EU, the party as a whole may prefer closer ties with the Middle East. In fact, the government itself has been willing to look elsewhere for friends. It has made energy deals with Iran — a pariah in Western eyes — and made overtures to an increasingly assertive Russia.

Andrew Mango wrote almost a decade ago that, where Turkey was concerned, there was a need of “an enlargement of the European mind.” Not too much has changed since then and some European politicians should perhaps be careful what they wish for. Their vacillation towards Turkey may soon put them in the position of feeling damned if they do and being damned if they don’t.

Jason J. Nash is head of research at the Oxford Business Group.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Levant

Economic Zones

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

Jordan is setting out its stall as an industrial center in the Middle East, from which companies will have privileged access to export markets and a favorable business climate. To this end, it is increasing the number of new economic zones and industrial parks, following the success of the Aqaba Special Economic Zone (ASEZ). These developments should encourage further investments, thereby creating jobs for Jordan’s growing population and tackling high unemployment in poorer areas.

The ASEZ has to a large extent been a flagship for Jordan’s economic development and a model for further economic zones. The zone was launched in 2001 and offers a range of tax and tariff incentives to businesses, as well as a more favorable repatriation and operating regulatory environment. The 375 sq km zone drew in $8 billion worth of investment in its first five years, an amount that officials rather conservatively estimate will increase to $22 billion by 2020.

The flagship is now being joined by other zones with the same aim of stimulating investment, particularly in added-value export and high-tech sectors.

The largest of these is Al-Mushatta Industrial City, near Amman’s Queen Alia Airport, which has completed its first stage of development. It is unusual in that it is an entirely private project, owned by Investors & Eastern Arab for Industrial and Real Estate Investments (IEAI). Some 40% of the leasable space at Al-Mushatta has already been allocated. Jordan Ta’ameer Holding, Medicare for Medical Solutions, JOFCO Fire Fighting & Safety Equipment Certified Manufacturer, DHL and Elba House, which makes prefabricated houses and large vehicles, have reserved space.

Qualified industrial zones

Al-Mushatta has been designated a qualified industrial zone (QIZ), one of 10 industrial parks which are allowed quota-free access to the US market. The US has been Jordan’s primary export market since 2003, two years after Jordan became the first Arab country to sign an FTA with the Americans. There are QIZs located in Amman, Irbid and Zarqa which can export quota and duty-free to the US if the products in question meet the “laws of origin” insisted on by the American government. These stipulate that at least 35% of the value of the product must originate from the Jordanian QIZ, the Palestinian Territories or Israel, and at least 8% of the contents is by an Israeli manufacturer.

Mohammed Turk, CEO of IEAI, thinks that with the new SEZ and QIZ projects, “Jordan has the ability to establish itself as an export base for medium to high end products, particularly for the growing US market.”

While the private sector is developing in Al-Mushatta, there are also a number of state economic zone projects underway around the country. Many of these are designed to stimulate economic activity and promote job creation in less prosperous regions. Jordan suffers from persistently high unemployment, with official figures of around 15% and unofficial ones of up to 30%. Some areas have unemployment rates as high as 70%.

The World Bank and the Jordanian government have identified 20 “poverty pockets”, where more than 400,000 people live in areas where unemployment officially exceeds 25%. With a fast-growing population and the influx of Iraqi refugees, job creation is a pressing priority for the government. This is where the authorities believe that economic zones can come into their own.

One such public project is the $750 million King Hussein bin Talal Economic Zone in Mafraq, in the northeast. This is archetypal of the projects that the government wishes to create now. While Aqaba is the country’s second city, towns like Mafraq are considerably smaller and less well-known. The zone in Mafraq alone is forecast to provide around 32,000 jobs on completion, an important boost to the region.

Similarly, in Tafileh, the poorest governorate in the country, the Tafileh Industrial Estate is under construction, with the aim of creating up to 2,000 jobs. The project is being overseen by Jordan Industrial Estates Corporation (JIEC), a semi-governmental organization which says that zones it operates have created more than 41,000 jobs so far. JIEC has other projects in Zarqa and Madaba.

Economic zones are not without their critics. Some say that they distort markets unnecessarily, and that in many of the areas there is little reason for a large amount of economic activity, and that population mobility would be a more laudable goal. Certainly, underemployment for the sake of cutting jobless figures would be counterproductive. However, given the jobs they have created thus far, and the realistic limits of expanding lively centers such as Aqaba and Amman, the zones are likely to play an important role in Jordan’s regional development and job creation.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Levant

Taking on the art world

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

Syria’s artistic pedigree has long been admired — when the Mongol ruler Tamerlane conquered Damascus in 1401, he enslaved the city’s famed artisans and marched them back to his capital Samarkand. Given the country’s riches of Islamic art, antiquities and carpets, it’s hardly surprising that modern and contemporary art has always struggled for recognition. Modern art in Syria is, however, finally beginning to steal the spotlight. A wave of new galleries promoting modern and contemporary works have sprouted in the country’s main cities in the past few years and Syrian artists are quickly cementing a reputation as among the most collectable in the Middle East.

Prices of 20th century Syrian art have hit record highs in recent years, with the value of some modern works rising five-fold in the past two years alone. The works of deceased 20th century Syrian artists Nasser Chaura (1920-1992), Louay Kayyali (1922-1978), Fateh al-Moudarres (1922-1999), Mahmoud Hammad (1923-1988) and Abdul-Latif Smoudi (1948-2005) have all had strong showings in recent international auctions, doubling and tripling pre-sale estimates. At the same time, living Syrian artists including Safwan Dahoul, Sabhan Adam, Abdullah Murad and Khaled al-Saai are all commanding ever increasing prices.

“Really, you could describe the market akin to something like the gold rush,” Yazan al-Atassi, from Atassi Galley in Damascus, said. “A lot of people have suddenly become interested in Syrian art and art from the Middle East in general. We’re taking phone calls and e-mails from all over the world.”

Middle East art en vogue

A new passion for modern and contemporary art in Syria — and the impressive dollars it is commanding — mirrors a similar trend throughout the Middle East. The depth of the region’s 20th century art market has attracted the attention of the world’s two most prestigious auction houses, Christie’s and Sotheby’s. Both have launched dedicated auctions of modern and contemporary Middle Eastern art. In 2005, Christie’s became the first major auction house to open an office in the Middle East, while Bonhams, the top second-tier international auction house, is in the process of setting up shop in Dubai.

Fuelled by cash rich Gulf residents looking for investment opportunities, contemporary Middle Eastern art auctions continue to break records each time they are held. The strength of the market was best illustrated by the sale of “Yek Donia” by in-demand Iranian artist Farhad Moshiri. The work, which depicts a map of the world executed in thousands of crystals, was expected to fetch between $60,000 and $80,000. When the hammer finally fell it took $601,000.

Khaled Samawi, owner of Ayyam gallery in Damascus, said Middle Eastern art — Syrian art in particular — has long been undervalued and lacked proper marketing and representation. The entrance of international auction houses has finally given the region a central forum in which to test prices. “Syrian art and art from the Middle East has been closed, shut off from the international market,” Samawi said. “Before Christie’s and Sotheby’s started auctions the art market was very localized. Now the Middle East has a central market for art and we are finding out what the real price is. I don’t like to say we are seeing high prices — we are seeing a devalued commodity being floated and its true value emerging.”

The first major modern and contemporary Arab and Iranian art auction was organized by Christie’s in May 2006. The $2.2 million in sales almost tripled pre-sale expectations and heralded a new area for modern art in the region. The auction’s highpoint was the sale of Moustafa’s “Where the Two Oceans Meet” (Variant No 3) which sold to a private buyer for $284,800, the highest sale price obtained by an Arab artist at the time. Deceased Syrian artists Kayyali, Moudarres and Hammad received posthumous recognition, with three works by Kayyali selling for an average price of $40,000, while Hammad’s painting “Allah Nur al-Samawat” fetched $36,000.

Eight month’s later the auction house took more than $4 million in sales from a comparable selection of Arab works. Syrian artists were again heavily represented, with 18 works by the country’s artists going under the hammer for $571,200. Dahoul’s painting “Rêve” fetched $38,400, while Murad, one of Syria’s best known contemporary abstract artists, saw his arabesque-style “Night” sell for $21,000. An untitled painting by Fadi Yazigi and “Box” by Youssef Abdelke both sold for $12,000 each.

Breaking world records

Christie’s third sale last October established 62 new world records

and generated a jaw-dropping $15,235,725 in sales. The sale of Moustafa’s “Qur’anic Polyptych of Nine Panels” for $657,000, the highest price ever achieved for a painting by an Arab artist, stole headlines. The result more than doubled the previous record for any work by an Arab artist, also set by Moustafa. Syrian artists continued to cement their reputation as among the most sought after in the Middle East. Leading the way was the $250,000 sale of “Head” by the German-based Bachi, making it the most expensive work by a 20th century Syrian artist and more than doubling Christie’s pre-sale estimate. Six paintings by Moudarres and Kayyali collectively sold for $403,750. The top-selling work from the collection was Moudarres’ “The Last Supper” which sold for $145,000, nearly three times the low estimate. Smoudi’s “Soul of the East” fetched $70,000.

Sotheby’s entered the market in the same month, generating $3.14 million in sales from an auction in London, more than $1 million in excess of the high pre-sale estimate. The highpoint of the auction was the $216,000 sale of Iranian artist Mohammad Ehsai’s “Oo Bakhshandeh Ast,” close to three times the pre-sale low estimate. Other major sales were Kayyali’s “Shoeshine Boy” for $80,000 and al-Saai’s “Samarkand” for $45,000, both works selling for twice the high pre-sale estimate. Dahoul’s “Rêve” again went under the hammer, selling for $70,000, close to double the price it fetched when it was auctioned eight months earlier.

“Sotheby’s first dedicated sale was a tremendous success and exceeded all our expectations,” Sotheby’s art specialist Lina Lazzar said. “It represents a very exciting start for modern and contemporary Arab and Iranian art. Sotheby’s sees this area of the market as relatively young and becoming more international. We expect to witness enormous growth over the coming years.”

It’s a sentiment echoed by others working in the industry. Samawi expects price increases of 50% annually over the next three to four years. He draws similarities between the Middle East’s modern art market and that of India’s. “The big auction houses like Christie’s became involved in Indian art around seven years ago and today Indian art is up 30-fold,” Samawi said. “Christie’s became involved in Middle Eastern art a year-and-a-half ago and we are up five-fold. We are tracking a similar course and the collectors with petrol dollars, the collectors with real estate dollars, are not going anywhere.”

The region’s high liquidity is no doubt pushing prices higher. But oil booms are nothing new. While traditional Islamic art and collectables such as antiques and carpets have always been highly prized, many see a new appreciation for modern and contemporary art emerging, along with a new breed of investor willing to spend money on it. “There is a lot more interest and a lot more respect for modern art among Syrians,” Mustafa Ali, artist and owner of Mustafa Ali Gallery in the old city of Damascus, said. “This is a trend we are witnessing not just in Syria, there is a new appreciation emerging throughout the region and throughout the world.”

At the same time, the intense global focus on the region following the 9/11 attacks is trickling down into the region’s arts community. “More and more people are focusing on Syria and the Middle East in general and I think this makes people more curious about what comes out of Syria and the region in general,” al-Atassi said. “People are asking, what do their artists have to say?”

All of which bodes well for the region’s young artists. “Seeing this trend, perhaps more young artists will decide to devote their professional life to their art, instead of taking a monthly salary as a graphic designer or something else,” Samawi said. “That can only be good for art.”

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Lebanon

Connecting rural areas

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

One of the greatest complaints by Lebanese living outside Greater Beirut is that they are left out of many development plans. Especially in the IT sector most attention is focused on Beirut where the lion’s share of action normally takes place. Rural areas, however, are left out and not thought of as places where information technology or connectivity means much. But these days this is changing, as a small micro financing program is under way. Al-Majmoua — The Lebanese Association for Development has received a $150,000 grant from the International Executive Service Corps (IESC) to support rural area entrepreneurs in the ICT sector.

This is the first time a microfinance program is aimed at businesses in IT in rural communities, according to Mahmoud Elzein, deputy country director of IESC. “Since IT businesses in rural areas are small, there are many obstacles for them to get financing through a bank whereas microfinance is much more appropriate for them.”

The program provides short-term loans of up to $15,000 to micro and small business entrepreneurs to secure the capital needed to start, as well as for established businesses to expand. The interest rates are subsidized, leaving the borrower with a 1% interest rate and the administration and other fees are waived. “The loans are dependent on the entrepreneurial spirit and a viable business plan,” said Mohammed Bensouda, country director of IESC.

To further encourage interest in the loans, Al-Majmoua has limited the loan guarantees to business capital and excluding personal assets and mortgages. “We wanted the guarantee to be flexible to encourage start-ups to take loans, so that it’s not a barrier,” said Alia Farhat, business development manager at Al-Majmoua.

Value-added program

“If it is a new client we might ask for fixed-asset collateral, which would mean if they were using the loan to buy computers, Al-Majmoua would then own the computers or office equipment during the term of the loan. We don’t go into mortgages or hold personal collateral.”

Borrowers may also get added value of the loan program through technical assistance and training from IESC. The organization already provides ICT-training programs in many rural areas and announced its support and provision of expertise to borrowers. As Bensouda pointed out, “In our program we have several local volunteer experts to assist in rural centers.”

IESC has brought several other ICT initiatives to rural areas, such as affordable wireless ICT access to 20 areas through the establishment of wireless internet service providers (WISPs) and technical training for entrepreneurs. In addition, it announced an e-tourism initiative for rural tourism establishments through internet aggregators.

In just under three months the program has lent to over 35 entrepreneurs in the South, the Bekaa and northern Lebanon. The majority of business start-ups have focused on opening internet cafés and connectivity centers.

The program is sustained through the recycling of funds as loans are paid off and reused for new lending schemes to other IT businesses. “After five years, we would have almost 25% extra capital to use in the future,” said Farhat.

For Ali Nazar, mayor of Arabsalim in the Nabatieh region, one of the major difficulties his village faces is the lack of job opportunities. According to USAID figures, unemployment and underemployment in rural Lebanon is estimated at 25%. While the program is rather small in its range and scope, Nazar is excited about the job creation possibilities as well as the opportunity to keep families connected to their children abroad via the expanded internet centers. Bensouda concurred, “The great part about it is that the program brings greater connectivity to these areas in that the local community will go to these places and use their facilities.”

At a recent press conference in Saida on the micro financing program, one of the recipients told the audience about how she, as a widow in South Lebanon with four children, was able to get a loan and open an internet shop, and is now supporting her family through the business. The loan paid for the computers and also allowed her to hire an additional employee to work in the evenings. “It’s very small scale but it adds up and makes a difference,” commented Farhat.

This program is operated in conjunction with other micro-lending efforts by Al-Majmoua, which in 2006 boasted a loan portfolio of $7 million and over 8,500 beneficiaries all over Lebanon. Since its foundation in 1994, Al-Majmoua has dispersed over $75 million through 80,000 loans. Their 2006 distribution included 37% for services and 44% for trade. Al-Majmoua began operations as the micro-credit arm of Save the Children Lebanon. Since then, it has grown considerably and now has eight offices throughout Lebanon providing not only financial services but also entrepreneur training and exhibition space. Two years ago Al-Majmoua began offering a variety of business development services focusing on gender and women’s economic empowerment.

As Bensouda summarized it, “At the end of the day, this program is about job and wealth creation for people in rural areas.”

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Lebanon

Prospects for prosperity?

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

The ongoing political instability in Lebanon has taken an economic toll on the embattled nation, but it seems that foreign companies in the Mediterranean country have not been dissuaded. The recent removal of the barricades opposite the downtown branch of Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Megastore in Beirut not only brought improved access for shoppers, but also an announcement that the company foresees expansion in the near future.

The major international electronics brand Sony has beat them to the mark, however, with their new 170 square meter Sony World showroom in the ABC Ashrafieh Mall. This showroom comes in addition to the previously established Hamra branch. Ziad Asmar, responsible for Sony at Fattal Holding, the sole distributor of the brand in Lebanon, said that despite the current situation Sony saw growth this year in Lebanon. He suggested that an “expanding line-up of products” has helped the brand stay competitive. He also noted that Sony caters to “financially secure customers, meaning that people delay rather than cancel their purchases.”

Other foreign product lines in Lebanon have also been expanded or will do so in the near future. AZElectronics has opened a 400 square meter store in Sami Solh Avenue to exclusively showcase their Whirlpool and Phillips home appliances. They also expect to open another store in Kaslik in early 2008. Commenting on the difficulties in the country, the chairman of AZElectronics, Andre Zalum, said, “Here in Lebanon, we are used to instability. Life goes on and so does business.” He added that profits remained stable from 2006 to 2007 and that the overall volume of sales has increased. Due to the weak dollar the company has been trying to source products from the United States and the Far East as they are now cheaper than goods from Europe.

Total number of registered foreign companies

Source: Lebanese Ministry of Economy and Trade

Anticipation and expansion

The German automaker Volkswagen has joined the expansion trend as well with their new 800 square meter showroom on the Dora Highway. Inaugurated in October 2007, the new building makes for a larger, flashier venue than the previous structure. The sales manager at Volkswagen, Gergi el-Murr, stated, “Volkswagen believes in Lebanon and expects further expansion in the future.” He said that despite the instability, business has been stable for the past three years and that growth is anticipated in 2008.

But it’s not just previously established foreign products that see a future in Lebanon. According to a report from the Lebanese Ministry of Economy and Trade, 44 foreign companies registered to do business in Lebanon in 2007. That’s up from a wartime low of 34 in 2006 and a year-on-year growth of 29%. It should be noted, however, that this growth only brings the foreign company registration rate back to its pre-July War levels. Twenty-six of the companies are non-Arab and many of those are from the United States and Europe, including the American television news station NBC News and the UK airline British Midland International (BMI).

The Lebanon route came to BMI as part of a packaged take-over of 17 destinations, according to BMI sales manager Maria Sabbah. “We have daily flights from London to Beirut, which is more than any local carrier.” She explained BMI optimism over the deal, saying “this proves that we have faith in Lebanon. We are excited about expanding into the Middle East and Lebanon is high on our priority list.”

While sellers of locally produced products quietly wait for their leaders to usher in the next phase of Lebanon’s never-ending political drama, foreign product vendors and companies have adopted a somewhat more optimistic approach. They seem to speak with a unified voice: Business must go on.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Office ArchitectureSpecial Section

Executive health

by Executive Staff January 24, 2008
written by Executive Staff

Executives and office workers are suffering from work-related health problems. Sitting at desks for extended periods of time, frequent travel, in-between-meals, junk food and minimal exercise are taking their toll.

Recently, health facilities in Lebanon responded to this problem with programs specifically designed for corporate executives and management, and nutritionists are developing special meal packages.

Work-related health problems can manifest themselves in a myriad of ways. Some of the most common complaints are neck pain, backache and eye strain, all mostly from 8-plus hours of staring at computer screens and slouching in chairs. And then there’s the so-called “killer” — stress — which can lead to more serious health concerns like heart disease, heart attacks, digestive disorders, autoimmune diseases and more.

Contributing to the problem, of course, are hectic work schedules. Most executives and businessmen are reluctant to schedule appointments for check-ups, which are usually done during the workday and often involve lengthy waits in doctors’ offices. As a result of this, visits to the doctor are generally put off until obvious symptoms show up, according to Dr. Nabil Nassar, director of the American University Hospital (AUH) Executive Health Program. To address the issue of time AUH set up the Executive Health Program as a way to expedite check-ups and preventative tests for busy executives and corporate managers.

The AUH program opened in 2004 and had immediate success with mainly Gulf and Lebanese expatriate clientele. Since the hospital is a non-profit organization there is minimal press about the program, save a description in Middle East Airlines’ in-flight magazine Cedar Wings. The aim of the Executive Health program is patient-focused. “Our main focus is on the executive and his personal needs,” Nassar pointed out. After an analysis of the patient’s existing health, the doctors run a number of patient-specific tests, which are followed by a briefing and recommendations for future health care, like nutrition and exercise guidelines. “The main idea is that every program is personalized, from the basics like gender, age and family history, to anything else that may show up.”

The program

The program essentially consists of a number of packages, each designed to address the specific needs of the individual patient. Prior to scheduling an appointment, the executive is asked to complete a confidential medical questionnaire, which is then reviewed by an executive health physician who will recommend an appropriate package. These differ on the number and type of tests required. A patient with a family history of heart disease, for example, would be advised to take a number of cardiologic exams in addition to basic screening tests. The patient (‘client’ might be more appropriate) then books an appointment with the hospital, which means one or, maximum, two nights in the program’s Executive Suite, which comes equipped with internet service so the executive can send and receive work-related emails, a television with satellite, a private bathroom, and a mini bar stocked with non-alcoholic drinks and healthy snacks. Indeed, the executive treatment begins upon arrival, with a quick call to the program’s office so that an elevator can be reserved and sent down for the client.

After the series of tests and checkups, the executive is offered a choice of additional services, some of them catering to the region’s trends and tastes. “For example,” said  Nassar, “one woman asked and was able to have a plastic surgery procedure done through our program as well.”

Some out-of-town clients will even have the program book hotels for them. It is in this sense the AUH program shows its Lebanese side. While the number of clients has declined due to the July War of 2006 and the unsteady political situation, the primary selling point, even with a university hospital like AUH, is providing outstanding service coupled with a reputable hospital and relying on the Lebanese tourism sector. Many of the clients are Gulf executives who swing by while on their way up to Faraya’s snow with their families. News of the program has largely spread through word-of-mouth, with high-up executives from international companies booking appointments after hearing about it through colleagues. One such company (the name of which has been withheld for confidentiality) had a manager book appointments for all of its employees. “Absenteeism from work is becoming a problem, and this particular manager found it to be more cost-effective to invest in preventative health,” explained Nassar.

So how much does an appointment at AUH’s Executive Program cost? Given the personalized nature of the program, the final bill can run from $1,000 to $4,000, with additional costs for extra procedures.

Clemenceau’s Medical Center (CMC) also offers a similar program, the Premiere Executive Health Check. Here, clients who book appointments are also promised strict confidentiality, and sign up for one full day containing several health care screenings, thereby accommodating overloaded work schedules. Clemenceau’s program is arguably more posh than AUH’s, with valet parking and dinner with a spouse included in the package. 

Beirut’s St. Georges Hospital also offers an Executive Medical Health Assessment Package, which, according to director Dimitri Haddad, is a “complete package of visits and checkups.” At St. Georges, clients will go to a preliminary appointment with a family physician, and then have the option of a range of personalized health tests, with an emphasis on work-related risks, like cardiologic, pulmonary, and vision tests. The St. Georges package can cost anywhere from $600-$1,000, again depending upon the individual and health needs.

Dietary options

The three hospital programs all have an emphasis on preventative medicine. Following their allopathic methods, the standard procedure is to screen for any unseen symptoms and then recommend either medicine or surgery. Nutritional guidelines are offered, but are not an integral part of any of the programs.

There are, however, options for the health-conscious on-the-go executive. One of these is NutriFit, a company consisting of dieticians and cooks who offer a broad-range of culinary and delivery choices for busy office workers.

NutriFit’s services begin with a one hour consultation with a dietician to assess the quantity of fat present in the client’s body, followed by weighing, measuring, and checking bone mass. “The primary concern is to lose or to maintain weight,” said NutriFit dietician Zeina Scheib. “Most of our clients are single men with long working hours. They eat out a lot and when they’re home they don’t like to cook. Their only options are delivery, which is full of fat, and they often don’t have time to exercise.” NutriFit’s aim, therefore, is to provide healthy options for lunch, and all other meals if the client requests, provided in the form of full-day catering. Healthy breakfasts, lunches and dinners will all be delivered to the client in the morning, eliminating the need for even thinking about what to eat and and, more importantly, what to avoid. NutriFit tries to diversify and, according to Scheib, meals are as close to “regular” as possible, while avoiding added sugar and anything fried. A typical meal might be cheese manakish with snacks of fruit and sugar-free cake, a Lebanese home-cooked lunch platter like loubiya, and a dinner of healthy pizza. Another choice is the Tailor Made Diet, which “respects each person’s nutritional requirements and daily caloric expenditure.” After a thorough consultation, the dietician creates a diet suitable for busy executives to follow, including restaurant order recommendations for business lunches. So far, feedback has been positive, with at least 50% of the clients being busy executives.

There are two other aspects of office-related health problems that remain to be fully addressed in Lebanon, although their increasing popularity and incorporation in the American corporate world might mean replication in the Middle East. The first is ergonomics, the science of the study of the human body relative to office objects, like desks and chairs. Ergonomics is derived from the Greek words ergon meaning work and nomos meaning natural laws. Ergonomics is typically used by companies as a way to design tasks and work areas to maximize the efficiency and quality of employees’ work. It is an applied science that focuses on equipment design to maximize productivity by reducing fatigue and discomfort. An ergonomist will come into an office and inspect employees as they sit at their desks. He or she will then measure the distances between elbows and keyboard, computer monitor to eye level, and the amount of bend in the knees from the floor to the chair. These will all be adjusted to support the body’s needs. Ergonomists can greatly enhance work environments by dealing with and preventing common office-related ailments like carpal tunnel syndrome and chronic neck, back and shoulder pain, and also offer ergonomic keyboards and chairs to preventive recurrence of health problems.

The inner dimension

After an executive is medically screened, well-fed and ergonomically aligned, perhaps the final step is attending to one’s inner dimension. Recently, companies and individuals are turning to ancient sciences like yoga and Sufism, now made palatable to the Western mindset through office-sponsored workshops and retreats. One such yogic science is the ancient practice of meditation and chanting found in Isha yoga practices. These practices, or kriyas, are based on the science of locating and distributing stale or suppressed energies within the body. Like Tai Chi and acupuncture, kriyas remind the individual of his or her inner strength, especially when confronted with the stresses of the corporate world. Whether holistic, allopathic, nutritional or ergonomic, executives now have a variety of options that help them to invest in their own bodies and minds as well.

January 24, 2008 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • …
  • 549
  • 550
  • 551
  • 552
  • 553
  • …
  • 693

Latest Cover

About us

Since its first edition emerged on the newsstands in 1999, Executive Magazine has been dedicated to providing its readers with the most up-to-date local and regional business news. Executive is a monthly business magazine that offers readers in-depth analyses on the Lebanese world of commerce, covering all the major sectors – from banking, finance, and insurance to technology, tourism, hospitality, media, and retail.

  • Donate
  • Our Purpose
  • Contact Us

Sign up for our newsletter

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • Linkedin
    • Youtube
    Executive Magazine
    • ISSUES
      • Current Issue
      • Past issues
    • BUSINESS
    • ECONOMICS & POLICY
    • OPINION
    • SPECIAL REPORTS
    • EXECUTIVE TALKS
    • MOVEMENTS
      • Change the image
      • Cannes lions
      • Transparency & accountability
      • ECONOMIC ROADMAP
      • Say No to Corruption
      • The Lebanon media development initiative
      • LPSN Policy Asks
      • Advocating the preservation of deposits
    • JOIN US
      • Join our movement
      • Attend our events
      • Receive updates
      • Connect with us
    • DONATE